Early Mass Effect 3 Winners May Have Jumped Into Legal Hot Water

The two men who won an early copy of Mass Effect 3 this weekend may have broken both state and federal in the US laws by trying to raffle it off.

Two weeks ago, publisher Electronic Arts took copies of the sci-fi role-playing game and launched them into space on weather balloons. GPS devices were attached to each balloon, so dedicated fans could track down landing points and get their paws on early copies of the highly anticipated game, which comes out for PC, Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 on March 6.

This past weekend, videomakers Michael Davis and Miguel Droz uncovered a copy of the game in the Arizona desert. On Sunday, they decided to raffle it off. Interested gamers could pay $US5 for a ticket and a chance to get the winning number, as determined by a random generator. Davis and Droz said that 30 per cent of the proceeds would go to the Child's Play charity organisation — and that the rest would go to the video game company they hope to open.

But by choosing to raffle off the game and keep some of the proceeds, Davis and Droz may be subject to "potential criminal penalties," says attorney Mark Methenitis. According to state law in Nevada, where the pair say they are based, lotteries are only legal if all of the funds go to charity.

"They're running an illegal lottery which subjects them to potential criminal penalties."

"You can pretty much never rely on a charitable gaming exemption unless 100 per cent of the money goes to a charity (though you can often use part of the funds to cover event costs, i.e. dealers at a charity casino night)," Methenitis said in an email to Kotaku. "Diverting the funds here is about as clear cut as you can get; they're using the funds for personal gain."

Though Methenitis does not practice in Nevada, he says he has experience with similar laws in other states. In addition, since Davis and Droz are accepting entries across US state lines, Methenitis says it's both a state and a federal issue.

"In short, they're running an illegal lottery which subjects them to potential criminal penalties," Methenitis said. "I would imagine that Child's Play, if they knew what was going on, would not want to be involved. I won't even get into the issues with the IRS that could come up here."

Although Davis and Droz say they will match whatever they earn by donating that amount to Child's Play at some point within the next few years, Methenitis says that's irrelevant. The raffle is still illegal.

Kotaku has reached out to both Child's Play and Electronic Arts for comment. We also reached out to Davis and Droz this morning, but as of this writing, they have not yet responded.


    surely ebay wouldve been the smarter way to flog the game off for nice profit?

    "donating that amount to Child’s Play at some point within the next few years"

    This bit is pretty important. This is probably where some of the good will is lost.

      Yeah, it's a bit Brian Butterfield there.

      "We'll do the right thing at our leisure some time in the future. Not right now, but don't worry - we promise."

    I told my friend about this, and his response was "I guess its better than the 4chan guy that found it and poop'd on them".
    He has a point?

      You have the best friends, Bish.

        "Bish says:
        I did not even know about the 4chan guy
        well, the more you know
        He says:
        I helped"

      What a glorious day that was in 4chan. Just shows how much they hate anything with Bioware tagged on it.

      Can you elaborate on this story please? Colour me intrigued.

    Haha i told you people somebody would get sued over this publicity stunt!

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now