What You Said: LA Noire Too Big For Xbox 360

lanoire2.jpgWow. We had a big response to our post containing leaked details on Team Bondi's LA Noire. The comments didn't just focus on the game however - you guys talked about everything from Blu-ray and HD-DVD to PS3 fan boys... with a bit of Brendan McNamara hate thrown in.

Would anyone at Team Bondi like to comment on the rumours? I get the feeling I'd be better off asking my toilet the same question...

Hit the jump for a raw comment extravaganza!

LA Noire Too Big For Xbox 360 [Kotaku Australia] Rob:

It seems that Team Bondi has never heard of the concept of multiple discs.

Casey Toney:

GTAVI is having size problems, BLACKGUNNER. Why do you think it was delayed from fall of this year to first quarter next year? They couldn't fit it on a disk. And that exclusive downloadable 360 content is stuff they couldn't fit into the 360 version so they had to make it downloadable and Microsoft slapped down 50 mil to get that exclusive. They can use whatever bullshit they want now. Eventually, 360's capabilities will be so far behind that developers won't even be able to dream of making their game work on the 360. PS3 will start getting all the exclusives.

Brian:

Microsoft could have included HD DVD to the 360. But to do it would mean delaying the 360. They had to get all those awesome games to market fast. Games like Gears of War and Halo 3. Wait, those games weren't release games? Oh, I guess Microsoft could have waited six months for HD DVD to come out afterall.

Razmossis:

xbox 360 is really like a ball and chain around the ps3s leg dragging it down, the games coming out for both means that the ps3 version is sooo under its potential just so the watery 360 can handle the pace, if that chain was broke then every game the came out for ps3 has the potential to sh1t on every 360 game!! LA NOIRE cant be put on 2 disks, its a free roaming game, youd have change disks every time ya wanted to go across the map... geyyyy!!! PS3 WILL WIN

Jose Cuervo:

RAZMOSSIS has the right idea, right now games are being made for both consoles because developers havent seen the true next gen potential in PS3. HD is going to be common just like SD has been for so long. No one will wanna play shitty 360 non-HD Halo 3 looking games...you'll look back to Halo 3 and gears of war in less than a year and laugh when you see what the ps3 has in store. La Noire would fit on maybe 5 of your shitty 360 discs...and you'd have to change everytime you go from one side of the map to a territory on another disc. Games will be downgraded in order to port to 360 soon, live with it. PS. When your warranty is up and your 360 dies, you'll wish you'd have gotten a PS3...360 is terribly built, youll be lucky if it lasts you 3 years...PS3 was built to last over a decade.

Jacob33:

LA Noir sounds like the most boring game ever! Did anyone play the awful 'True Crime LA?' - Half the problem with that was that real-life LA is a god-awful flat and tedius city to drive around. Have a look at some real maps if you don't believe me. Then take it to the 1940's, where you'll be driving chuggy antique cars with a top speed of 40mph around a bland undeveloped fraction of what LA is now. And of course there will be harldy any traffic either.

Then base it on 'real' crimes, which just sounds like an pointless anchor on the designers! If my nanna was still alive she might have cared, but can't see anyone going 'Ooo real 1940's crime! - I'm getting it now!' So with it all being real we can forget about any over-the-top hollywood style action entertainment sequences. I half expect there to be a bit where you spend hours doing paperwork. Bake the above in a dreary desaturated film noir oven, and I think you've got the recipe for the most boring sounding game of all time. I can almost hear the bland cheesy saxaphone as I spend forever driving slowly from point A to point B and back again. Hey, but at least the characters will be wearing an authentic shade of brown. (A colour that really suits the game) Hopefully there will be a watching paint dry mini-game to help spice it up ;) Not coming to 360? *wipes away a single tear* Awww, pity that ;)

XXCoop42XX:

first off, ps3 was delayed how many times... thats right 4 times.i wonder why? ohh wait i know first it was the video card overheating in just 2 hrs of play, then the hdd locked up(which xbox was the original hdd user,stolen idea by sony)then the whole dualshock crap then other little problems.the 360 is way more powerful than the gaystation3 and always will be and guess what microsoft doesnt have to make 5 different versions of a console to get it right.we have pro edition, core edition and the elite. sony has really killed itself with this paperweight3. many games wont port to ps3 because it cant proccess fast enough.so every one who was dumb enough to spend 500+ on a ps3 goodluck finding something to do, you guyz got nothin.(xb360 has xblive also,hmm ps network doesnt seem to have much goin on, i wonder who's home).


Comments

    I remember a time when Kotaku was full of intelligent discussion... But that's back when you had to be invited to comment.

    This shows most commentators now are just a bunch of moronic fan boys trying to prove who's got the biggest dick... the funny thing is it's not even their own dicks they're talking about...

    @ XXCoop42XX

    You my boy are a complete psycho and need to open your eyes. Now i have nothing against the 360 except for its owners as they all have big heads when they have no reason to. Yes the PS3 was delayed but it was worth it coz they ironed out the problems unlike the 360 where for every 2 sold, one is returned as its faulty. And even after that the ones that didnt get returned over heat and die so they get a new one anyway which has the exact same problem. About 75% (and im being nice to the 360 owners) of all people i talk to about the 360 who own one has said that they have had to return their 360 over 5 times to get it fixed from over heating and dieing. How is that a solid console right there. LOL. WTF are you on about with the different versions, 360 has 3 different versions LOL. ANd how is SONY making their consoles better still. They are removing features to reduce price so therefore the best was the first one. LOL. What is this you speak of as the XBOX being the first to get a HDD, I think you will recall the PS2 having an external HDD, oh and back in the NES days one of them had a HDD aswell. And if that isnt enough to convice you, i think you need to look over at your PC or MAC and see that it too has a HDD so therefore your theory is incorrect. If you want to see the power of the 360 vs PS3 just look at the specs mate, the two consoles are nearly the same spec wise but the PS3 has that extra bit of oooommmph that will take it on for years unlike the 360 that has already been maxed out in everyway. If SONY has somehow killed itself with the PS3, why is it still selling consoles. LOL. About the proting aswelll, its the other way around. The 360 is struggling to get ports to it now and you will begin to see it more soon when the 360 cant handle it. How can the PS3 not process fast enough when the specs of the PS3 are a bit better than the 360. LOL. And finally for the whole argument about LIVE vs PSN. I dont see any of the SONY guys (including me) paying for PSN, and i dont blame it if its behind LIVE becasue its free. LIVE costs money and i think its a rip off because who wants to pay over $100 for a game and then have to pay to go online with it. LOL. So overall i think that the 360 is still a good console but has far too many problems. The PS3 is the one on top of this fight and the reason the sales are not as good is because the 360 came out yonks before the PS3. Oh and if i recall correctly the only PS3 that died was becasue a guy put duct tape over the vents. CASE CLOSED.

    @ XXCoop42XX

    Yes the PS3 was delayed but it was worth it coz they ironed out the problems unlike the 360 where for every 2 sold, one is returned as its faulty. And even after that the ones that didnt get returned over heat and die so they get a new one anyway which has the exact same problem. About 75% (and im being nice to the 360 owners) of all people i talk to about the 360 who own one has said that they have had to return their 360 over 5 times to get it fixed from over heating and dieing. How is that a solid console right there. LOL. On to different versions, 360 has 3 different versions LOL. And how is SONY making their consoles better still. They are removing features to reduce price so therefore the best was the first one. LOL. What is this you speak of as the XBOX being the first to get a HDD, I think you will recall the PS2 having an external HDD, oh and back in the NES days one of them had a HDD aswell. And if that isnt enough to convice you, i think you need to look over at your PC or MAC and see that it too has a HDD so therefore your theory is incorrect. If you want to see the power of the 360 vs PS3 just look at the specs mate, the two consoles are nearly the same spec wise but the PS3 has that extra bit of oooommmph that will take it on for years unlike the 360 that has already been maxed out in everyway. If SONY has somehow killed itself with the PS3, why is it still selling consoles. LOL. About the proting aswelll, its the other way around. The 360 is struggling to get ports to it now and you will begin to see it more soon when the 360 cant handle it. How can the PS3 not process fast enough when the specs of the PS3 are a bit better than the 360. LOL. And finally for the whole argument about LIVE vs PSN. I dont see any of the SONY guys (including me) paying for PSN, and i dont blame it if its behind LIVE becasue its free. LIVE costs money and i think its a rip off because who wants to pay over $100 for a game and then have to pay to go online with it. LOL. So overall i think that the 360 is still a good console but has far too many problems. The PS3 is the one on top of this fight and the reason the sales are not as good is because the 360 came out yonks before the PS3. Oh and if i recall correctly the only PS3 that died was becasue a guy put duct tape over the vents. CASE CLOSED.

    The biggest mistake Xbox made was releasing one without a hard drive. If all their units had a hard drive then you could simply load up all 2 or so dvd's of data onto the xbox itself and just using the game disk to play the game. If they did that not having a HD drive wouldn't be a problem for large games. For this reason only PS3 is a generation ahead.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now