Danc at Lost Garden has another take on the utility (or lack thereof) of game reviews in today’s gaming landscape, this one looking at the ‘expertise bias.’ He points out the disparity between reviewers and players when it comes to looking at new games — especially ones that have a gentle difficulty curve. His basic operating premise is that because game reviewers have plowed through so many titles and mechanics, they’re looking at ‘difficulty’ in an entirely different light than vast portions of the audience. What will the future look like? He posits observation of other players is going to become increasingly important to developers, and if reviews can’t keep up with that, they will really fall by the wayside:
I do love Lost Garden’s prototyping challenge, though I will never in my life prototype any game, even simple and super cute ones. However, I always love seeing what other people come up with — it’s an interesting exercise in observing the design process with playable prototypes. The latest is a cute idea that takes advantage of 3D engines and real-time shade. The basic idea is that you play a farmer who has to save his haul from the scorching sun: