Muse Uses Japan’s Rising Sun Imagery, Forgets It Pisses People Off

Muse Uses Japan’s Rising Sun Imagery, Forgets It Pisses People Off
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Kotaku Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.


British rockers Muse have a new music video out. It was shot in Tokyo, and it’s lighthearted and fun. Oh, except for the part that pissed people off.

On YouTube and 2ch, commenters are pointing out that the video briefly featured Japan’s Rising Sun Flag — something that angered people online. For many, it symbolises the country’s imperialistic past and everything awful associated with it.

After the video debuted, some on YouTube began criticising the imagery. Others defended it. The comments section turned into a big mess.

“To the people who can’t understand why some are mad, I guess you can compare the Rising Sun flag with the Confederate flag,” wrote commenter Naenuu on YouTube. “Some people can go on and on about how the Confederate flag is a symbol of Southern heritage, but come on now, you know that’s not what people associate it with. Same with the Rising Sun flag. Both are rife with controversy and history.”

A few YouTube went further and compared the Japanese military flag to the Nazi swastika.

“Past is not past, man. If you are Korean or Chinese, You can still feel anger in your mind,” wrote Michael Sanghyuk Jang on YouTube. “There are still many war victims in Korea and China, especially old woman who had been raped by Japanese troop during WWII. You should understand and respect neighbour countries’ sorrow abyss [SIC].”

On 2ch, Japan’s largest forum, some commenters pointed out that the flag is still used by the Japanese Navy as its official ensign. What’s more, Asahi beer also uses the flag’s imagery as does Asahi Shimbun and Asahi taxicabs.

The flag, obviously, has a very different meaning in Japan. Some on 2ch also pointed out that they think the Rising Sun Flag’s design is better than the current flag’s, adding that this is probably why Westerners, such as Muse, often seem to use the imagery.

The controversy over the Rising Sun imagery comes after Kyary Pamyu Pamyu, one of Japan’s most popular singers, poised with a Rising Sun Flag earlier this year. These images were intended as New Year’s greetings, but angered Korean fans so much that Pamyu Pamyu had to cancel her South Korean tour last month.

Muse, it seems, wanted to avoid any trouble. Hours after the YouTube comments started to get heated, turning into a “Panic Station” of its own, Muse apologized on Twitter and released a new version of the video, with the Rising Sun imagery edited out.

Watch the edited Muse video in the link below.

Panic Station (Official Video) [YouTube — Thanks Mr Raccoon!]
英国ロックバンドのMuse(ミューズ)[中央日報 via 2ch]


Culture Smash is a regular dose of things topical, interesting and sometimes even awesome — game related and beyond.

Comments

  • I don’t see any reason why they have to apologise.

    edit: I also believe these are the same type of people who would think the manji symbol should be removed from existence because it’s “the nazi symbol”.

    • An apology is not something one has to do, its something you do out of respect for another person when your action has an unintended consequence. Muse obviously didn’t want to make a statement, or offend, so they’re all like oops sorry guys, we’ll fix it.

  • “There are still many war victims in Korea and China, especially old woman who had been raped by Japanese troop during WWII. You should understand and respect neighbour countries’ sorrow abyss [SIC].”

    And I’m sure these old ladies are watching the music video right now. Right? Silly example for sure, the examples there but should have said something different. From an outsiders pov all I can say to those bitching is get over it. But that’s because I’m ignorant and don’t care to learn about it just so I can get involved in the bitchfest that was occurring.

    • That you post a comment like that on ANZAC day is incredibly ironic. Or don’t you observe it because you’re ignorant and don’t care to learn about it?

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!