Are video games art? This question has been bothering gamers, journalists and critics alike for a long while. Proponents might say that art is subjective, that anything capable of eliciting a deep emotional response could be considered art. Then, perhaps, there is no greater argument for calling video games art than Team ICO's work.
Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, released in 2001 and 2005, respectively, left a huge mark on the PlayStation 2 community. Both instant classics, they won over their audience with their unique atmosphere, emotional story, deep characters, and fresh gameplay. No wonder then, that players of these two games eagerly await the series' next instalment. An instalment which, much to their chagrin, has been delayed time and time again.
Team ICO creative lead Fumito Ueda's latest creation, The Last Guardian, suffered many hurdles during its development. In this Kotaku Timeline, we follow TLG's evolution from just a rumour to a solid, confirmed title. We look at when, why, and how Sony delayed the game, and also collect all the details and bits of information they, and Team ICO, released. We will also remain on the lookout for announcements and events, both good and bad, in the future.
It all started with a Sony meet for an unrelated game in 2007. And so that's where our timeline begins...
May 18 — Something is rotten in Germany
At a German Sony-organized MotorStorm
-related event, a Sony employee reveals to a fan
that Team ICO is working on two games. Wow, two games! None of it gets confirmed, of course, but it's something
October 10 — The Last Canyon? What is that?
, with the help
of Game Informer's
Andy McNamara, squashes the rumour
that Team ICO's new game would involve deserts, gliders and lots of canyons.
January 24 — The teasing begins
Sony Japan updates Team ICO's career page with an image, and an announcement that they're now hiring for the developer's next project.
August 4 — At least we know it'll be good
Yoshida: "They haven't released a PS3 title yet — but they have something really, really good on the way."
Sony's Shuhei Yoshida asks everyone
to be patient — the wait will be worth it.
August 6 — The creator speaks
Ueda: "Although I do get pressurised, that's not happened yet [on the current project]."
and Shadow of the Colossus
creator Fumito Ueda divulges a few details to gamesTM
about his new game — in particular, that it's nowhere near ready development hasn't reached the cricital stage yet, meaning there's still a long way to go.
August 28 — The new game won't be at TGS
VG247 asks Yoshida
if Team ICO's new title would be ready to be shown to the public at Tokyo Game Show 2008. He says he doesn't know — turns out he was right not to make any promises.
February 23 — Ueda to speak at GDC
that the series' creative lead will be attending next month's Game Developers Conference.
March 25 — A repeat performance
Ueda: "Probably, it will be similar to... um... Well, the essence of the game is similar to ICO."
Ueda does appear at the GDC, and he does mention something about the new game. It's not too much, but, to be fair, he actually wasn't allowed to say anything.
May 19 — rumoured first footage of the new game leaks online
PlayStation Lifestyle reveals
an almost four-minute video which features scenes of interaction between a boy and a large, furry, feline beast. A few instances of cooperative platforming are also shown. At one point, the title "Project TRICO" appears.
June 2 — More details revealed at Sony's Press Conference
A new video, this time four and a half minutes in length, is shown at Sony's Press Conference at E3 2009. In addition to a few new images and better quality, we also learn the new game's title: The Last Guardian.
June 3 — Ueda talks Trico
Before he could slip away, IGN manages to snag an interview with Fumito Ueda, who agrees to divulge a few things about several different aspects of the game — namely Trico's (the creature's) design, and gameplay.
June 10 — The first batch of screenshots is here!
Some from the trailer, some brand new. Here's the very first batch of great-looking high-res screens for TLG
June 12 — Kotaku's Best of E3 Awards 2009
Wherein we recognise The Last Guardian as one of the biggest reveals of E3 2009.
September 17 — Here's why it's called "The Last Guardian"
Kobayashi: "The Japanese market is only one fifth of the global market (...) Unless we gain success in the overseas market, our studio will go bankrupt."
Sony Japan's Vice President Yasuhide Kobayashi tells Games Industry
that the game was titled "The Last Guardian" to appeal to western audiences. A fine decision — "The Giant Man-Eating Eagle Toriko" doesn't quite have the same ring to it. He also speaks about the importance of proper localisation.
September 23 — TLG makes an appearance at TGS
And Kotaku is there to liveblog it. The video to the left is shown during the presentation.
September 27 — Ueda likes cats!
Ueda: "There's a lot more we can do with the PS3 so there can be more dynamic developments in the game."
Fumito Ueda tells Kotaku all about his love for cats, how his love for cats influenced the creation of Trico the creature, and how the PS3 is the perfect console for TLG.
February 1 — More high-resolution goodness
Sony Japan launches the official website
, and immediately uploads a whole bunch of screenshots.
February 3 — We can expect more TLG news soon
Ueda: "At the time of the E3 announcement, the tremendous response was a shock to me personally."
Fumito Ueda tells Famitsu that he'd like to make new announcements this year. Does that mean E3?
June 22 — No TLG news at E3
TLG is absent from E3. That means no announcements until fall.
September 8 — TLG confirmed for TGS 2010
Sony confirms that The Last Guardian will be there at the next Tokyo Game Show.
September 16 — This is Kotaku, live from TGS 2010
September 17 — Ueda in the TGS' aftermath
Ueda: "We wanted to show a bit more of the emotional attachment between the boy and Trico."
PSB-EU talks to Fumito Ueda, who details intentions, inspirations, and mentions the main characters of TLG.
September 22 — No TLG movie planned (maybe they should release the game first)
September 24 — The PlayStation Blog is at it again
Ueda: "I would describe [TLG] as an adventure game that you play with [Trico]."
interview with Fumito Ueda from last week was apparently too lengthy for a single post — here's the rest of it
. The ICO
head honcho speaks about what kind of game TLG
is, the relationship between its two main characters, and what makes video games art.
March 2 — Early-year revelations
? — We almost got a demo. Almost.
Ueda tells 1UP
that the team's considering including a TLG
demo in the upcoming Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection
. It doesn't exactly
? — Trico is pretty much like any other pet
Ueda: "I think each player will have a different Trico to work with depending on how he or she chooses to interact with him."
Ueda describes TLG's gameplay as part pet training.
11:00am — A slice of the action
At a private Sony-held event, the press is shown a so-called "vertical slice", that is, a demonstration of the unique elements of TLG. Here is Kotaku's account of what transpired.
March 10 — Apparently the last two games weren't good enough
Ueda: "I'm making the game so that it's appealing, with the hope that many people will give it a try and love it."
Ueda expresses his desire to avoid making the mistake of creating yet another award-winning title cherished by thousands with The Last Guardian
. On a more serious note, what he wants
for his next game is a wider appeal — which is understandable.
April 20 — A longer wait
Ueda: "To provide more challenging and better quality of content (...) I decided to postpone [TLG's] release timing."
Things do not go as expected, and Team ICO delays all their upcoming games. Although the Ico & Shadow of the Colossus Collection does come out this year (albeit slightly late), TLG is nowhere to be seen.
July 20 — Ico/SOTC Collection to have TLG material
Even with no release date, there's still something coming: according to the PlayStation Blog
, the upcoming Team ICO rerelease disc will have TLG
-related behind the scenes footage on it.
September 8 — No TLG at TGS 2011
September 20 — A sneak-peek behind the scenes
Courtesy of PlayStation Blog
, here's part of the bonus footage from the upcoming Ico & SOTC Collection
. The whole clip can be found to the left, courtesy of IGN
November 30 — Uh-oh. Did Ueda just leave Sony?
that Ueda has parted ways with Sony. Supposedly, this doesn't affect TLG's
development, which Ueda will reportedly finish working on as a freelancer.
December 5 — TLG is, indeed, marching on
A tweet reveals
that Ueda and co. are still hard at work, regardless of their leader's current relationship with Sony.
December 7 — There goes another one
executive producer Yoshifusa Hayama throws in the towel and leaves Project ICO
December 13 — Officially separated
Sony finally confirms to Gamasutra
that Ueda has left the company — adding that Ueda is contractually obligated — and willing — to finish work on The Last Guardian
December 22 — Cancelled? No.
A mistake on GameStop's part causes panic amongst the already nervous TLG pre-order crowd.
February 14 — Making a game is hard — especially when it's TLG
Yoshida: "The team's always been making progress, but there are lots of difficulties."
Head of Worldwide Development for Sony, Shuhei Yoshida, says that while there are hurdles to overcome, The Last Guardian will absolutely see the light of day.
February 21 — Team ICO calls for aid... and Santa Monica will answer
Sony tells Wired
that Ueda and co. have enlisted the support of several studios scattered around Europe and North America, including the folks behind God of War
, Sony Santa Monica, to help finish TLG
June 5 — Nothing at E3. Where is it?
We express our disappointment over TLG's absence from E3 2012.
June 6 — It's coming When It's Done™
Rohde: "Gamers are first. And the experience that we provide is first. And that's why we're going to talk about that game when we're ready to talk about it."
Sony's VP of Product Development Scott Rohde tells GameSpot
that they refuse to reveal anything until everything's absolutely perfect and ready.
June 20 — Everything's better with dubstep
Or maybe not. In any case, Michael McWhertor brings us this gem of a trailer re-imagining.
June 21 — Ueda reassures everyone, sort of
Ueda: "I can't really comment on the details."
Kotaku catches up with TLG's creator, who offers a few (very few) words of reassurance. At least there still are "details" that can't be commented on.
August 9 — TLG's abandonment issues
Sony's trademark registration for "The Last Guardian" expires. Kotaku
explains why this news shouldn't scare anyone. Also, Sony confirms
that the game is still being worked on.
August 15 — Why the wait? Here's why
Yoshida: "The engineering team had to go back and re-do some of the work they had done."
September 3 — Crisis over
It is revealed
that Sony has actually already filed for a new TLG
September 20 — More reassurance
Sony dev: "I give you my word that it exists."
A mysterious, unnamed Sony developer talks to Kotaku about TLG's development, but sadly he doesn't offer much more than a "yes, it's still being worked on".
November 7 — No TLG in 2013. In fact, no TLG for a while.
Yoshida: "The team is working hard on the project, including the engine."
Developer: Team Ico
Publisher: Sony Computer Entertainment
Platform: PlayStation 3
Release date: TBA