Ubisoft: Beyond Good & Evil 2 Must Be Perfect

Ubisoft CEO Yves Guillemot assured me today that work continues, has never stopped, on the highly anticipated sequel to 2003's Beyond Good & Evil.

"We were, as we are, working on the game," Guillemot told me during a meeting at Germany's Gamescom this week. "What is very import with this next product is that it will be perfect.

Developer Michel Ancel's "intention is to come [out]with something really exciting. But everybody needs a little bit of patience."

What makes Beyond Good & Evil 2 so significant to both Ubisoft and an industry powered, and sometimes limited by, great investments and huge profits, is that it is a sequel to a game that was, at least financially, a flop.

Guillemot said that Ubisoft was both happy and not happy with the reception of the original action-adventure game which had players taking on the role of reporter Jade who was investigating an alien conspiracy on her native planet. While the game received relatively strong reviews, sales were lacklustre.

"I would say the game was very well appreciated by the people who played it," Guillemot said. "But we didn't have enough people when it was launched. After its time it become a very recognised product."

Guillemot chalks the game's disappointing sales to the fact that the game pushed on the notions and conceptions of what people at the time expected a game to be.

This time around, with Beyond Good & Evil 2, Guillemot expects that the buzz already building around the game will help get more people to pick up the title in that critical first month of release. But it's still a risk.

So why do it?

"It's in our DNA to do innovative stuff because that's how the company was become what it is," he said.

And that doesn't strike me as a talking point or line from a press release when Guillemot says it and then quickly follows up the claim with a list of the titles that he says helped put Ubisoft on the map, help grow the company.

First, he says there was Rayman, a game the company head describes as a breakthrough in animation and one of the first platformer to hit stores that wasn't created in Japan.

"Rayman brought the western flavour," he said.

Then there was P.O.D. racing, one of the first games to support the MMX processors. It was bundled with some computers using the Intel chipset.

And there were both the Splinter Cell and Ghost Recon games, both new series that did tremendously well on the current and last consoles.

For this generation, Guillemot said, there is Assassin's Creed.

"The first Assassin's Creed was very innovative, but as with most innovation everything was not perfect. But then with the second game you go one step forward. You have to be able to start and come up with something that will be different first."

And those risks often pay off for Ubisoft. It did with Assassin's Creed, which delivered a sequel last year that was far better received than the original.

"You have to take risk," Guillemot said.

But sometimes the risks you take need to be in smaller markets. For instance, upcoming god game From Dust won't be released on a disk, instead it's coming on as a downloadable game for the Xbox Live Arcade and Playstation Network.

"When we do From Dust we are doing it on Xbox Live Arcade because there are not too many products on XBLA," Guillemot said. "Using a new format for a a new game can help the creators be seen. When you are in the crowd it's harder to be recognised at being innovative. The products on the market now, like Assassin's Creed and Call of Duty, are not perfect, but they close to perfect."

But often a victim of innovation is polish.

"It's difficult to be innovative and be perfect," he said. "Gamers love innovation but want perfection."

But that doesn't stop Ubisoft from taking risks, huge risks, risks like unveiling at this year's E3 a laser-tag game that uses plastic toy guns.

Guillemot calls Battle Tag a "next-generation" toy which using a machine, community and creativity to deliver something innovative.

The idea with Battle Tag is to have the people playing it create their own laser tag game modes and share them, it's a toy that will allow people to play one city against another or compete in worldwide competitions. It's also a toy meant to connect people.

Most of these ideas come from within the company, from teams who approach the management with concepts.

"When we have a team come to us with an idea we give them a certain amount of time to develop that idea," Guillemot said. "We are very open to new ideas."

That's how real-time strategy console game EndWar came about. And when it didn't do as well as expected, Ubisoft still approved the development of another real-time strategy game that tinkers with the formula of such titles.

R.U.S.E. has players using deceit along with standard tactics to trick players into losing military battles. Guillemot said that he is very intrigued with the use of the Move motion controller in the PlayStation 3 version of the game.

"The real-time strategy genre is not doing very well on the console because the interface doesn't work," Guillemot said. "The better the interface the more we will be able to give lots of fun to consumer playing those games on the console."

It's that same willingness to continue to try in the face of occasional financial failure that allows developers like Michel Ancel to make a sequel to a game that wasn't a tremendous success.

Beyond Good & Evil 2 is the sort of title that gamers should love when it comes out, not just because of its content and its pedigree, but because of what it says about a company still willing to take risks despite the potential costs.


    After playing through Beyond Good & Evil for the first time a couple of months ago, I really can't wait for the sequel. It was great fun, with amusing characters and decent story.

    Although I'm almost certain the sequel will feature completely different gameplay (unfortunately).

    I think that one of the reasons that sales were so slow is that the game was so short. I remember there always being a steady stream of second hand copies being available, which is how I got mine. Also, there was pretty much no advertising behind it as I recall. Hopefully both of those issues will be fixed for this sequel, as the first game really was a charming experience :)

    I didn't think it was too short, I recall taking a fair amount of time to play it, but it was probably short for the time in which it came out.

    But really BG&E 1 was the closest anyone's got to creating a Zelda like experience that didn't feel cheap to me. In fact when I say closest anyone's got, I would hold up BG&E to be as good as many Zelda games.

    I think Ubisoft has the right idea and I hope to see their company grow even more into the future. I hate it when a company creates a new idea and expects 10 million copies out the door...ideas take time to ferment and although it won't always work out with a hit franchise (eg Red Steel, at least commercially) but the occasional hit franchise eg Assassin's Creed, will certainly make it all worth while in the end.

    I suspect following up a game that was a sleeper and dare i say cult classic would be more tricky than following up a commercially successfull franchise that ubisoft are so good at generating (splintercell etc).

    Not just graphic engine upgrade> new feature> new story> repeat.

    Good on them for taking it seriously, thats got to be a risky move for a developer.

      Exactly! I think of it with a lot of cult movies or short lived TV series.

      I've always thought, with its status as a cult classic and committed fanbase, why can't Whdeon bring back Firefly or a do a sequel to Serenity.

      But I think, they're perfect as they are. I know a man like him, I choose to believe, wouldn't eff up a revamp or sequel. But it may feel different, look different. I don't wanna spoil what WE have just to experience a little more.

    I think one of the biggest problems for Beyond Good and Evil was lack of advertising. I heard about it in the back of a gaming mag, in an article about the years most over-looked games.

    After seeing me play, two of my friends went out and bought it.
    It was just lucky I happened to read that article on the crapper that day!

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now