Steve Rogers Has Turned Into A Full-On Comic Book Supervillain

Steve Rogers Has Turned Into A Full-On Comic Book Supervillain
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Kotaku Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.

If you’ve been following the long saga of Steve Rogers, you’ll know that this year he returned to superpowered heroism as the current second Captain America. You’ll also know that he came back with some… intriguing quirks, like, for example, being a secret brainwashed Hydra agent. That would be bad enough, but now he’s become a loopy supervillain, and it’s amazing.

Over the past few issues of Steve Rogers, Captain America — by Nick Spencer, Jesús Saiz and Joe Caramagna — Steve has been plotting a takeover of the resurgent Hydra from under the control of the Red Skull. It’s involved the sort of double-crosses and twists and “wait, wasn’t that guy dead?” moments of subterfuge you’d expect from a sinister backstabbing plot involving an organisation like Hydra, even if your protagonist is a cosmic-cube-brainwashed version of America’s most beloved and patriotic superhero.

But this week’s Steve Rogers, Captain America #8 leaves much of the Hydra-based secret shenanigans behind, as Steve finds himself on the front lines of defending Earth from a surprise Chitauri invasion alongside Captain Marvel and Maria Hill. The waves of Chitauri soldiers have been heading towards Earth on a more frequent schedule recently, much to the confusion of Carol and her Alpha Flight, tasked with safeguarding the Earth from cosmic threats. While Steven and Maria are in orbit with her, they discover another wave of aliens is on its way, bigger than anything that has tried to hit them before:

Things look very bad for our heroes until Avril Kincaid, the new incarnation of Quasar introduced earlier this year during the Standoff miniseries, shows up out of nowhere and uses her burgeoning new powers to turn the entire horde of Chitauri into cosmic space bits. You’d think everyone would be pleased that they and the rest of Earth didn’t just get turned into Chitauri kibble, but out of nowhere, Steve is pissed at Avril’s unannounced act of heroism.

He lays into Carol and Maria, enraged because he thinks that they called Avril into action, despite Steve’s own express request that she be kept from being put on duty before she’s completed her training with the former Quasar, Wendell Vaughn. He even gets some good digs into Carol for the outcome of Civil War II while he’s at it, before storming off in a huff back to his secret Hydra Lab of Evil Machinations (I’m sure that’s its real name, probably).

But why is Steve so angry that Avril saved all their butts, and the entire planet while she was at it? I mean, being Hydra doesn’t mean you actually want the entire Earth to be invaded by aliens that would come and eradicate the humans you want to rule over, right? It turns out Steve’s plans have gotten way more ridiculously villainous than simply taking over Hydra.

He’s the one responsible for trying to get the Chitauri to invade the Earth. By luring them to Earth by secretly hiring a farmer in Montana to hatch a Chitauri Queen.

Steve’s anger comes from the fact that there’s now someone capable of stopping his plan of bringing the Chitauri to Earth to cull the human population.

This is way, way beyond the bad guy turn we’ve been seeing from Steve Rogers since this series started. Even if we know his heel-turn was due to some cosmic cube-altering shenanigans from Kobik, this is just amazingly, almost hilariously evil. When this twist was first revealed, I said that I was in for the long run just to see what Spencer and Saiz did with an evil Captain America. “Captain America secretly planning a giant alien invasion of Earth for shits and giggles” is absolutely not where I expected it to go, and I kind of love it for going there anyway.


  • Isn’t the Spider-Gwen Universe Captain America (A Hispanic Female) becoming the second All-New Captain America soon?

    • Not that we know. So far they have kept those two universes intently separated. She’s African American, btw, not Hispanic.

  • I despise this in every way possible and I have still not bothered to buy a single Marvel title since this botched abortion of a storyline came out.

    Nick Spencer is a talentless hack. If he were a GOOD writer, he’d manage to build a REAL villain, but he can’t. He’s like a 10-year-old with a spray can who defaces a piece of art and claims he’s the next Banksy.

    I don’t care who they get to be Captain America. I would have been open to Sam because I like him if only they’d kept Steve around; they’ve done that before. Now, with what they’ve done to Steve? I don’t care who they get as Captain America. I’m not buying it, I’m not having anything to do with it, and judging from the suckage of sales Marvel’s getting right now, nobody else is, either. This is a mockery of a terrific character and how ANYONE can think this is a good thing is beyond me — except if you’re the usual, ‘I can’t stand any hero unless he’s actually a villain in disguise’ type. SOME of us like actual good guys and miss them. And no, for the record, I’m not a screaming conservative either — quite the opposite.

    The only way I want this to end is for Steve to come face to face with Kobik, realize this is a probable reality, and refuse her gift the second time around. He deserves to be remembered as the character he really is and has been for 70 years –a truly good person who’s tried to do his best for others. We need MORE of those, not to have the very very few we do have thrown into a pile of pigs*it, which is exactly what this storyline IS.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!