Surprise and disappointment seem to go hand in hand. The most surprising thing about the nominations for this award was the crossover: so many people were disappointed by games other people were surprised by! I guess that's just the cycle of hype and backlash at work. Still, some nominations in here that I heartily agree with. Others I'm scratching my head at!
But it's time to vote! Feel free to let us know your reasoning in the comments below!