art
Street Fighter IV Box Art: Which Is Worse?
Posted by Stuart Houghton at 8:40 AM on September 24, 2008
Oh, come on Capcom - you can do better than this, surely?
This dodgy diptych of box art features a slightly too muscular Chun Li (c'mon she may be a strong lass, but as drawn here she could throw shot at the Moscow Olympics) a Ryu who looks like he is trying to do long division in his head and typography that looks like the artist was doodling band logos during double geography.
If you look closely, you will see that Ken is striking exactly the same pose (even down to the spray of mud at his heels) when fighting both Chun Li and Ryu at the bottom of their boxes.
Ryu, incidentally, is demonstrating an ancient fighting technique, known in the East as Goatse Hadouken.
[Thanks to MarkMan for the tip]

Comments (AU Comments · US Comments)
There are currently no AU comments for this post.
tralfaz23
Posted 9:12 AM 24/9/08
why didnt they just get udon to do the cover?
tralfaz23
smuai
Posted 9:11 AM 24/9/08
they're not terrible, but they're not okay... what bothers me most is how big ken is in proportion to chun-li/ryu at the bottom of the cover... even though that's the angle/perspective, it still looks (as we say in the ghetto) "deflicted".
smuai
quen
Posted 9:11 AM 24/9/08
@FrigidAir44: Leaving the cloud characters subtle works pretty well, actually. If they were coloured and more obvious, you'd have a bland mess. Instead you have a nice clear focus on a single striking character, with a little subtle detail in the background to make it more interesting.
Also I'm amused at the 'wasted space' concept (somebody else said it too). Good visual design does not consist of filling every square millimetre with artwork. Whitespace isn't wasted space. [That may not have been what you meant, it just came across that way.]
I think the Chun Li cover looks reasonably decent. The Ryu one, not so much (goatse or not, his hands just look like a confused mess). Neither are exactly going to blow anyone's mind but they're not terrible.
quen
Mahale
Posted 9:10 AM 24/9/08
just once I'd like someone else on the cover.
Why oh why can't they like release a cover for each character? I'd buy the hell out of a Vega (American Vega I mean the one with the mask) cover.
Mahale
Ashurahori
Posted 9:10 AM 24/9/08
@Netnavi: They disenvoweled me yesterday for a simple question on the cover contest, with no explanation when I asked. I guess the rules are "do anything not to get in the bad side of the editors".
Although they might diselvowel this reply as well.
Ashurahori
Primus30
Posted 9:09 AM 24/9/08
Wtf, I really don't see what's wrong with the box arts.
Primus30
Seinosuke
Posted 9:08 AM 24/9/08
@Blates-: They said it in the article...
Seinosuke
Ashurahori
Posted 9:07 AM 24/9/08
How is Chun Li the slightest bit muscular? I don't see any excess muscles, she looks pretty normal to me.
Ashurahori
ShaggE
Posted 9:04 AM 24/9/08
@Netnavi: To be fair, Goatse isn't technically a chan meme.
ShaggE
muckamuck
Posted 9:03 AM 24/9/08
Well, at least Ryu and Ken haven't been photoshopped onto each of Chun-Li's fists.
Activison, here's looking at you.
muckamuck
banana_ridah
Posted 9:02 AM 24/9/08
Seriously, this is the final box art? WTF?
banana_ridah
Shiningmonk_e
Posted 9:00 AM 24/9/08
Upon closer examination at the actual site the expression on Ryu's face isn't nearly as bad.
Shiningmonk_e
Netnavi
Posted 8:59 AM 24/9/08
Come on guys , you disemvowel guys here for chan comments all the time and use a widely used meme from the chans? I'm sure it's spread out to other parts by now but I'm sure most would know it from the chan sites.
Oh well, it's your website and I don't use memes in my typing (though sometimes it's tempting) I leave that kind of tom-foolery over there. *walks of waving my cane in the air*
Seriously though (on topic) I think that the Ryu one should be used. Isn't he the main character? Unless the story in it is focused on Chun Li it should be Ryu, no matter how cheesy the cover looks. I don't even think it needs character art on the screen. Super SF 2 just had the title with a brickwall background. A little 90's but it worked and the game was where your attention was at anyway. This will be the same.
Still getting used to how the commenting system works. Once you click on classic and submit it reverts back to the new format. A little confusing.
Netnavi
jasoncourt
Posted 8:59 AM 24/9/08
So I just wanted to admit that I am an idiot because I thought this was going to be a downloadable game. Oops. Also this game art isn't so appealing, although it does represent the in-game character art.
jasoncourt
MarkMan
Posted 8:59 AM 24/9/08
Chun Li <3
MarkMan
-EDGE-
Posted 8:59 AM 24/9/08
Well it's no "tub girl" but then again what is, huh Kotaku? (*wink, wink, nudge, nudge*).
But yeah, that box art is pretty weak. I used to love some of the SF arcade cabinet art, so indeed they can do much better! NOW DOO EEET!
-EDGE-
Yam
Posted 8:58 AM 24/9/08
We all have seen what Capcom can do and this is simply unacceptable.
Capcom, I am still disappointed at you about the character design of this game!!
Yam
Demonbird
Posted 8:58 AM 24/9/08
=/
Honestly, pathetic.
Capcom,
Please get Udon to do your box art for you since it seems you are incapable.
Love,
Everyone with eyes.
Demonbird
Communist_Gamer
Posted 8:56 AM 24/9/08
Ok ok we've had ENOUGH defication jokes, can we stop now?
Communist_Gamer
FrigidAir44
Posted 8:56 AM 24/9/08
Chun-Li one is better... though its not saying much. I thought a lot of space was wasted as well till I looked closely...
The clouds have the faces of the cast of the game. However the picture is "epic fail" as you don't notice that immediately.
Lame.
FrigidAir44
y2kenjination
Posted 8:56 AM 24/9/08
My beauty Chun graces the U.S. cover. HALLELUJAH! Sex to teh eyes. D:
y2kenjination
namesRhard
Posted 8:55 AM 24/9/08
The chun li is better, whether she deserves to be the central image or not
namesRhard
lantus
Posted 8:53 AM 24/9/08
If I had to pick, I'd say the Chun Li cover is much better, but I don't really care for either.
lantus
Fangeh
Posted 8:53 AM 24/9/08
At least Chun Li doesn't have mutant thumbs. And I didn't notice the characters in the clouds at all until Mit pointed them out.
Fangeh
firstworldman
Posted 8:53 AM 24/9/08
I would try and use the characters to create more depth by making them larger and slightly covering up the logo. the logo doesn't hurt my eyes too bad. I think Chun-li is at her usual strength. I'm pretty sure she could have competed in the Moscow Olympics (not sure what you meant by that). Over all, it needs a little more work.
firstworldman
Blates-
Posted 8:52 AM 24/9/08
@Communist_Gamer:
COMMENT OF THE WEEK <3
Blates-
jookie
Posted 8:52 AM 24/9/08
I like the Chunli one better.
jookie
resetbutton
Posted 8:49 AM 24/9/08
Ryu looks the worse....his face looks like mine when im taking a shit.
resetbutton
maniacmayhem
Posted 8:49 AM 24/9/08
What is up with Ryu's eyebrows? Seriously he looks like a muppet.
Is there a problem with going to the folks from Udon?
maniacmayhem
DiGiC
Posted 8:49 AM 24/9/08
The chun li one is just about acceptable to me, Ryu is a bit wtfbbq
DiGiC
neojam
Posted 8:49 AM 24/9/08
The cover with B(.Y.)BIES wins!
Ryu's face (just like the most faces of male SF4 characters) looks a way to retarded.
neojam
Capt_Billy
Posted 8:49 AM 24/9/08
Well played, sir. Goatse Hadouken. I was eating until I read that. Now I will not risk it for fear of that mental image coming back. XD
Capt_Billy
Bedlam
Posted 8:48 AM 24/9/08
They should've sticked to the style of the first cinematic trailer and leave out the big character portraits
Bedlam
ikon
Posted 8:48 AM 24/9/08
I feel rather ashamed of myself, after reading all the previous comments and all, but I kind of like the Chun-li one. Then again, it has Chun-li in it ^^
ikon
OGHowie
Posted 8:47 AM 24/9/08
Ryu is just plain fugly on that cover.
OGHowie
Mit
Posted 8:47 AM 24/9/08
They're cool ideas, but I think it'd look a lot less plain if they colored the characters that are in those clouds. They don't stand out at all from a distance, making it look pretty boring.
Also, Chun Li looks fine to me O_o She's looked much more muscly in the past, and looks more muscly in the actual game too.
Mit
Communist_Gamer
Posted 8:46 AM 24/9/08
For a series that spawned some great (and often VERY questionable, you know who you are ¬¬) fan art, to do such terrible covers when we all had those perfect images of Ryu doing that great hadouken, it is a bit of a disgrace really.
Communist_Gamer
Rianq
Posted 8:46 AM 24/9/08
Hulk say "Ladies first". Hulk not that photogenetic anyway.
Rianq
xAnarChisTx
Posted 8:45 AM 24/9/08
If anything, I would choose Chun-Li. I don't like the constipated look on Ryu's face, let alone the goatse hadouken, lol.
xAnarChisTx
Cragnous
Posted 8:45 AM 24/9/08
Worse - Ryu
Best Chun-Li
I mean this is no contest, the Ryu one is quite ugly but the other one is great i think.
Cragnous
Giolon
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
*shrug* I like the Chun Li cover.
Giolon
Eviscerate
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
Normally I'd say the one with Ryu on the cover but this is by far the worst looking version of Ryu out of all the Street fighters. Guess my new main is gonna be Akuma /sigh
Eviscerate
Karisu-Zero
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
Ryu is SF's poster boy, but he looks horrible here. Plus, you don't mess with a chick who could throw shot at the Moscow Olympics. :/
Karisu-Zero
InvaderGirJr
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
Personally the Ryu boxart looks more like crap than Chun's.
InvaderGirJr
b.bear
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
Goatse Hadoken? Oh man, that is hilarious. Now, I can't look at that picture and think of anything else. Thanks, man.
If I had to choose between the two, I'd pick the one with Chun Li. All things considered, it doesn't look quite as bad as your describing. I'm not particularly happy with either of them, though.
b.bear
Ad-hominem
Posted 8:44 AM 24/9/08
Aww..Cmon. They're not that bad.
I mean, I see no IGN watermarks.
And, I've seen far worse.
Overall, they're okay, not bad.
Ad-hominem
Morpork
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
Goatse Hadouken
That puts new meaning to "tearing someone a new ass hole".
Morpork
RagingBull
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
Holy shit...
Where did they get my 7th grade art class paintings?! MOM!!!
RagingBull
Gummyworm
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
Yeah, but out of the two, I prefer the latter one.
Ryu looks a bit retarded over there, also, why is the bottom base pictures grayed out.
Gummyworm
Absent Blue
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
50% requires actual talent.
25% requires you to neglect aesthetic design principles.
25% requires Filter > Render > Clouds
Absent Blue
kingmanic
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
This is capcom. Be thankful it's not the megaman 1 cover or has the IGN watermark on it.
kingmanic
ShadowFFVI
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
The Ryu one wastes a lot more space, so I say the Chun Li one is better.
ShadowFFVI
liquid_kore
Posted 8:42 AM 24/9/08
Oh god the goatse comment made me laugh.
liquid_kore
Communist_Gamer
Posted 8:42 AM 24/9/08
Hahahahahaha goatse hadouken.
Man not often does Kotaku make me giggle out loud.
Communist_Gamer
Spedfrom
Posted 8:41 AM 24/9/08
Looks a bit amateurish...
Spedfrom
BaseVilliN
Posted 9:33 AM 24/9/08
@maniacmayhem: Ah I was gonna say the same. A muppet indeed...
BaseVilliN
Naturestee
Posted 9:33 AM 24/9/08
Goatse Hadouken
Why??? Why must you put that image in my head?!?
Naturestee
kryzhal
Posted 9:32 AM 24/9/08
As bad as those covers may be they are nowhere as bad as the NA Street Fighter 2 box art. That one makes Ryu look exquisitely dead, and Blanka looks like a pervy hulk about to ball on Chun li.
kryzhal
Troubadour
Posted 9:30 AM 24/9/08
"Goatse Hadouken"
OH GOD I CAN'T UNSEE IT!
Troubadour
Cloudbusting
Posted 9:27 AM 24/9/08
Gee, awful covers. Strange considering how good the character art is.
Cloudbusting
NGE KrazyTiger on XBL
Posted 9:27 AM 24/9/08
@MarkMan: If only it was better. D:
NGE KrazyTiger on XBL
BigSteve
Posted 9:26 AM 24/9/08
Dear Markman,
Does you sending in tips re: SFIV mean that you've finished working on what could only be the greatest joystick in fighting game history? I'm going to assume 'yes'.
Thanks in advance,
Steve
BigSteve
Sam Smith
Posted 9:25 AM 24/9/08
I've seen worse. Seriously these aint that bad
Sam Smith
Captain Fury
Posted 9:22 AM 24/9/08
box arts are not what they use to be...
:X
Captain Fury
Mister_Jack
Posted 9:21 AM 24/9/08
You're making Ryu angry. You won't like him when he's angry.
Mister_Jack
shade-black
Posted 9:20 AM 24/9/08
the one with chun-li looks the best though.
shade-black
Cosmic_Bard
Posted 9:19 AM 24/9/08
What the hell's wrong with the one on the left? I thought it looked pretty badass. Ryu's summoning the very clouds into his hadouken.
Cosmic_Bard
MGSchick
Posted 9:18 AM 24/9/08
I like both I guess. But while I think the cover should have Ryu, but Ryu looks retarded in this picture so I think the Chun Li one looks better. All the characters in her background look much clearer and I like that better.
MGSchick
maex
Posted 9:17 AM 24/9/08
They're only worth it if the cover comes in 3-D
maex
rockmanjoey
Posted 9:16 AM 24/9/08
I agree that the U.S cover looks much better than the European cover. Well, being a PS3 owner I may just order the Japanese version if the cover looks good but I am leaning towards a U.S copy!
rockmanjoey
redpikmin
Posted 9:16 AM 24/9/08
The Ryu image sucks. The Chun-Li artwork on the other hand is great. I'd be more than happy for it to be the final cover
redpikmin
PhilESkyline
Posted 9:15 AM 24/9/08
Why not just have a black box with the Street Fighter IV logo? Makes a better statement to me...oh well.
PhilESkyline
Cryoh
Posted 9:52 AM 24/9/08
Or it could be this:
[upload.wikimedia.org]
Cryoh
daschupa
Posted 9:52 AM 24/9/08
Logo soooo smaaaaaaall...shriiiinkiiiiing....
daschupa
sim0n
Posted 9:51 AM 24/9/08
rushed box art only compliments the rushed gameplay featured in this game. (yes, i've played it a bunch)
sim0n
Kamix
Posted 9:51 AM 24/9/08
Honestly, Ryu looks like he's ready to get his kamehameha on!
Kamix
Aex
Posted 9:49 AM 24/9/08
The Ryu one sucks compared to the Chun Li one.
In fact, I could probably live happily with the Chun Li one.
Aex
PlatformJunkie
Posted 9:48 AM 24/9/08
@ShadowFFVI: Exactly. The Chun-Li one is fuller and the background is better colored.
PlatformJunkie
Reilaos~
Posted 9:48 AM 24/9/08
I thought the game art was okay, except for Ryu's constipation face...
Reilaos~
Vault69
Posted 9:44 AM 24/9/08
I can't say that I like either of those. Of course, it could always be worse.
[upload.wikimedia.org]
Vault69
DoomLight
Posted 9:41 AM 24/9/08
chunli is better lookin.
DoomLight
ShareYourTreats
Posted 9:41 AM 24/9/08
These suck
Why don't they have one with all the characters (or atleast the main ones) highlighted on it?
It would be a lot more colorful and eyecatching that way (plus it would make more sense considering neither Ryu or Chun Li are the "main characters").
Having only one character on the cover makes it seem like an action game with a main character like God of War or Devil May Cry.
ShareYourTreats
Sooku
Posted 9:41 AM 24/9/08
Chun-Li may be an important character, but she doesn't deserve central billing on the box. Ryu maybe, but a group shot, or at least a partial one ala Soul Calibur, would be best.
Sooku
proplasticgeetar
Posted 9:40 AM 24/9/08
What's Capcom's mailing address? I would like to vomit into an envelope and mail it to them.
proplasticgeetar
Gouki4u
Posted 9:40 AM 24/9/08
Wow. These are crap. Maybe they should find the guy who did all the Street Fighter illustrations for GamePro in the 90s.
Gouki4u
chemical_eng_mx
Posted 9:38 AM 24/9/08
No, no, no.
You're all wrong.
Capcom saw how much people loved the god-awful retro-nes of the Megaman 9 mock boxart that they decided to do it for real on SFIV.
chemical_eng_mx
Frologic
Posted 9:36 AM 24/9/08
Chun Li looks awesome.
Ryu looks stupid.
Frologic
Fikus
Posted 9:35 AM 24/9/08
Chun Li.. only cause everything blends in then all of a sudden you see Boobs.
Fikus
Playstation
Posted 9:34 AM 24/9/08
@Spedfrom: Sometimes it's difficult in a situation like this to not put out fingers on the designer(s). But most of the times this is not the case. We often come up with an awesome idea and the implementation is just pure awesomeness.
But then we have to deal with the client (in this case maybe Capcom) who most of the time don't have any art background or whatsoever which makes our life even more difficult. Then we have to deal with their legal department, which sometimes they have their own thoughts and ideas. Most of the time you can't say no to them. They are the one who pays the bill.
Which I think also the reason why the other day Leo Burnett (one of the big agencies) decided to seperate way with Nintendo (I heard they are such a hard client to work with).
Playstation
Jesu
Posted 10:10 AM 24/9/08
Forget the box art, the game itself sucks. I played it at the arcade at chinatown in nyc. Slow and ,boring gameplay and it feels like a bad 3D version of SF2.
Jesu
RobotsAnger
Posted 10:06 AM 24/9/08
I actually like the Chun-Li cover, doesn't look too masculine to me.
RobotsAnger
animat0
Posted 10:06 AM 24/9/08
I like the Chun Li one...
but...Ryu...wtf happened to your face??
animat0
y2julio
Posted 10:05 AM 24/9/08
Lol the goatse hadoken made me laugh, took another look at the covers after I read that.
y2julio
jting76
Posted 10:03 AM 24/9/08
how can you tell that chung li is too muscular?
jting76
ertyu
Posted 10:02 AM 24/9/08
I think the thing wrong with Ryu is the facial expression.... it really throws it off. Chun Li looks fine, however =P
ertyu
osteofight
Posted 10:00 AM 24/9/08
The Chun-Li one is actually pretty good. Remember, she's the -strongest woman in the world-. That said they should do a retro cover with Blanka rolling in a ball yet somehow grinning at Chun-Li.
osteofight
Omata
Posted 9:59 AM 24/9/08
That's an extremely tacky logo they have on both versions.
Omata
Jiggeh
Posted 9:57 AM 24/9/08
Both look tremendously boring. I'm hoping the Japanese boxart will look a lot better!
They should just have Nishimura Kinu do a proper cover illustration, instead of this pseudo-painted CG crap.
Jiggeh
Desertwolf
Posted 9:55 AM 24/9/08
Definitely the Chun Li, Ryu's face is just... ugly..
Desertwolf
Thugmunk
Posted 10:30 AM 24/9/08
I'd shoryuken Chun-li all night long while she kicks those juicy thighs all over my body...
I mean..
Yeah. Art cover.. Amateur...
<3
Thugmunk
Dr_Claw4891
Posted 10:29 AM 24/9/08
Is that Ryu or The Rock?
Dr_Claw4891
Daisuash
Posted 10:29 AM 24/9/08
I vote for the Chun Li one. But if they make one with Akuma, it will win.Definitely.
Daisuash
benkarl
Posted 10:28 AM 24/9/08
My friend used to practice Goatse Haduken with his uncle... He was pretty good - so my sister said.
benkarl
TacoGrande
Posted 10:23 AM 24/9/08
i'll never understand why guys don't like chun-li. because i love her. and she loves me.
that ryu cover is horrible. and kudos to the goatse reference. havent heard that in years...
TacoGrande
kingme
Posted 10:22 AM 24/9/08
okay yeah it six but if I was to choose it would be chun li. Ryu looks ugly in 3d and I think the drawing of him and ken below her looks cool
kingme
Undyne
Posted 10:20 AM 24/9/08
I think the chun-li one is sweet. Ryu isn't all that bad.
Undyne
yflow
Posted 10:17 AM 24/9/08
@ShadowFFVI:
Lucky you if you live in America then. Supposedly the Americans are getting Chun Li and the Europeans are getting Ryu.
yflow
DigiMish
Posted 10:16 AM 24/9/08
Pretty terrible, like others have said.
Capcom, please give us Ryu and Ken engaged in an epic fight on the cover.
DigiMish
Yofu
Posted 10:15 AM 24/9/08
I like the Chun Li one, and still think she is very hot.
Yofu
James in Dupont
Posted 10:50 AM 24/9/08
For all I care the box art can just be Goatse. I'm not buying SFIV because I give a shit about the box.
James in Dupont
Mohrdikai
Posted 10:43 AM 24/9/08
@maniacmayhem: Thank you! I was trying to think of what Ryu reminded me of but I couldn't quite put my finger on it. He's definitely looks like he came out of Henson's workshop.
Mohrdikai
Gaschamber
Posted 10:43 AM 24/9/08
I lol'ed
Gaschamber
tinkyXIII
Posted 10:42 AM 24/9/08
People actually think Capcom will release good fighting game cover art in the West?
tinkyXIII
push eject
Posted 10:39 AM 24/9/08
the one with chunners is great
push eject
Sunamaru
Posted 11:10 AM 24/9/08
lol at Ryu funny face
Sunamaru
TheHeartless
Posted 11:07 AM 24/9/08
On the one hand, Ryu's face looks goofy. On the other hand, Chun Li's man hands have been shrunk down and I feel that it's misleading to the player.
...
Chun Li one, that's my pick.
TheHeartless
KagaSakai
Posted 11:05 AM 24/9/08
Both are pretty bad, but if I had to choose one, it would be Chun Li. Ryu looks like he needs to take a big dump.
KagaSakai
twesterms 2nd
Posted 11:05 AM 24/9/08
I actually like both of the covers. It could be worse, we could have something like the Spiderman: Web of shadows boxart.
twesterms 2nd
Wolfers
Posted 11:03 AM 24/9/08
I wonder how it'd look without the large character...
Wolfers
Knoxximus (XBL/PSN)
Posted 10:59 AM 24/9/08
If anybody should be on the cover, it should be either Ken and Ryu, the stalwarts of the series, or just Ryu...with maybe a shadow of Gouki for good measure.
Knoxximus (XBL/PSN)
Strangelove
Posted 10:56 AM 24/9/08
I actually kind of like the Ryu conceptually -- how the background clouds swirl into the Hadouken. Not so much the Chun Li, though.
Strangelove
ChaosKnight
Posted 10:56 AM 24/9/08
Chun Li's has a lot more color and depth in shadowing. I kinda wish they brought that over to Ryu's.
ChaosKnight
GrandfatherParadox
Posted 10:54 AM 24/9/08
They're both terrible, though I do dig the 80s heavy metal bracelets that Chun Li is wearing.
GrandfatherParadox
Moonshadow101
Posted 11:33 AM 24/9/08
I would say the Chun-li one, until I saw Ryu's face. That's messed up. So the left one is worse.
Moonshadow101
Warrior_Within_
Posted 11:28 AM 24/9/08
@Communist_Gamer:
hahah!..NOT! that wasn't a slight bit funny. Whoever wrote that column is an idiot. The Chun-Li boxart looks great by the way.
Warrior_Within_
Rubezh
Posted 11:24 AM 24/9/08
What they need is Jean Claude Van Damme as Guile.
Rubezh
Codman24
Posted 11:21 AM 24/9/08
The right one
Codman24
Stevetrop
Posted 11:53 AM 24/9/08
My mind is tainted with thoughts of Akuma performing a Raging Goatse in SF4 :(
Stevetrop
lostinseganet
Posted 11:50 AM 24/9/08
The one of the left is the worst.
lostinseganet
d3v
Posted 11:49 AM 24/9/08
Am I the only one dissapointed that it's still not as bad as the original '90's SFII US arcade cabinet art?
d3v
Channing
Posted 11:45 AM 24/9/08
How can you not like the Chun-li one?
Nyoro~ :3
Channing
Pojomofo
Posted 11:38 AM 24/9/08
Goatse Hadoken???? Epic
Pojomofo
DigitalHero
Posted 11:38 AM 24/9/08
Could be worse. Street Fighter Alpha for PSOne anyone?
[www.reflectonreality.com]
DigitalHero
Crawl to China
Posted 12:12 PM 24/9/08
The Ryu one is worse.
Especially now that goatse was mentioned.
Crawl to China
salaminizer
Posted 12:08 PM 24/9/08
hahahah goatse hadouken was awesome
salaminizer
henhowc
Posted 12:07 PM 24/9/08
Ryu looks like a f@cking ape. Why can't they just use this as the freaking box art...(wise the in game design was like this too)
[en.wikipedia.org]
henhowc
Ken Hikari
Posted 12:04 PM 24/9/08
Looks...empty. There should be more characters on that box art.
Ken Hikari
TheGuilty1
Posted 11:57 AM 24/9/08
I really don't understand what Stuart's problem with Chun-Li is. She looks fine.
Ryu, though.....wow.
TheGuilty1
hessblake
Posted 12:33 PM 24/9/08
I like the Ryu one better....
hessblake
GrassJelly
Posted 12:32 PM 24/9/08
Call me crazy, but I like the Chun Li version. Anyone remember the cover art for the original Street Fighter II for the SNES? Yikes.
[www.playright.dk]
GrassJelly
WolfmanWalt
Posted 12:17 PM 24/9/08
I don't see how you could find that picture of Chun Li too muscular - you can barely see anything about her. Anyways, the Chun Li one is fine. The Ryu one looks like a rejected Geico ad.
WolfmanWalt
phalanges
Posted 12:14 PM 24/9/08
I don't mine the Chun Li one.
phalanges
neo177117
Posted 12:48 PM 24/9/08
@OGHowie: I agree! he is F-UGLY!
I choose you Chun-Li.
neo177117
Chewbenator
Posted 12:47 PM 24/9/08
I dunno, I kinda like the one on the right.
Chewbenator
TheMysteriousStranger
Posted 12:44 PM 24/9/08
They could have done a lot better.
TheMysteriousStranger
Rebochan
Posted 1:09 PM 24/9/08
Seriously, what's wrong with the Chun Li art? She looks fine. I'm not even seeing any grotesque muscle or mutated potato thumbs.
Rebochan
Veridis_Quo
Posted 12:56 PM 24/9/08
Nice, Goatse Hadouken ☺.
Anyways I guess everyone can agree that the cover art is absolutely crap. I mean it's not creative at all. I know Capcom can do a hell of a lot better than this that. I mean look at the cover art for SFII! No cover art sells better than Blanka rolling into Ryu while Chun Li defends herself. That cover art made you think! Well that maybe isn't the best example, but you know what I mean.
Veridis_Quo
MugenacjaPL
Posted 1:19 PM 24/9/08
The one with Chun-Li is acceptable.
MugenacjaPL
plasticgonads
Posted 1:44 PM 24/9/08
chun li's is better. both are still crap though
plasticgonads
FlagshipFighter
Posted 2:11 PM 24/9/08
If these are the same looking for the xbox 360 version, then i would go for the Chun-Li one, even if i am a fan of Ryu that Chun-Li cover is by far better
FlagshipFighter
Esnel Pla
Posted 2:10 PM 24/9/08
Maybe the Super version will have better art.
If not, then the Turbo.
Esnel Pla
Mr.Sad
Posted 2:09 PM 24/9/08
i want the Chun Li one
at least she looks reasonably hot
Ryu just looks silly. i think its the teeth
cos all along Ryu is brooding in all past editions of the game
except now.
Mr.Sad
Alex_Mexico
Posted 2:28 PM 24/9/08
could someone enlighten me on the whole Goatse Hadoken joke? I just dont get it :S
Also, I dont think the Chun Li one is bad. Not great but not bad. The Ryu one is indeed awful.
Alex_Mexico
Br00klyn-Grenade
Posted 2:18 PM 24/9/08
I like the Chun-Li box art better.
Br00klyn-Grenade
Scruffylookin13
Posted 2:16 PM 24/9/08
Rasengan please
Scruffylookin13
kadosho
Posted 2:43 PM 24/9/08
Bit unsure about these covers, just an overall cast groupshot would be more worthwhile. (*hey if the past games promo artworks could pull it off, why not newer titles?)
Capcom needs to work on these covers more. --,
kadosho
Cpryd001
Posted 3:50 PM 24/9/08
@Communist_Gamer:
Goatse Hadouken... genius.
Of all the lovely artwork capcom teased us pre-SF4 - they can't even get a nice boxart for us?
Cpryd001
NewSpecies
Posted 3:35 PM 24/9/08
I like both of them. I don't see what's wrong. They look good, plus I love the detail they put in to the clouds. Also Chun-Li always looked muscular, she has what you'd call "Thighs of steel". :P
NewSpecies
Shachihoko
Posted 4:02 PM 24/9/08
@maniacmayhem: He look like Bert and Ernie's love child!!!
Shachihoko
Shachihoko
Posted 3:59 PM 24/9/08
@Alex_Mexico: I don't get it either, but I know what Goatse is.. And believe me... You do not want to look it up.. Trust me.. Just ignore it..
If you are curious, just do not eat and while looking it up..
Shachihoko
Shachihoko
Posted 3:55 PM 24/9/08
I like Chun-Li one better.. She stands out better, almost eye-catching and the contrast of colors look better than Ryu one.. Plus, I think Ryu look ugly and too much like the Hulk.
Shachihoko
zdevex
Posted 4:32 PM 24/9/08
The Chun Li box art isn't bad at all. Ryu's would be so much better if his face wasn't so horrible.
zdevex
ChiChi_BBQ
Posted 4:15 PM 24/9/08
I'm a Ryu fan, but that boxart makes him look like a Ninja Turtle. Chun Li, on the other hand, is drawn SO pretty in my opinion.
ChiChi_BBQ
KaliKOtt
Posted 5:30 PM 24/9/08
Thankfully Capcom listens to video game blogs like Kotaku right?
Or are they like activision with the sad Spider-man cover art? =(
KaliKOtt
Starplate
Posted 5:29 PM 24/9/08
the composition of the chun-li one is better. the faces of the other fighters are way too subtle in the already-bastardized-face-Ryu version
Starplate
getbonus
Posted 5:27 PM 24/9/08
@kingmanic: y'know, i'm actually hoping an IGN logo slips in there, and that capcom then prints up some awesome variant covers. because these suck shit.
getbonus
BillyLee
Posted 7:56 PM 24/9/08
I think they both look awesome! Apart from Ryu's face anyway. I'm a Street Fighter fan but I don't get the Goatse Hadouken joke. Can someone explain?
BillyLee
Gekopa
Posted 8:13 PM 24/9/08
I like the Chun-li one better.
Ryu looks like he was constipated!
Gekopa
Sloopydrew
Posted 8:09 PM 24/9/08
@getbonus:
Did anyone get their variant covers for Okami? I never got mine. One of my friends also ordered one and, last we talked, he hadn't received his either. Hope it wasn't just a PR stunt on Capcom's fault, and they intend to send the cover inserts out.
Sloopydrew
L___E___T
Posted 9:05 PM 24/9/08
Why oh why won't they just give the cover art job to the Japanese, this looks kak and let's be honest Capcom don't quite have the best reputation when it comes to localised box arts.
L___E___T
xxBetaMaxxx
Posted 10:45 PM 24/9/08
ryu is worser
xxBetaMaxxx
joey1234
Posted 11:01 PM 24/9/08
I like the Chun-Li cover. I also like the cloud effect with the characters in the background.
As for Ryu - they need to work on it. Is he smiling? angry? focused?
Chun-Li's expression at least looks like she's slowly exhaling during a fight.
my 2 cents.
joey1234
SavidDaunders
Posted 11:22 PM 24/9/08
What's wrong with her right boob?
SavidDaunders
doc_DDoublekill
Posted 1:06 AM 25/9/08
ARGH Ryu looks like a garbage...Look at his face, it's ugly damn....They should have called some guys from UDON to draw him.
doc_DDoublekill
siamgx
Posted 1:36 AM 25/9/08
Use Chun-Li to coincide with Chun-Li Movie plus the Ryu one looks bad.
siamgx
epy0nkaru
Posted 1:49 AM 25/9/08
There has been Street Fighter III boxart with Chun Li on it (check the Street fighter Anniversary Collection Special Edition for japan) and it's pretty cool. Chun is as much of a street fighter poster person as ryu and ken
also, the chun li box is pretty good, but we know capcom can do much better
epy0nkaru
Zombie_Crunch
Posted 2:23 AM 25/9/08
@Communist_Gamer: I type lol a lot when i don't actually lol. But this was an actual LOL. :)
Zombie_Crunch
kayven
Posted 2:45 AM 25/9/08
that is incredibly weak. im trying really hard to be a fan of this game but its just not happening so far. i can't get over the no parrying thing. everytime i play it feels like they dumbed down the experience.
kayven
vysionist
Posted 3:12 AM 25/9/08
Whack directors at Capcom USA, no wonder a majority of them got fired or were ask to resign. They got a bunch of non talented people(with master degrees with no art background) over there making bad decision. If you notice the quality of art work coming out from there, you'll see what I'm talking about. Very poor quality control. The games are great but to have bad graphics and ideas associated with the game is unacceptable. Capcom use to be great but now they're just mediocre. Lucky for Capcom USA, the name still carries them.
vysionist
Koztah
Posted 3:12 AM 25/9/08
@Captain Fury:
They sure aren't...
[upload.wikimedia.org]
Koztah
EMPEROR_COW
Posted 3:49 AM 25/9/08
i dunno i kinda like'um both ...
ryu always looked like an idiot anyway :P
but yeah the chun li one is pretty nice IMO
EMPEROR_COW
DontCrossMyanimals
Posted 11:47 AM 24/9/08
I wont say the Chun-Li one, because it's a little stuffy and weired. The Ryu cover is awesome though.
DontCrossMyanimals
LeLoi
Posted 7:50 AM 25/9/08
Ryu looks like he's about to take the biggest shit of his life so I would have to go with the Chun-Li cover.
LeLoi
FrigidAir44
Posted 10:47 AM 25/9/08
@quen: Well I was exactly looking for the other faces to be colored. I agree... that would wreck the composition.
However making the faces a bit more bold which would allow them to stand out more would help.
FrigidAir44
Blue_Bomber88
Posted 11:54 AM 25/9/08
This must be a joke. These cant possible be the final covers. They better be drafts or something, cuz that looks crappy. They gone from awesome covers like Okami to this?! Cmon Capcom, get ur crap together
Blue_Bomber88
NeoChaos
Posted 3:41 PM 25/9/08
Do you smell what The Ryu is cookin'?
All they need to do now is give El Fuerte a chair to use as a blunt weapon.
NeoChaos
poplin
Posted 6:05 PM 25/9/08
I like the chun li one. makes it easier to note that the cloud is actually made up of the rest of the characters, which is pretty cool
poplin
lucifer_goosifer
Posted 7:29 PM 25/9/08
Ryu syphoning thin air into an invisible bucket? Chun-Li doing her "Oh" face? Great! But where's the "Zangief adjusting himself" cover, though?
lucifer_goosifer
evilralphwiggum
Posted 1:11 AM 26/9/08
wait..these look bad? xD..they don't look too bad to me..
evilralphwiggum
Sintonado
Posted 4:12 AM 26/9/08
oh and whatever happened to our Okami covers?
Sintonado
Kurow
Posted 11:59 AM 26/9/08
For the first time in the history of Capcom games America gets the best cover!...
September 25 2008... remember the date xD
Kurow
zigurat
Posted 3:42 PM 24/9/08
If I had to choose I would pick the Chun Li one. But seriously Capcom, you can do alot better!
zigurat
EmperorExile
Posted 1:40 PM 24/9/08
Ryu looking like a cave man, Chun Li looking perfect...PS3 version it is. Sorry Kotaku but Chun Li looks fine.
EmperorExile
Te-Piso
Posted 11:05 AM 24/9/08
fuck you
Te-Piso
latiosking
Posted 10:57 AM 24/9/08
Just color the charaters on the clouds a bit and the chun-li would look better.
latiosking
Cr1msonk1ng
Posted 10:20 AM 24/9/08
Coming from someone who doesn't play street fighter, I don't think the art looks THAT bad. I mean It's certainly much better than the slop developers have fed us when making us decide the cover art. Web of shadows and Resistance anyone?
Cr1msonk1ng
FilthyAssistant
Posted 9:37 AM 24/9/08
Chun Li's pose and art is fine, but the logo is pretty stupid. And yes, Ryu looks awful.
FilthyAssistant
Tmills2002
Posted 9:32 AM 24/9/08
I actually like both of the covers...
Tmills2002
dago2888
Posted 9:02 AM 24/9/08
are these for real?
If so i pick the Chun li one,but i hope they reconsider and create new box art for this game.
dago2888
phatdog45
Posted 8:50 AM 24/9/08
1st one is a little better
phatdog45
bucocky
Posted 8:46 AM 24/9/08
Ewwwwwwww... why can't the covers look like the other street fighter games? Hand drawn beautiful anime/comic look? Ugly photoshop look instead.
bucocky
Saigin
Posted 8:43 AM 24/9/08
I dunno, I think that box art shouldn't sell a game. So it doesn't matter much to me.
Saigin
HadleyDadis
Posted 6:17 PM 25/9/08
I'm a SF fanatic, and even I think Ryu looks like a muppet in this pic
HadleyDadis
Postlapsaria
Posted 10:58 AM 24/9/08
I like the Ryu one.. -_-
Postlapsaria
CyberZombie
Posted 9:36 AM 24/9/08
I agree that the Ryu cover is a bit subpar...but I actually kind of like the Chun Li cover. Maybe we've all just come to expect orgasmic works of art from Capcom, with their Udon Studios just pushing out the awesome 24/7 (which, as it so happens, is one of my absolute favorite studios right up there with the studio that did the works of Magna Carta), but really...I don't see the butch side that Mr. Houghton is remarking on in Chun Li's case.
Now I will say if Sakura was more present on the cover I'd give it a higher grade, personally...
CyberZombie