Metacritic

News

Modern Warfare 3 Developer Pleads For Better Metascores, Discovers That’s A Stupid Idea

1:00PM November 18, 2011 | Owen Good

Why someone from Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 3 developer Sledgehammer would consider its fan-voted Metacritic score worth a get-out-the-vote tweet is utterly beyond me. It is by far the most polarising title among gaming’s annual releases, so a user score of 1.7 is probably to be expected, given how much gaming’s snobs cognoscenti despise all that it stands for. More »


News

Metacritic Bans Review Bombers

8:00AM September 23, 2011 | Owen Good

Metacritic doesn’t just aggregate the arbitrary scores that professional reviewers assign to subjective works such as video games. It aggregates the arbitrary scores anyone can apply to subjective works such as video games. This has all sorts of fun applications, such as abuse. So, recently, Metacritic banned a bunch of spam accounts set up to slag Bastion and Toy Soldiers: Cold War for no good reason. More »


In Real Life

Metacritic Calls On Writers To Review More Shitty Games

1:00AM July 17, 2011 | Owen Good

Metacritic’s founder made a little bit of a stir earlier in the week when he went on the A Jumps B Shoots podcast to discuss a wide variety of topics, one of them being that game reviewers were obligated to “review all the shit,” not just good games or those expected to sell well. GamePro followed up for a clarification of his remarks. More »


PC

The People Are Panning Portal 2

2:00AM April 20, 2011 | StephenTotilo

Portal 2 is getting rave reviews from critics (including from us), but it is getting torn to bits by angry gamers over at the review aggregation site Metacritic. The Game of the Year? Not according to furious fans who have saddled the game with an average review score of 4.7 out of 10. More »


News

Metacritic Responds To Criticism, Removes Ability To Rate Developers

Flag
2:00PM March 29, 2011 | Mark Serrels

Earlier this week we got word that Metacritic was intending to start rating individual developers in addition to video games. There was a bit of a backlash amongst consumers and the press, and now Metacritic has responded. More »


News

Metacritic Now Rating Humans

8:00AM March 27, 2011 | Owen Good

Metacritic, whose 90s, 80s, 70s and dreaded 60s are points of pride and shame for the video game industry, will now be applying ratings to individual game developers, giving them a score based on an average of all the games they’ve worked on. More »


News

Maybe Metacritic Doesn’t Matter THAT Much After All…

Flag
3:15PM March 25, 2011 | Mark Serrels

Earlier last week, THQ’s share value dropped 25% as a result of mediocre early reviews for Homefront posted on Metacritic but, despite that, the game has gone on to sell strongly, shifting 1 million units across all markets, with 2.5 million shipped. More »


Mobile

Metacritic Now Ranks IPhone And IPad Games

2:30PM March 19, 2011 | Owen Good

Metacritic, whose cumulative scores provide a thumbs-up/thumbs-down barometer that can move games publishers’ stock prices, has expanded. The review aggregator has begun listing iPhone and iPad apps. More »


PC

Dragon Age II Dev Rates His Own Game On Metacritic

2:00AM March 16, 2011 | Mike Fahey

A glowing fan review for Dragon Age II on Metacritic discovered to have been written by a member of the game’s development team sparked outrage among the gaming community yesterday. EA’s response? That’s how it works. More »


In Real Life

Objection! Should Video Game Reviews Change?

Flag
4:00PM January 19, 2011 | Mark Serrels

Welcome to Objection! This is where we take the time to go on-depth on gaming issues, and let you guys continue the discussion in the comments section.

This week we’re taking video game reviews to task – are they now redundant? So they need to change? More »