The Problem With Reality

Video games are meant to be flights of fancy, but as with television, reality has become an increasingly popular concept to tap into.

Nowhere is this more evident than in music-themed video games. Titles like Guitar Hero 5, The Beatles: Rock Band and soon-to-be released DJ Hero all use real musicians, living and dead, to help create a stronger sense of realism.

But is that a good thing?

For the surviving members of The Beatles and their fans it seems to be.

The self-titled Rock Band game released to phenomenal reviews and delivered an experience that was solely devoted the band. The game, it seems, was an effort to not only give people a chance to play through their favourite Beatles hits, but to get a better sense of how The Beatles grew both us musicians and a band.

The same week that fans of the fab four were rejoicing in the singular experience of The Beatles: Rock Band, the widow, fans and band mates of late grunge icon Kurt Cobain were up in arms over his inclusion in Guitar Hero 5.

Prior to the game's release, publisher Activision told Rolling Stone magazine that Courtney Love wasn't just integral in bringing Cobain to life in the game, she was great to work with.

But in a frenzy of late-night Twitter updates a week after the game's release, Love denied that she was happily involved in the project, posting 214 Tweets over a six-hour period decrying the game, Cobain's inclusion in it and most hotly the ability to have the grunge singer perform other songs.

It's this single feature, which allows gamers to unlock Cobain and have him sing everything from Johnny Cash's Ring of Fire to Bon Jovi's You Give Love a Bad Name, that seems to be the most upsetting to friends, fans and family.

Some critics too, were unhappy with it. Kotaku's own review described the ability to reanimate the virtual corpses of Cobain and Johnny Cash and control them as marionettes in other people's songs, as tacky and crude.

Krist Novoselic and Dave Grohl, the two surviving members of Nirvana, released a joint statement asking Activision to alter the game to prevent the virtual Cobain from performing songs that are not his own.

"Kurt Cobain wrote songs that hold a lot of meaning to people all over the world. We feel he deserves better."

Activision, which had initially agreed to participate in this story, declined to respond to questions about the decision to include real-world musicians in games and to say whether they would change Cobain's inclusion in Guitar Hero 5.

They did send along a prepared statement saying that the game had the necessary licensing rights from the Cobain estate in a "written agreement signed by Courtney Love to use Kurt Cobain's likeness as a fully playable character in Guitar Hero 5,"

While Love didn't respond to our requests for an interview, her attorney did, saying that while there was an agreement in place, it didn't allow the sort of treatment Cobain is getting in the game.

"Ms. Cobain is extremely upset about Activision's use of Mr. Cobain's likeness to sing the songs of others in its Guitar Hero game," Keith A. Fink, Love's attorney, told Kotaku. "Activision was granted permission by Kurt's trust solely to use his name and likeness. Activision was not given an unbridled right to use Mr. Cobain's name and likeness. "

"The agreement Activision has with the trust doesn't allow them to use his likeness in ways that denigrate his image."

Love's response to Guitar Hero 5 is a far cry from the response The Beatles: Rock Band is getting from the family and surviving members of The Beatles.

Perhaps that's because in the Rock Band game players can only perform as The Beatles in songs by The Beatles. The game comes with 45 tracks, and more are on the way, but they're only going to be Beatles songs. And none of those Beatles songs work on Rock Band 2.

It's a clear distinction that could explain Love's emotional and slightly delayed reaction to Cobain's use in Guitar Hero 5.

Had she seen The Beatles: Rock Band I'm sure she couldn't help but ponder over what could have been: A video game that celebrates Kurt Cobain rather than using him. A title that expands Cobain's audience, reminds people of his importance in the world of music and gives fans and neophytes an equal opportunity to try and understand the godfather of grunge.

In the future, game developers attracted to the allure of reality should perhaps keep in mind that what makes reality so intriguing is that it's real, not that it's a jumping off point for a distasteful fiction.

Well Played is a weekly news and opinion column about the big stories of the week in the gaming industry and its bigger impact on things to come. Feel free to join in the discussion.


    now lets all hope for "Nirvana: rockBand"

    I don't... understand. What's the big problem here? Why is it "denigrating" to Mr. Cobain's image and/or memory to see a virtual marrionette with his likeness perform songs that he did not actually sing?

    What's so upsetting about that? Ms. Love's trust surely understood that the game was not solely about Mr. Cobain or his music, right? But still they signed up, so they have no right to complain, as far as I see.

    Games are not reality, and don't necessarily reflect it, people. If the player was able to violently murder Mr. Cobain and then dismember his corpse, then I could understand the outrage, but this is just a singer singing. Right?

      The issue here is that Activision are using Cobain in a way that he fought against most of his life.

      It's like everyone buying Che Gueverra T-Shirts. By purchasing the shirts, you are actively supporting the capitalism he died fighting against.

    In Rock Band it would always feel like a glitch when the female vocalist from your first song is then singing Mastadon in the next. Same applies to Guitar Hero WT when you see Ozzy Osbourne singing Willie Nelson. It seems like bad design, a programming error, idiotic and damaging to the vague sense of immersion in the plastic instrument genre. Music icons performing their own songs makes it just that bit more special. Alternatively while I’m fantasising, if you chose to play as Cobain the available song list could also include a song that’s in the game originally but has been covered by Nirvana. I know the masters for these rare tracks would be hard to come by, but the same song performed in 2 different ways while still respecting both the original performer and the iconic guest would be an ideal way for players to appreciate music from 2 different perspectives.

    maybe if courtney wasnt a junkie and actually paid attention to what activision were saying and doing we wouldnt have this situation right now. i was and still am a HUGE Nirvana fan and, although i dont think that Kurt should be able to be used for whatever, this is courtney's fault. It would be really good to see them enter into negotiations and maybe release GH Nirvana. Now that would be a KILLER game. I'd buy it for sure!

    What's the big deal? It's just a game. Jesus

      Wow. Really. You're going to put THAT out there?

      As somebody who considers themselves a gamer, is it really possible to say "it is just a game"?

      It is like saying it was just paper alliances that caused the First World War or simple racial discrimination that caused the Second.

      Whilst all of these may be true to an extent, they are completely dismissive of the full context of the actual issues.

      If somebody was to take your name and image and slander it amongst your peers and society in general, you'd hardly be willing to accept the excuse that "it's just words" so why would you accept such an unimaginative argument that "it's just a game"?

      That attitude of not caring about the consequences of your actions is EXACTLY the problem.

      If designers continue not to take any moral responsibility for their actions, then they are just as corrupt as every other greedy capitalist.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now