R18+: Let's Just Get This Thing Done

“And so it goes,” read the article in New Matilda, “conservatives flailing in moral panic as gamers parade their seemingly indefatigable and adolescent sense of entitlement.”

One of the most frustrating situations I had to deal with this week was an article, discussing the R18+ debate, in which I was quoted. To be perfectly fair, I found a lot of common ground with some of the arguments and sympathised on some level, but one thing bothered me in particular.

Surprisingly enough, it wasn’t the fact that I was quoted out of context - which I was - but they apologised and even added a note to the piece after I clarified my point. It wasn’t even the fact that they framed a strange Straw Man argument, and then conveniently avoided bringing anything valuable to the table in return.

It was this part:

“By focusing on the frankly trivial issue of R18+ games, we are missing out on much more relevant debates about the classification of entertainment.”

And then later - a suggestion that larger issues of classification were being derailed by a “mediocre, vapid bun fight over video games.”

I felt like screaming from the rooftops. Do people actually think gamers enjoy this charade? That this is our time to bask in the glorious rays of mainstream media attention – that we’re happy to see this issue being dragged out, beaten to death with the same old arguments, the same old pointless bickering.

Of course not.

Just to clarify – the article in question claimed that the endless squabble between gamers, politicians and lobby groups over the “trivial” R18+ issue was distracting politicians from what was really important – a long overdue discussion on broader classification and the attitudes of decision makers towards sexuality as a whole.

Let’s be clear here – I completely agree. In fact, I couldn’t agree more. The R18+ issue, in the grand scheme of things, is absolutely trivial. Completely.

That’s precisely why we just need to get this “trivial” thing over and done with.

Yesterday Brendan O’Connor released the draft guidelines, presented to the Attorneys-General in anticipation of the SCAG meeting in July. After the release there seemed to be more squabbling. Almost on cue the ACL claimed the guidelines “failed families”, but they haven’t brought anything new to the debate in a decade so we can completely ignore anything they have to say. Of more interest was the squabbling over specifics – is the wording too vague? Why does it say this instead that.

Questions to which I say – let’s just get this thing done.

Because, despite our differences, this is the one area where the New Matilda piece gets it absolutely right – R18+ is distracting politicians from doing their job (ironic since most politicians do a decent job of distracting the public from the fact that they can’t do their job).

This is precisely why Brendan O’Connor is attempting to push R18+ through this July, in order to free up the Australian Law Reform Commission to tackle the larger issue of classification in this country. This is precisely why the iGEA were completely happy to let the issue slide until R18+ was put back on the SCAG agenda.

And personally, do I want to spend the rest of my life writing the precise same article over and over again until oblivion? No thanks. I got into this gig to write about video games, not politics. The only people who enjoy this political equivalent of Groundhog Day are those who gain political mileage from the situation – and I’ll let you take a wild guess who that is.

Let’s just get this thing done.

In the grand scheme of things it doesn’t really matter anyway. The ALRC will no doubt present findings that will revolutionise the way we classify content in this country. Hopefully the decision makers will listen and change things accordingly. We may even have a system in place that allows the games industry to responsibly self-regulate. We may have more consistency; we may have less - who knows?

Regardless, the ALRC will no doubt do a better job once the R18+ issue is done and dusted and they no longer have to engage in this hoopla for the remaining six months of their investigations.

Again, I’ll be clear - R18+ is trivial. It’s trivial because the correct answer has been staring us in the face for the past decade and, quite frankly, I’m getting a little bit bored.

Let’s just get this thing done.


Comments

    I've been watching and reading a lot of stuff about censorship in the past week - not games, but music and film, particularly the MPAA and the PRMC.

    Though the PRMC is two decades old now and the MPAA's membership has (possibly?) changed, its interesting to note that this conservatism, fear-mongering and a reliance on advocacy groups and the government to compensate for parents' inability to raise their children isn't exactly a new phenomenon.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxxzXOrG690
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U9E20lxsTs&feature=related
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UTL3XMDwY0c

    and it's true it's why i wish the SCAG would stop dragging the thing out.

    At this point i don't much care what the rating is anymore. Since with the internets everything comes from foreign soil and ignores any petty arguements our country might have agaisnt it.

    I'm starting to think that AG's are like me when it comes to uni assignments. The night before the SCAG meeting the try cramming as much knowledge about the topic in their head, get to the meeting the next day and decide they aren't ready to present their finding's.

    Must have loved it when Atkinson was there "eh we can ignore that it's got no hope".

    the thing is while the whole SCAG thing is meant to be unanimous my belief is that it's meant to be unanimous so that Vic,Qld,NSW,SA can't form an alliance so they can screw WA out of something.

    The fact is that the R18+ rating doesn't have any of those connotation's. It's majority rule isn't going ahead because it can steal some of the mining money or what not. The policy puts no state at an advantage or disadvantage to any other. It's probably one of the few decisions that shouldn't need a unanimous ruling(since there are reasons it exists)

    Indeed. The paperwork and documents in the national archives on this issue should be gathering 7 years of dust by now.
    Here is hoping we don't have to facepalm too many more times before this is over and done with. Then we can stop facepalming at games being inappropriately under-classified into MA15+ as well.

    I think the draft isn't very good for 18+ gamers. RC content will still be there and they will just push the MA15+ games to R18 and the games that should have been R18 will just get RC again.
    No benefit for adult gamers, just benefits for retarded parents who don't pay attention to what their children are playing.

    "ironic since most politicians do a decent job of distracting the public from the fact that they can’t do their job"

    Priceless.

    Once again it's the self proclaimed Christian groups that act in the most anti-christian way, throwing tantrums about things they don't approve of like video games or same sex marriaged. Both have more benefits than not if legalized in Australia,

    Proudly importing all my video games since 2010, currently playing Mortal Kombat!!

    In all seriousness I gave up on the Australian Govt a long time ago, and seeing how nearly everything tech based i own i import, i'm past caring about this issue.

    Why pass a law on the entire population when "Gamers" are such a small minority.
    P.S.
    Bikers dont bother me either

    Left the ACL a big comment on it all on that post linked in this article, hope they approve it!

      Nope, didn't like it. :P

      Didn't attack them personally so it must have had too many good points or something.

    Could not agree more. On everything from how this should've been resolved a decade ago, to the fact that media debacles make great distractions on them not doing their jobs. ;)

    It seems trivial because it has taken an inordinate amount of time to resolve and bring us up to date with every other western country's standards in the world. I don't enjoy being the but-end of gaming jokes about it eiher.

    All these ignorant people thinking we are not a nanny state.
    Come on, we are the worlds joke. We are at least 20 years behind the rest of the world with everything. We are ripped off left and right. I don't even care about this R18 rating, Im still purchasing everything overseas and avoiding these ridiculous 200% markups for everything.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now