Marvel vs. Capcom 3 and Pokken Tournament fans just closed out a weeks-long, neck-and-neck donation competition over a primetime spot at the prestigious Evolution Championship Series tournament. It seems that Marvel vs. Capcom 3 will make an appearance at EVO 2017, having raised over $US71,000 ($93,008) of the total $US150,000 ($196,495) for the Make-A-Wish foundation. But Marvel's victory didn't happen without its fair share of drama. Because Marvel has been an EVO mainstay for years, defending its slot made this year's wallet war a bitter one.
After Marvel pulled through, EVO announced today they will commit $US10,000 ($13,100) to future Pokken tournaments.
Kotaku contributor Ian Walker reported last week that the 2017 charity competition reopened old wounds in the fighting games community. EVO's 2013 donation drive raised $US160,000 ($209,594) for breast cancer research, but also pitted Skullgirls fans against Super Smash Bros. Melee fans in an emotional donation war. Afterward, the tournament brought the fighting games community together over a shared passion for gaming skill. This year's contenders included Skullgirls, along with Killer Instinct and Nidhogg.
When Pokken appeared at EVO last year, some viewers left with a bad taste in their mouths. The tournament ran two hours over. Many were doubtful that it deserved to be at EVO because of its gameplay speed. A week of Marvel and Pokken telethons and livestream events prefaced today's decision, which, lead EVO organiser Joey Cuellar says, is "unofficial" until donated money goes through.
This morning, unconfirmed accusations of chargebacks and shady credit card donations among Pokken fans proliferated across the web. It started with a Reddit post on /r/Kappa that appeared to be a screenshot of Pokken fan "Zyflair Griffane" describing how he'd "charge back the donations and tell my credit card company my card was stolen once Pokken wins". On the thread, a commenter pointed others to a 4Chan page in which individuals listed credit cards that offer a sign-up bonus. That way, Pokken fans could donate larger sums and win. On 4Chan, one fan said he'd donated $US500 ($655) twice after opening up new credit cards. He said he'd "do it again if we don't pull ahead before noon".
I know it wasn't perfect, but the FGC raised nearly $150k for charity. Much respect to both Marvel and Pokken scenes.
— Tom Cannon (@ProtomCannon) February 8, 2017
When reached by Kotaku, Griffane said the post was Photoshopped, which a friend whose name appears in it corroborated. (It is impossible to prove this independently, and Griffane was unable to produce a screenshot of the original post). But the damage was done. Accusations that a few Pokken community members participated dishonorably spread on Pokken and Marvel forums across the web, as well as on Twitter, where EVO enthusiasts discussed the accusations. Compounding this was head EVO organiser Joey Cuellar's tweet responding to related allegations of shady donations:
@MrWiz We are aware of potential charge back tactics, and that will factor into our decision.
— Joey Cuellar (@MrWiz) February 8, 2017
Cuellar did not respond to a request for comment. Pokken community members I spoke with denied that unsavoury EVO donations were widespread or even existent. Pokken fan and #PokkenEVO teammate PK Sparkxx told me that "the scale of potential chargebacks from my #PokkenEVO team is zero... We're out to get respect, and employing chargebacks from a donation to a charity is NOT the way to do it." He, and all others reached, alleged that the /r/Kappa post was fake, too. (The original poster on /r/Kappa did not confirm whether it was Photoshopped.)
Marvel fan Matthias Regge explained that there's no basically no overlap between the Pokken and Marvel fan communities, which may have led to the unproven allegations. It could spark animosity. The "wallet war", in his words, "is very unhealthy and brings out a lot of toxicity within the communities."
I saved Marvel!
— Echo Fox Justin Wong (@JWonggg) July 14, 2014
Seven hundred and fifty more Marvel fans donated to Make-A-Wish than Pokken fans, but Pokken only raised about $US4000 ($5240) less. In part, that was due to Pokken fans' unparalleled passion for the game and how much they had to prove on behalf of their game. Competitive Pokken player Anthony Paratore (Rokso) donated over $US4000 ($5240), which he says he saved over the course of three years working as an HVAC mechanic and donated because he enjoys giving to charity. In an email, he described today as "emotional". "The reasoning for the accused chargebacks are simply because people do not understand why Pokken is even a contender in the drive," he said.
In the end, Marvel pulled through after Street Fighter V athlete Justin Wong donated a well-timed $US2000 ($2620). The Make-A-Wish foundation will receive $US150,000 ($196,495) while EVO 2017 will look much like EVO 2016. All in all, EVO provided a chance for a lesser-appreciated fighting game to see the spotlight, which, within such a wide-spanning genre, is a very good thing. The reputations of these games' fans and players, though, is a significant factor for less popular games hoping to break onto the main stage.