If Haruki Murakami's New Book Were Sold Like A Video Game

It's easy to buy a book. It's easy to be someone who buys books. Go to the store, pay some cash, walk out with the book. Or go online, punch in your credit card info and the book comes to your door. Or maybe you just turn on your Kindle and the book is yours in moments.

It's not so easy to get a new video game. No, getting a game is a process. It lasts as long as a pregnancy and offers almost as many hassles. You can read about the rocky nature of Battlefield 3's launch or the confusion over Arkham City's online pass and raft of pre-order options for examples of this.

But another way to make this point, another way to show how good book-readers have it, is to imagine if something similar had happened with the hottest new book this season: Haruki Murakami's newest novel, 1Q84.

It started in January...


Are you guys as excited to finally check out Haruki Murakami's new novel 1Q84 as I am? Because boy, I am really looking forward to reading it. I've been following his work for a long time, and it sounds like this book is on a whole new level. Can't wait.


Oh man, at Lit-Fest 2011, Murakami's publisher Shinchosha totally stole the show! They took us to a huge theatre and played a blasting recording of Ian McShane reading the second chapter of the book. It was amazing! There was all this stuff about the nature of reality, it was bleak and beautiful. Hang on, gonna go pre-order.


Hmm, it's been a month and I still can't decide: Should I pre-order through Amazon, or through Barnes & Noble? It looks like Amazon gets a special bonus of a foreword from the author… that would be pretty cool to read. Oh, but Barnes & Noble has a special bonus chapter in the book itself, which folds seamlessly into the narrative. Hmm. I remember preordering from Barnes & Noble once and when I went to get the book, they didn't have it.


Oh look at that, if I pre-order on Kindle, I get a different bonus chapter, which re-imagines 1Q84 as if it starred Kafka from Kafka on the Shore. Well that sounds cool! Aw man, hopefully I'll be able to buy all of these bonus chapters later.


They announced a release date! That's great. He must be almost done with the book, which is exciting. Somewhere, 1Q84 exists, and it's readable!

Hang on, my friend is telling me that in the UK, they get both bonus chapters at both Amazon and Barnes & Noble, but not the forward. Wow, this is getting complicated. Hmm… I guess I'll go with Barnes & Noble, and I'll probably get it on Kindle, too?


Gosh am I excited about the 1Q84 Beta that's coming up! I heard that Murakami is still polishing the final book, but that he wanted to see how his distribution channels are working, and make sure that we can all get the book, that the translation is OK, and that we understand it. That's good, you want to be sure that stuff is working!

But really, I'm just excited to finally get to read some of it! I've been waiting for this book for so long, getting an advance taste will be amazing.


What the shit. I am pretty disappointed in this beta. This book just isn't finished! Man, there was a part in Chapter 3 where every time I turned the page, it was the same page again, over and over and over… I kept having to start over from the beginning, nothing made any sense! The translation seems off, like they're having trouble getting the words right.

I know this has been an issue with his books in the past, and that they've always worked it out, but this has me concerned. It's so close to publication — maybe the book just isn't ready?


Sounds like a lot of people are cancelling their pre-orders. I'm gonna stick it out, though. This whole thing is so frustrating and weird, I'm sick of wondering if I'm getting the best preorder chapters. I just like Murakami, and I want to read his damn book! When did everything get so complicated?

All I know is I'm glad I'm getting the book new, since there's a whole main character who's left out of used copies. It changes the story significantly! I mean, the first chapter is even different. Not sure how I feel about that, except that I want to be sure to get those chapters in my copy.


The book comes out next month! I've switched my pre-order a couple of times, but wound up on Amazon, since they threw in a limited edition dust jacket if I pre-order their version.

I'm kind of exhausted about worrying about whether or not the book will be finished when I read it, and hope that even if it's messed up, Murakami will fix it afterwards by issuing some better chapters.


The book arrived today and, well, things have been weird. For a while, it wouldn't open—the cover seemed glued shut? So I pushed and prodded it for a while, then turned to customer support. They said they'd get back to me, but were kinda vague… I think they're overwhelmed at the moment.

Update: I looked on Twitter, and it sounds like everyone else who got the book is having the same issues. Even professional book reviewers! Wow, I thought those guys always got publisher-approved, mint-condition copies of books. Guess not.

A few people on a message board said that if you microwave the book for a certain number of seconds, it opens. Against my better judgement, I tried it, and it worked!

But even with the book open, things are still dicey. Everything's blurry, and I think there's an incompatibility with my reading glasses. Customer support says that they're sending out updated text soon, but it hasn't arrived yet. They've been so slow to respond, I'm not sure what to do. And the book keeps closing on me as I'm reading it, too. It's pretty frustrating.

Later That Week

Well, I got the new text, and the book works with my glasses. It's a pretty good book! Still shuts randomly sometimes, and some of the text is kinda garbled, but I'm sure that's just a translation thing that they'll fix eventually.

Earlier today I happened upon my old copy of After Dark, and started re-reading it. I wound up reading until like three in the morning. Man, that was a really good book.


    Haruki Murakami’s new book? So how's a casual going for you?

    You're the reason us hardcore readers get stuck with this rushed, cookie cutter rubbish.

    This is the most brilliant thing I've read on Kotaku that isn't from Serrells.

    Please post review about 1Q84.

      And what? Assign an arbitrary number to a work of literature based purely on the reviewers concept of what is and isn't a good?

      Whats the difference between a book that gets an 8.5 and a book that gets an 8 A-a-a.

      Hamilton will probably give it a low score just to get some attention, because its the only way to draw readers in.

    Fucking Amatards. Barnes and Noble have smoother page turning by about 0.02s per turn, and not to mention you dont have to pay extra for MR (multireader).

    I suppose they're better than Borders. You may as well just be reading it on stone tablet!

      But Borders always have the awesome alternative book skins.

        Pft but then you're locked into crappy motion controls. Here's a tip, NO ONE WANTS TO WAVE THEIR HAND OVER THE PAGE WHILE THEY SHAKE THE BOOK TO TURN THE PAGE!

    No idea who this person is, no idea of their previous works, thanks for an intro and information on them.


    sorry some of this is retarded.
    no one forces you to pre-order, no one forces you to closely monitor news on the game.
    Wait til the game has been out for a week (so it actually kinda works), read the reviews, play a demo if one exists, buy it.
    Granted yes, PC gaming sometimes makes me long for the day i just would stick my secret of mana cartridge in and it *would* *just* *work*.

      You're right nobody forces you too but you do anyway, anyone who cares about a particular games release goes through these steps just about every time

        Apart from me i guess. Even if I'm excited about a particuliar game, I'll often wait til i can get it as a GOTY edition or something- all the DLC for free and less bugs.

    What really annoys me is that if I buy this from a used book store, I have to send the publisher $10 to be able to read the proper ending of chapter 4.

    I got a friend who bought the physical version (special edition hardcover) to photocopy the entire book for me.

    It's not like I was going to buy it anyway, so they don't lose any money.

    i got a ripped version off the net. Its missing all the dialogue, but reads just fine apart from that.

    I just pirated my copy. I mean it was a bit hard at first to find out the correct way through the neighbours fence, but I know how, I get everything that way. Books, movies, groceries, you name it.
    They recently installed Dog based DRM, so now I have a new pet too!

    I heard they took out chapters 13 and 14 before release and are making them available as a separate novella later. And man, that one reviewer that gave the book an 8 instead of a 10? He got roasted by fans...

    What exactly does this have to do with a video games?

      It's essentially a "what if the buildup for books was like in a videogame?"


    Book Movie Song Game Painting

    The formats are too different to compare in this way.

    The story highlights the problems with some AAA games we all know about, but ultimately says nothing in a clever way.

    How about an article written in the same format that addresses the noisy issues in the AAA games industry in a constructive way Kotaku?

    I really dig ur post.
    am not sure if it's a coincidence that i beast on Black Ops...

    This is easily my favorite article of the week. Excellent job, Kirk!

    No mention of the multi-player? I wanna know how good this book will be to read with my friends. We used to read those Choose-your-own-adventure books, but i got kicked for haxxing cause i was holding my thumb between the pages so i could go back.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now