Ys VIII: Lacrimosa Of Dana: The Kotaku Review

The Ys series has been setting the bar for combat and music in action role-playing games since 1987. The latest game, Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana, is no different, but it does have something more recent entries have lacked — a memorable story.

Adol Christin is one of the most enduring heroes in gaming. For three decades now the eternally-youthful redheaded swordsman has been hunting for adventure. He's constantly getting himself embroiled in schemes to destroy the world, fighting dark gods and foiling foul plots. His exploits are the stuff of legend.

But Adol exists in a space similar to all classic Japanese action role-playing games, where defeating gods and saving the world are everyday occurrences. His legend is cobbled together from RPG tropes.

He's the hero whose coming was foretold by prophecy. The chosen one of several ancient cultures. He's even started off one of his adventures suffering from amnesia, which is about as JRPG as you can get.

If you've played many Ys games, then you know this boat Adol starts off on is doomed.

I've played through four Ys games over the past 13 years, and I've enjoyed each one, but not for the story. I've been drawn in by the responsive combat and lulled by the lush music. If you asked me to match the plot of those games to their titles, I would be at a loss. That's not going to be the case with Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana. It's something else.

Lacrimosa of Dana opens with Adol and his blue-haired companion Dogi aboard a ship called The Lombardia, heading to the continent of Eresia in search of more world-shaking adventure.

The trip is cut short when a massive sea creature destroys the vessel, sending Adol plunging into the briny depths. He awakens on the shore of Seiren Island, a cursed place from which legend says no one has ever returned.

Traditionally, this would be where Adol stumbles upon an ancient culture and is proclaimed the "the warrior of legend" or some such, but that doesn't happen. Instead, our hero and other survivors from The Lombardia band together and form a small settlement.

Called Castaway Village, it serves as a base of operations for Adol and company as they scour Seiren Island for more survivors and the resources they will need to escape.

There's more driving Adol than his relentless thirst for adventure this time around. It's about survival, not just just for him, but for the growing community of castaways that look to him and his adventuring companions for protection, salvation and comfort. They rely on him.

And he relies on them. Each recovered castaway fulfils a role in the ever-growing village. A young woman found wandering dazed on the beach turns out to be a tailor, lending her skills to crafting accessories and outfits for Adol and his friends.

A medical student becomes a doctor, brewing potions from resources gathered during the party's expeditions. There is no money on the island, so a rescued merchant trades more exotic materials for common supplies.

More than stand-ins for the nameless merchants and menders populating standard fantasy RPG towns, each new resident of Castaway Village is a distinctive character. They have got stories to tell and quests to give, and by the time they're done they have endeared themselves to the player as surely as if they'd been out in the wilderness fighting by Adol's side.

The plight of the stranded passengers is an incredibly compelling call to adventure. So much so that when Adol begins to dream of a blue-haired girl from a long-dead civilisation — the one all over the game's cover and concept art — it doesn't feel nearly as important as it should. For a game subtitled The Lacrimosa of Dana ("lacrimosa" is Latin for "weeping"), I really wasn't feeling the whole Dana thing.

Dana is supposed to be the second main character of the game, the first time anyone's shared top-billing with Adol. The problem in her introduction into the game starts off as a series of dreams that occur right before Adol and fellow fighters Laxia, Sahad, Hummel, and Ricotta are about to do something exciting.

With the promise of a new creatures to battle, exotic terrain to explore and the possibility of adding a new face to Castaway Village, the urge to skip these visions is very strong. Where is she from? What is her connection to Adol? He's probably some sort of chosen one again, whatever. Let's go rescue some survivors.

Oh no, my lacrimosa!

Dana becomes much more interesting as she's further integrated into the primary portions of the game, but it takes a while to get there. I'm talking a couple dozen hours here. It sounds like a lot, but there's so much to do and explore that doesn't involve a secondary story I'm not all that invested in.

There's a map to fill in, each individual section showing me the percentage explored, treasure chests to be opened and resources to harvest. It takes a lot of jumping and climbing to hit those numbers.

The brown on beige maps can be a little hard to follow, which has undoubtedly tacked on extra hours to my play time.

The village From time-to-time the village will get raided by beasts, setting in motion an Interception event, pitched battles during which Adol and his companions defend the settlement against waves of invading enemies. There are also Suppression missions, which see the castaways taking the battle against the beasts to the wilderness, keeping the population in check lest they be overrun.

You will be acutely aware of every stray water ripple in this game.

There are fish to catch, crops to grow, items to craft and meals to cook. A lot of work goes into keeping up a semblance of civilisation.

Then there's the pure joy of running about with a trio of adventurers, slaughtering any unfortunate creature that gets in your path. Ys has a knack for fast-paced dynamic combat, and Lacrimosa of Dana is the best it's ever been.

Building off the rock/paper/scissors system introduced in Ys Seven, each of the playable characters does a certain type of damage — slash, strike or pierce. If an enemy has a tough outer shell, Sahad's massive striking anchor weapon is just the thing to crack it. If an enemy flies, piece its wings with Laxia's saber. And Adol's slashing sword is just the thing for getting to the heart of basic beasts.

Players swap between the three active characters in their parties on the fly during battles to exploit enemy weaknesses. They switch styles and create combos, with well-timed dodges and guards slowing down time or nullifying damage, opening up enemies to devastating attacks.

It's an intoxicating dance, borderline addictive. So much so that while the game features a fast-travel system that lets Adol and crew warp between save crystals in an instant, I often found myself hoofing it just to wreck more beasts.

And where's there's dancing, there's music. The Ys series is lauded for its soundtracks, producing some of the finest scores in gaming. Rather than tell you how good the music in Lacrimosa of Dana is, here's the 55-track playlist developer Nihon Falcom uploaded to Youtube. It's gorgeous.

Satisfying combat and wonderful music are Ys' bread and butter. the basic components that have carried the series through multiple sequels and remakes over the past three decades. The stories haven't been strong, but when they're just a place to hang our hat while jamming and stabbing, it's not a big deal.

Hell, we might have been better off. By adding an enthralling tale packed with rich, engaging characters and an ever-looming man-versus-nature conflict, Nihon Falcom has crafted a game that's incredibly hard to put down. There are no real "Everything's ok now, we can rest" moments in Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana. The struggle isn't over until everyone escapes the island.

I'm somewhere between 35 and 40 hours in, and it doesn't look like I'm getting off anytime soon. That's fine. I've got everything I look for in an action RPG right here.


    Aside from Final Fantasy XV, it's been a while since I've played a JRPG, especially more of a "classic" one.

    What console(s) is this game available for?

    I am super, super excited for this. Ys is a massively underrated series.

    Not sure what the reviewer's been playing previously though...

    "it does have something more recent entries have lacked — a memorable story."

    What utter rubbish. The Ys games have memorable stories, even the original which was admittedly a bit brief (as you'd expect from a game from 1987) but definitely there. They stepped up the story elements significantly with Seven and Celceta, to the point that I've seen people complain that they're too JRPG-like. Personally that's what makes them so good for me - Seven especially, it's a JRPG with all the fluff and fat trimmed away.

    "If you asked me to match the plot of those games to their titles, I would be at a loss."

    Don't get this either. The title directly relates to the plot, aside from Ys Seven. In chronological order:
    - Ys Origin explains the the origin of the entire story of Ys I & II
    - Ys: Ancient Ys Vanished is about Adol finding his way to the vanished city of Ys
    - Ys II: Ancient Ys Vanished - The Final Chapter is about Adol finishing his journey to Ys
    - Ys: Memories of Celceta is about an amnesiac Adol wandering a massive forest in Celceta, regaining the memories that he lost while adventuring there previously.
    - Ys: Oath in Felghana is about Adol visiting Dogi's home town in Felghana
    - Ys V: Lost Kefin, Kingdom of Sand is about Adol traveling into the desert to try and find a city that sank beneath the sands in a large desert.
    - Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana is this game.
    - Ys VI: The Ark of Napishtim is about Adol washing up in an island chain that is inescapable due to a whirlpool, then searching for the Ark of Napishtim so he can get off the island.
    - Ys Seven is a direct sequel to VI, this time Adol makes it safely to Altago and has some adventures there.

    Incidentally if anyone is interested in giving Ys a try and doesn't want to wait for VIII, all the games are self-contained, except I&II which should be played in order. Steam is the best place for them nowadays. With the release of Ys Seven this week, only Memories of Celceta - Vita exclusive still - and Ys V which was SNES and PS1 and was not localized at all, all of the Ys games are on Steam. Falcom is a massively underrated developer and these games deserve way more interest and recognition than they tend to have.

    The version of I&II on Steam is basically the original 1987 gameplay with late 16-bit era sprite upgrades and an absolutely awesome re-recording of the music (you can switch back to the earlier soundtrack versions though, if you wonder what it sounded like on PC-88). It's great fun, you basically run into enemies and as long as you don't hit them straight on, you hit them and do damage. It's very simple and very fun. Ys II changes it up by giving you a ranged attack.

    Falcom subsequently made Ys III: Wanderers from Ys, which was localized years ago, then licensed the name to both Hudson and Tonkin House, who each made a Ys IV (Dawn of Ys and Mask of the Sun). Then Falcom made Ys V which was terrible and sank the franchise for nearly a decade until Ys VI came out.

    Ys VI is an early PS2-era 3D action RPG. It's pretty fun but probably the weakest of them. The engine was the basis for Oath in Felghana (a remake of Ys III) and Ys Origin (prequel to I&II) so these all play similarly. Oath is more refined than VI, and Origins is way more refined than Oath (the bosses especially are much better).

    Then Falcom moved to PSP and created Ys Seven. This changed the gameplay a lot - jumping removed, added more JRPG elements and you now are in a party where the characters have Piercing, Slashing or Crushing attack types and different enemies are weak or strong to different types. The story side is beefed up. Celceta (Vita) and VIII build off this gameplay style, though they also restore some of the platforming elements removed from Seven as well and have better gameplay as a result.

    Falcom make rad soundtracks, as an aside. They're also cool enough to have uploaded basically all of them to Youtube if you feel like sampling: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCz7eke4JGlbtc11_6mmA7ew/playlists

      What console is the above game for?

      Will I have need to have played previous titles to understand this story?

    This comment is awaiting moderation. Check back soon!Comments never get moderated, do they?

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now