Game Critics Turn Back The Score Clock On Final Fantasy XIII-2

Tomorrow marks the second time in Final Fantasy history that Square Enix releases a direct console sequel to one of the numbered entries in the fabled series. Considering the first time around we got a trio of pop divas playing dress-up, this one has to be better, right game reviewers?

We've seen how I feel about Final Fantasy XIII-2, now it's time to take a look at how the rest of the game reviewing world handled the time travels of main character's sister and her Kingdom Hearts refugee-looking sidekick. Has Square made up for Final Fantasy XIII? Can Square make up for Final Fantasy XIII?

When the dust clears tomorrow and the game is in the hands of North American fans, perhaps the series' harshest critics, none of this will matter. For now, bring on the assembled video game reviewers.

Joystiq There was once a time when "Final Fantasy" meant greatness, when seeing Square's brand on a game box meant you were about to play something special. That time has long since passed. In today's gaming landscape, Final Fantasy is more punchline than powerhouse, more quantity than quality. After the mediocre Final Fantasy XIII and the sheer disaster that was Final Fantasy XIV, many fans have lost faith in the RPG titan. Final Fantasy XIII-2 is the publisher's attempt to mend this relationship. At times, it feels like the development team just went down a laundry list and added everything that fans believed Final Fantasy XIII lacked. Non-linear dungeons? Check. Sidequests? Check. NPCs and towns? Check, check. In other words, the whole game seems like one big apology.

Gamespot That isn't to say Final Fantasy XIII-2 is as epic an adventure as you may have expected. The story isn't long as far as Japanese role-playing games go — maybe 25 hours for a standard playthrough. There are reasons to linger or return if you're the completionist type, but the length is a consideration for series fans hoping for a Final Fantasy-sized adventure. If those 25 hours were jam-packed with challenging action and dramatic cutscenes, perhaps you wouldn't notice the story's brevity. Alas, a lengthy fetch quest makes the game drag considerably, as does a protracted platforming sequence that causes the pace to chug as you near the conclusion, right when you'd expect the tempo to take off. The cinematics and battles both burst with occasional thrills, but it's as if developer Square Enix decided that unnecessary padding was the proper solution to the problem of Final Fantasy XIII's overly linear progression.

IGN Environments no longer follow a single path. With webs of rooms to explore and treasure chests hidden off the map, Final Fantasy XIII-2 encourages you to take your time and look around. You can access these environments, which dot the timeline, in more than one order. While a general flow from one place to another moves the plot along, the freedom to sidetrack greatly enhances the explorative flavour.

More impressively, you can unlock the ability to close time gates and start the area from scratch, correcting mistakes or just trying something new. This functions as a literal "reset button" mid-game. This sense of freedom, even if you choose to ignore it, helps Final Fantasy XIII-2 feel more like a traditional RPG where discovery dominates the experience.

Game Informer The combat of FF XIII returns in a familiar yet improved form, resulting in my new favourite battle system in the Final Fantasy series. Fights require a satisfying mix of strategic management and direct control, forcing you to switch your tactics and adapt to changing conditions. Quickly shift to a defensive paradigm when a boss is about to use a powerful attack, or use a buffing/debuffing paradigm to prepare for a long battle. It's a little easier than the last one, but remains fun and fast-paced, without the minor annoyances that got in the way in FF XIII.

The biggest addition to battle is monster collection, which isn't just an optional side-activity. You'll always have Noel and Serah in your party, and the third slot is occupied by a monster that you've caught by defeating (no Pokéballs necessary). Each monster has a role that you can level up and use to build your paradigms. For instance, Feral Behemoths are commandos, Blue Chocobos are ravagers, and Cait Siths are medics. You need to consider these roles along with Serah's and Noel's aptitudes when forming your paradigms. This adds a level of customisation and versatility that you didn't have with your party before. Plus, finally obtaining a powerful monster that you've been hunting delivers an extremely satisfying thrill.

Eurogamer The hotchpotch world design - which feels as though a hundred artists went off into separate rooms to work on different places in isolation, before coming together to merge their work into a lumpy whole - is more forgiveable here than it was in Final Fantasy 13. The inconsistent art is explained away by the game's structure. However, the world lacks a coherent sense of place, not least because there's no sense of geography; after all, you access different locations from a menu screen.

It was a bold move on Square Enix's part to ask fans that struggled to engage with Final Fantasy 13's world to suddenly care about multiple versions of that world. Beyond the raw video game draw of solving each location's problems, few players will care about piecing together the jigsaw of its story.

Official Xbox Magazine It's easy to see how Square Enix took the feedback from FF XIII and used it to make a better product, but this follow-up still has some lingering issues. Every so often you'll encounter an obnoxious gimmick sequence, such as a giant time-jumping fetch quest, a series of out-of-place logic puzzles, or constantly regenerating and unavoidable Cie'th enemy hordes chasing you throughout a massive maze. Plus, the story falters at times, falling victim to leaps of logic and silliness, and dialogue exchanges often feel like characters are simply talking at each other rather than truly interacting. The trademark Square Enix CG is sparse, with most story sequences rendered in-engine. But perhaps most annoying are the technical issues: framerates drop precipitously when a lot is happening onscreen, and this sequel's few movie sequences frequently suffer from hideously artifacted compression.

Kotaku It's impossible to talk about the triumphs of Final Fantasy XIII-2 without touching on the failures of Final Fantasy XIII. Fortunately this is because in order to fully appreciate how good the second game is one really needs to have experience the first. Final Fantasy XIII was the shadow of an excellent game. Final Fantasy XIII-2 steps into the light, a much more tangible, spectacular, and fully-realized experience. Apology accepted.

80 isn't the end of the world.


Comments

    Interesting point: the review scores are lower than the original XIII, but most reviews say this builds upon the failures of XIII ... not that scores mean anything, but still...

      Not enough in the moneyhat this time around... :)

    The compressed video concerns me... They did the same thing in Deus Ex... Surely this should have been a thing of the past

      I would imagine that the compression artefacts are Xbox only due to the limited space on DVD's, which would also explain why their is so few CG cut scenes.

        i thought the same thing but deus ex on ps3 had terrible compression on the video sequences. Oh well. Not the end of the world

      And people say they don't want next gen yet! Wat the?!

        And a solution to compressed videos being more powerful hardware. Wat the?!

    What I'm wondering is did FF13 lower the expectations that people praise what should have been in the original?

    Edge gave it a 5/10.

      I often read their reviews and have always found them fair minded. I just think they don't subscribe to the paradigm that an average game deserves a 9 out of 10. They explained what they didn't like and it sounded fair, although I haven't played the game. I am still interested in it, and think I have a good idea what to expect.

      Maybe don't just casually throw around an accusation of bribery, alright bigfella?

    Game Informer called the story "laughable & borderline insulting" lol

    The Boss battle music in the form of a rap song has turned me off 13-2 entirely. XD

    The people in charge of this series really needs to take a step back and realise why people are loosing interest. They are making the same mistakes over and over.

    - Shit stories
    - Shit Character Personalities
    - Shit Character Design
    - Shit voice acting
    - Shit battle system
    - Shit music

    Just shit

    Maybe I've just been spoilt with fantastic western games like Uncharted.

      Whilst I did not like FF13 nor it's sequel based on the demo, you sound like someone has not played either.

      The story is actually pretty decent, had SE not bungled up the way it was told and the way it connected with the characters, nonetheless that doesn't retract from the fact that the story is there. The music is far from shit and is actually some of the best in the franchise as it was composed by a SE veteran.

      I thought the character development in FFXIII was the best the series has seen since VI, but I think most people didn't get beyond "corridor LOL", Hope's initial whining and Vanille's godawful voice actress to care. The story had an interesting idea but they didn't execute it very well. The combat system was pretty decent but they didn't execute that right either (It would have helped a lot if you could physically move the characters). The levelling system was the worst since VIII.

      It was not the terrible game some have made it out to be, but it was disappointing for how long it was in development. If XIII-2 polishes up some of the flaws of XIII it's probably a very worthwhile game.

    There's a solution. Buy every game that hironobu sakaguchi and tetsuya takahashi make.

      Blue Dragon is shit.

    I wish they made a REAL final fantasy

    I played the demo and didn't enjoy it at all. And after watching & reading reviews online I'm not convinced enough to shell out money for this FF game, and I shelled out upwards of $40+ on the old FF games off the PSN this week (January sale)

    FF13 really disappointed me as a fan and the only way I'll bother with this title is if I can find it extremely cheap or borrow it off a friend first to check it out.

    Now if you'll excuse me, I've got a Resident Evil game and a Metal Gear collection to buy this week

    Im so pissed off with Final fantasy I dont even want to read those reviews.

    The first 2 slabs said everything that needed to be said.

    Even if they decided to make sequels/remakes of 7 and 8, the people that uphold those games as the best would disregard and reject the sequel/remake, as we all know that Square (Unfortunately now Squenix) are over the hill.

    If they want to fix FF, they need me to show them how it's done.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now