Controversy Over The Chinese Pacific Rim Translation

Controversy Over The Chinese Pacific Rim Translation
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Kotaku Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.

Pacific Rim is a smash hit in China. People love it, even if the subtitles are iffy.

There is one subtitle translation in particular that has made the evening news in China. The on-screen subtitle for Elbow Rocket, Gypsy Danger‘s rocket-powered punch, reads “Pegasus Meteor Fist” in Chinese.

No biggie, right? It was changed, so what? Well, the problem is that the Japanese manga and anime Saint Seiya already has a “Pegasus Meteor Fist” attack.

And since Saint Seiya has a sizeable following in China, some theatergoers were either confused or amused by a well-known Saint Seiya combat technique appearing in Pacific Rim. Others were angered, saying bad subtitles made the film worse.

If you know Saint Seiya, for example, the subtitle makes it seem like Pacific Rim is ripping off the famed manga and anime series.

However, that wasn’t the translator’s intent. Xiuyan Jia, who did Pacific Rim‘s Chinese subtitles, said (via China News Network) that, since Guillermo Del Toro is a big anime fan, she borrowed the move’s name from Japanese animation. Jia is not a novice. The translator has done subtitles for numerous Hollywood movies released in China, such as Men in Black 3.

According to Jia, “It’s paying respect to Japanese animation.” A straight-up translation of “Elbow Rocket” does sound like awkward gibberish in Chinese (to be honest, it sounds awkward in English too).

“Guillermo Del Toro has said numerous times that this movie was a love letter to Japanese culture,” said Jia. “Even the end credits have loads of thanks to various Japanese people. The reason I went with Pegasus Meteor Fist is because I felt that Seiya is representative of Japanese anime and that the punch is very similar.”

This doesn’t seem to be the film’s only questionable translation. Online in China, there’s a list of all the discrepancies between the Chinese subtitles and the original English.

One particularly damning flub incorrectly substituted “polluted Hong Kong” instead of the correct text “populated Hong Kong.” This is certainly not the image the movie’s creators want to send to Chinese moviegoers. Jia, however, said the script she was working from read “polluted.” If so, then it’s possible the line of text was changed during filming or in post-production.

Warner Brothers found out about the Pacific Rim subtitle kerfuffle and began looking into the situation. As of today Sina Movies is reporting that Jia has left the movie subtitling business for the time being to go to graduate school.

揭秘”天马流星拳”背后的译制片江湖 [Sina]

环太平洋翻译遭封杀 神翻译 “天马流星拳”被吐槽 [CTV via ネタリか]

Eric Jou contributed to this article.


  • Translation, and transliteration, are an art in itself. Transliteration is ensuring a translation maintains the emotion and rhythm of the original intent – and is the reason why there are so many translations of The Iliad, Journey to the West and even interpretations of Chaucer and Shakespeare etc, but only a rare few are worth reading.

    Elbow rocket is incredibly lame as a phrase.

  • In the “Extra Patriotic” Chinese edit, Crimson Typhoon will be the hero Jaeger and the non-Asian characters will be portrayed as bumbling idiots.

  • Obviously, a stirring conversation-starter judging by the raucous comments section.

    “Hey, did you hear about the chinese subtitles for Pacif- Where’d everyone go?”

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!