Review: Kinect

Microsoft says that Kinect is the next big thing for video games, a way to control both games and TV without touching a thing. This expensive future is now. It's amazing, but you can wait for it.

The Kinect sensor is a device that plugs into an Xbox 360 controller and uses a combination of cameras and microphones to identify and track the movements of a person standing in front of it, as well as enabling voice control of games and video running on your TV. Wave your hands to play a game? Get your posture corrected by a virtual personal trainer? Tell ESPN to pause? Kinect does that.

Ideal Player Kinect's launch offerings have something for everyone, even those who don't play games, but, for now, Kinect is a device for people with extra money and — very important — a lot of room in front of their TV, a lot.

Why You Should Care Kinect isn't just hype. It is technology that goes beyond the microphones and cameras we've seen attached to game console before. It is sci-fi technology that Microsoft will be spending a lot of money to support for a while. Kinect isn't going anyway, so you might as well try it at some point. You might just love it.

Does Kinect really feel like something new? No doubt about it. The first time I used Kinect from my home couch to control my TV with simple hand gestures. I got chills. Sounds corny, but it felt like I was doing something extraordinary, just lifting my hand and using it to move a cursor around the screen. The fact that there is now a piece of technology we can hook up to our Xbox that can see whether we are dancing in time to Lady Gaga is amazing. It feels magical, except....

Does it work well? Or do you have to be in a lab to get it to operate right? Kotaku editor-in-chief Brian Crecente and I each used Kinects in our home with a variety of games for about a week before the November 4 launch. We've both had issues with some Kinect games not recognising a gesture here or being slow to respond to another. We've each had the voice-control fail us once in a while, forcing us to repeat whatever we barked at the Kinect. He's had it worse, seeing some games simply break, like the time Kinect Sports didn't let him detach a virtual bowling ball from his virtual hand. But it is impossible to say if the flaw is in the Kinect hardware or in the games. Some games, such as Dance Central and Kinectimals, are polished and seldom show cracks. Others suffer. Such are the problems that happen at the launch of hardware and software. Only time can show where the improvement can and will happen.

Is this basically the Wii all over again? Sort of. The Wii was a shock to gaming. Motion control was not mainstream and Nintendo smartly introduced it to the masses with a small number of games that worked well with a small number of gestures. It succeeded magnificently because of that relatively conservative strategy. Kinect, on the other hand, is as ambitious as it is scattershot. Ignore the gaming aspects and Kinect still feels important as a viable new way to use voice and gesture to control downloaded movies through the Xbox's Zune channel or to watch sporting events streamed through the regional ESPN3. The launch games are so diverse that and the options for control input with gesture and voice are so far-ranging that they can't help but fail to do any one thing excellently. There's no Wii Sports in the line-up. Is it the Wii again, though? Well... there's a workout game, a sports compilation, an arcade racer and so on... the imitation is shameless.

Does it replace the game controller? No. Some Kinect games feel like they'd be better with a controller. Others, like Dance Central, wouldn't be as fun. A comparison to a controller is apt, though, because gesturing to control a game feels as relatively convoluted and slightly slow as using a control stick. Kinect voice control, on the other hand, feels like it can be as precise as pressing a button. Buttons and control sticks together are a great combo; voice and gesture feel like just as terrific a pairing. This is the right Kinect combo, a pity the launch games go so heavy on gesture and so light on voice.

The worst knock on Kinect seems to be that it needs a lot of room. True? Sadly, yes. You can play single-player Kinect games at the same distance you've held a wired game controller plugged into a game console. For multiplayer or for more dynamic dancing and workout games you need more room than you do to play four-player Wii Sports tennis, more room than you need to jam with a full group in Rock Band. Can you fit a pool table in front of your TV? You'll need about that much room, because the Kinect sensor needs to see you. Can't be too close; can't be to far to the side. Be it my Brooklyn condo or Crecente's more standard-sized Denver house, we both had to adjust our living rooms to fully enjoy Kinect. Those with cramped quarters could find Kinect to be a non-starter.

Microsoft says this is essentially a new console, that Kinect is a new platform. True? Maybe, but it's at least right to say that Kinect is launching the way a new console does, with raw potential and some half-baked execution. At launch you can discover wonderful details, like the fact that Dance Central and Kinect Joy Ride pause when you step away from your TV. But you can also find frustration at games that don't share the same methods for skipping cut-scenes or advancing through menus. Without a controller in your hand, you will feel less capable of figuring out what's wrong, of tapping a button with elevator-door-close urgency to remedy a situation. It's confusing to be using a Kinect on day one. You fall in love with the voice control, as I did, but then you switch from ESPN to Zune and discover that the former doesn't use the same voice controls as the latter. These wrinkles need ironing.

But the million-dollar question is: Is it worth $US150? The Kinect comes with a full game, Kinect Adventures, which will take some of the sting out of the price. But it also comes with the inconsistencies described above and the lack of a killer app, the lack of a perfect game. Kinect launches in a state that merits a visit to your friend's house if you hear he or she has it. But it's not must-own yet, more like must-eventually own.

Kinect In Action

The Bottom Line It was ironic that in searching for an electric socket in which to plug my Kinect a week ago, I had to unplug my Wii. I now need to find a second socket. Kinect doesn't replace the Wii any more than it does an Xbox controller. It's not even a sure thing as a games platform, not until it has its first great game. But it doesn't have to be. If Kinect becomes nothing more than a replacement for the TV remote, it's a winner. Right now, at its price, it needs to be more. If Microsoft keeps supporting it and if its flaws can be patched and improved through software, it can be revolutionary.

Kinect was developed by and published by Microsoft for the Xbox 360, released on November 4. Retails for $US149.99, bundled with a copy of Kinect Adventures. Two Kinect sensors were given to us by Microsoft for reviewing purposes.We used Kinect extensively each for the better part of the week. Came for the gesture control; got won over by the voice-control.


Comments

    Neat kick animation at 3:07. Haha! It appears that they aimed too high and fell short. Maybe Nintendo or someone else can put it all together correctly without the delay.

      @Alastair (Highjacking your post)

      I think I know the game for the geeks everywhere...Star Trek. I'm calling it out now. If you are the Captain sitting in you seat(couch) commanding the enterprise. I know I would love that. The TV would be the view screen, You could point to attack specific targets naming what weapons you would like to use. Calling for evasive action. etc etc. I cannot imagine a better idea!

    'But it’s not must-own yet, more like must-eventually own.'
    That sums it up for me. I think that the technology is amazing, and MS will likely find numerous applications outside of console gaming (particularly in multimedia usage), and thus the Kinect will eventually become a standard. Until then, the lack of a 'killer app' means I can't justify the price for what amounts to an experiment in alternate control schemes.

      Bingo. This, and Totilo's last sentence, are how I feel and what I'll be waiting for.

    Hey! I have that Ikea TV unit too!

    It doesn't really sound very enticing. Not something I want to pay for, rather spend the money on a good steering wheel for GT5...if it comes out.

    the space requirement is the real killer for me i like many people have my xbox in my room and my tv has less tahn 2 feet of space infront of it before it reaches the bed

    So, tonnes of potential, but very little actually realised. It's about what I expected. I'm genuinely interested in this thing but there are several things holding me back

    1) Price. I'm not going to shell out close to a Wii console for this thing. Especially with Playstation Move costing roughly the same as a new release game.

    2) Not enough must-have launch titles. Child of Eden looks fantastic, but will have to wait and see.

    3) Execution of current titles. The Driving minigame that requires you to stand up and use BOTH hands on the virtual steering wheel at all times? This is even more annoying than real driving. At least I can take one hand off to scratch my nose or something without crashing.

    4) Space. My 'main' set-up for most of the year is a tiny room next to my bed at college with all 3 consoles stacked on top of each other with an old-school TV on top of a bar fridge.

      agree with those points especially 2, 3, and 4.

      it seems they dont care about japan at all with kinect needing a big area. fail. epic fail? looks like it.

    I think MS will end up incorporating gesture-control technologies into the next Xbox. Kinect at the moment doesn't have any games that interest me, however.

Join the discussion!