Far Cry Primal: The Kotaku Review

Far Cry Primal: The Kotaku Review
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Kotaku Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.

Far Cry Primal is frequently violent and occasionally, unexpectedly sweet. The caveman action game is an excellent concept best experienced by people who haven’t been playing every entry in Far Cry, another of gaming’s perpetual franchises.

It’s an iteration. It’s a tweak. It’s another reprise of 2012’s Far Cry 3 formula of first-person open-world hunting and base-raiding and character-levelling, this time with the grappling hook added by 2014’s Far Cry 4. It’s that familiar equation minus the guns and grenades, although many of those weapons’ functions are covered by Primal‘s bows, zooming bows and double-arrow-firing bows, bee bombs and fire-bombs.

You play as a caveman named Takkar. You’re tasked with going on major and minor missions throughout a lush, open environment, usually with the goal of taking out enemy factions. There are experience points to be gained, outposts to be cleared, and skills to be learned on a many-branched skill tree. Those of us who thoroughly played FC3 and FC4 have thoroughly climbed this tree before. It is hard to muster up excitement for enemy-tagging and chain takedowns the third time around.

If you’ve missed a Far Cry in recent years, then you’re lucky, because it will make Far Cry Primal feel less like you’re having for dinner what you just had for lunch.

Many game series repeat themselves, but usually at least benefit from the improvements of iteration. But Far Cry 3‘s creators crafted such a smooth-playing, satisfying shooter in 2012 that their subsequent sequels have improved but just marginally, switching locales from tropical jungle to Himalayan forest to, now, Stone Age forest.

Until now the series has also been limited in its available actions: kill, kill quietly, drive, and kill by driving. Here, though, is where Far Cry Primal has found something new to do beyond reinventing the wheel. It gives the series two newly available verbs: tame and pet.

The former has gotten the buzz, deservedly so. For the first time we can put the dangerous beasts of a Far Cry game under our control, tossing meat at sabre-toothed tigers, badgers and cave bears so that we can then summon them to kill and scavenge for us. This is a terrific addition to Far Cry‘s formula. It’s the most satisfying approach to commanding lethal minions since Assassin’s Creed Brotherhood let you whistle for an underling assassin to silently kill a guy down the street:

The petting is the subtler addition. It serves no gameplay purpose to pet the animals you tame. You gain no XP for massaging the scruff of a jaguar’s neck or the brow of a dog-like dhole. You simply can, and in doing so participate in the most exotic addition to a Far Cry game in ages: an interactive action of kindness. Far Cry games embody the default hostility imbued in so many game worlds. We are in a lot of them to kill or be killed. The buttons on our controllers seldom start jokes, make friends or de-escalate a deadly fight to a diplomatic handshake. Violence is the easiest interactive action to design and perform. To press a button to perform any nice action in a series such as this is a quiet revelation.

Despite its more brutal setting, its warring cavemen factions, its ear trophies and blood-drinking shaman character, Primal somehow manages to be the kindest Far Cry yet. It is still a bloody game, but in a way that strains the story less. Takkar makes sense as a killing machine far more naturally than Jason or Ajay from Far Crys 3 and 4. He’s a caveman living in rough times. He’s also, though, a man who pets his pet bear and who is building a village.

Being kind to your animals in this game means not letting them get trampled by a rampaging mammoth. Whoops!

Being kind to your animals in this game means not letting them get trampled by a rampaging mammoth. Whoops!

Primal‘s base of operations is a slowly reconstituted village, a community of fellow Wenja tribespeople that swells in population as you play. As you kill enemy men and women and as you skin fierce animals for their hides, you are able to move people into your village, build them huts and learn their stories. You kill in the name of building your community, and you might just be able to get some of your enemies to move in as well.

Your new neighbours lead to the game’s seven lines of quests that prove to be as fundamental to your progression as killing the game’s two major villains. One sidequest-giver teaches you to hunt. Another takes you on vision quests. The most compelling, a brute named Dah, complains of “skull fire” and earnestly beseeches you to help him as his head throbs from a Stone Age migraine. His is the most touching story in the game, the first in any Far Cry for which I’d use that adjective.

The game is mostly action, but its quests show a series primed for greater thematic complexity. You’ll spend more time using a pet owl as a prehistoric predator drone and sending in a stealth jaguar to kill your enemies, but you can also take a side mission to figure out why your village’s water source is making people sick or another to protect the people in your tribe who want to go out at night to sing to the spirits.

Many of Far Cry Primal‘s best missions are well-hidden and not pushed upon the player. This dynamic is a slight echo of its predecessors, which tucked some of its most interesting locations off its main path. One of the game’s low-key highlights is the batch of optional cave missions, each of which blocks Takkar off from his pet animal and challenges you to escape some of the most beautiful, enclosed locations of the game.

The Drowned Cave, one of the the game's cooler remote locations.

The Drowned Cave, one of the the game’s cooler remote locations.

Much of the game, enjoyable as it is, feels like a retread, but the late game brings more fresh ideas. Primal‘s alluring animal hunts build toward optional side missions each located in a large corner pocket of the map, each involving the hunt for a high-powered beast: an uber bear, mastodon and so on. These exceptional hunts work as free-roaming boss battles.

In one hunt set in the southwestern corner of the map, players set traps for an unusually vicious saber-toothed tiger by day and then ambush the enemy creature at night, chasing it back to its lair if it flees. More than anything, these encounters are a resuscitation of the underexplored boss battle sandbox design of games like Metal Gear Solid 3.

One of four pockets of the game's sprawling map that are dedicated to hunting high-level beats

One of four pockets of the game’s sprawling map that are dedicated to hunting high-level beats

The best parts of Far Cry Primal may be well-hidden, but the core is good, too. The running, the climbing, the sneaking and the shooting all feel as good as they ever have. For some, doing all that again but against cavemen and woolly mammoths will provide sufficient novelty. More subtly, the game’s moments of kindness and community-building and those extended hunting sequences show the flint sparks of an evolutionary step to come. Primal is worth playing, but only once you’re hungry for more and only if you’re prepared to plumb its depths.


  • As much as I enjoy riding animals, I’m finding the game very repetitive and am looking at returning it.

    • In terms of the formula of the game (ignoring the setting), how close is it to the previous games? I found FC4 to be pretty much a carbon copy of FC3, just in a different setting, and I just don’t find that particular formula interesting enough to want to play it across multiple skins…er, I mean titles.

      • I spent a lot of time in FC4 just messing about, really enjoyed it, but I didn’t get into FC3.
        Primal feels like it’s a stripped back FC4 with focus on the hunting/skinning.

  • I’ve played about 7 or 8 hours, I enjoyed the first 3 or so a lot but now I’ve tamed most things and can ride them and the main quests I’m on have all been boring. The bonus mammoth missions were flat out bad mechanics wise. Basically I liked the setting and running around in it but the missions are repetitive and a bit of a drag and I still don’t feel any attachment or drive to find out what happens next.

    The world feels a bit dull too, there seems to be a lack of variety in animals and things like bears and sabre tooth tigers are too easy to see coming and then too easy to kill. Hunting is a let down because there’s just SO many animals running around that if I need anything i just go to it on the map and will find 10 of the creature in 5 minutes.

  • Loved the early game, have been playing on Extreme with very minimal HUD (crosshairs and health only). Each enemy (but more often vicious animal) encounter had a really good sense of life and death (fitting very well with the ‘Primal’ aspect of the game). However since leveling up this threat level has diminished somewhat and later on there’s a tonne of enemies means I end up running past most groups to save time.

    I’m still enjoying it – just not AS MUCH as I first did, very repetitive as is mentioned and (no surprise) very similar to FC4. As stanvangundy mentioned, the world can seem very over-populated with animals, at one stage I ran into 3 consecutive Jaguars within minutes also yeah, the mammoth missions are TERRIBLE.

    I highly recommend playing on Extreme w/out HUD elements or using the UAV owl to perma-mark the enemies, as the best moments have come from stressful (but fun) combat and sneeki beeki jungle exploration./hunting.

    Strip it back to the games basics to get the primal experience/10

  • Oh man. Cave-man migraines… See, this is probably why trepanning was invented.
    Before I had a migraine, I always just imagined they were extremely severe headaches.
    Then I had my first one. Drugs didn’t work. Slamming my head against things or anything else to try and directed pain attention elsewhere didn’t work. It was all-consuming and came with nausea. I took myself to the ER because I thought I had a tumour/aneurysm and was going to die.

    Now, if it ever happens, I take a shitload of specific drugs and try to sleep through the resulting shitfight, fully aware that the next day will feel like a hangover without the fun. But in a world without effective drugs or knowledge of what the head-fire was?


    Also, I don’t think FC3’s Jason Brody gets anywhere near enough credit as a character. There was some serious Heart of Darkness stuff going on there, man. The moments with your friends openly horrified – even repulsed – by the psychopathic murderer you’ve become were just rare enough to not grow desensitized to their jarring context for what you’ve been doing. Ajay’s ‘freedom fighter’ stuff muddles the mix… but Brody was a lot simpler and nastier. He had embraced the madness and he liked it.

    • Agreed about Far Cry 3, it seems like people can’t seem to get past the fact that he seems to be a generic Dude-Bro. But there’s definitely more going on there.

      And also the fact that he was being totally used by the Locals without knowing it, especially Citra.

      Top game.

  • I’m a bit put off by how goddam awful those stupid bell-spinning “magic world” Shangri-la missions were in Far Cry 4 to think for that a Far Cry game without massive guns is a good idea.

    Those missions had shitty non-gun weapons and animals you could direct to attack your foes and they were easily the most annoying, least fun missions in the whole game.

    I’m cool with them mixing it up because the formula was stale, but I’m not sure that going back in time was the way to go. I’d rather a futuristic Far Cry (similar to an open world Crysis) or even another Blood Dragon.

    • The main reason I didn’t like those missions was because they were too confined and your toolset too small. You didn’t have a plethora of options for approach – just one of two. Go loud or go stealthy.

  • I bought this on PC expecting to be able to play it today. But no. It unlocked at 4pm, when I had to be at work. Why the hell couldn’t they have let it unlock at midnight in whatever timezone you are in?

  • I see a number of previous comments make comparisons with Far Cry 3 and 4. This is my first Far Cry game and I love it. The Stone Age setting is great change from the plethora of FPS. I’m about 20 hours in and I can’t put it down

  • It’s a shame that so many AAA series do this.
    “If you’ve seen one puddle of puke you’ve seen em all”
    Although for some people I imagine games are like bands, they change too much and you lose interest.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!