How South Park: The Fractured But Whole Retcons Gender

How South Park: The Fractured But Whole Retcons Gender
Image: South Park Fractured But Whole

I’m an old school South Park fan, and I loved Stick of Truth. My only real disappointment was that I couldn’t create a female character. That’s changed with The Fractured But Whole, but it wasn’t until a recent preview I discovered exactly how gender choices play out.

Much like its predecessor, The Fractured But Whole starts by customising your character. However, ‘male’ is still the only option. At the time, I noted it was odd that I could still choose feminine hairstyles and even makeup. And I remembered the reports from earlier in the year.

The story carries on from Stick of Truth. You begin as The King — the hero of the previous fantasy-style quest. But now the game has changed to superheroes, and you need to reclaim your status amongst the kids of South Park.

Not only does this involve completing missions, but becoming a social media influencer on ‘Coonstagram’ by getting as many selfies with South Park residents as possible.

After completing some preliminary missions to reacquaint you with the world and learn how to control your new powers, you’re sent on some side quests of self discovery to help fill out your character sheet. First off, I headed to Mr Mackay for a low key psych evaluation.

It’s during this session that you’re given the option to choose your gender. If you choose female, Mackay is shocked, saying that everyone was under the impression that you were a boy.

He calls your parents, who confirm that you’ve been a girl “this entire time.” You can then choose to be either a cis female or transgender.

Sure, retconning the issue of gender in the South Park games is definitely a quick and easy fix. I found it funny rather than problematic, as well as clever. The developers also took the opportunity to further inject their trademark brand of political commentary.

Mr Mackay warns you may be treated differently due to your gender. It’s not the first time this warning crops up in the game.

During character creation, you can change the difficulty of the game. Pretty standard, right? Except in The Fractured But Whole, the harder the difficulty, the darker your skin tone.

New South Park Game Gets Harder If You Play A Black Character

South Park. The Fractured But Wholes' difficulty slider will change players' skin colour. As reported by Eurogamer, the game's character creator will have an effect on gameplay, altering how NPCs respond and affecting how much money characters will make.

Read more

This alters the way that NPCs react, as well as how much money you will make while looting. This may be the same for choosing to identify as female, but as I’ve only spent a couple of hours with the game so far, I haven’t had a chance to find out.

However, Mackay’s warning does come to fruition as soon as you leave the school. A fight scene is triggered with the town’s resident rednecks.

“Well, well, well. If it isn’t a cis gendered girl. We don’t take kindly to your type around here.”

The funniest part about this is that the fight takes place whether you’re cis female, trans or cis male. This trend continues when your journey of self discovery finds you at the church, where priests will try to molest-fight you regardless of your gender.

Because South Park.

If you enjoyed Stick of Truth, Fractured But Whole is more of the same albeit with more streamlined fighting mechanics. I’m also keen to see how Ubisoft San Francisco blends comedy and social discourse, pushing the political envelope in a way that only South Park can.

Overt. Unapologetic. And utterly hilarious.


    • There’s this line in the other article: “the game’s character creator will have an effect on gameplay, altering how NPCs respond and affecting how much money characters will make”. This sounds like the skin colour affects loot and quest rewards or maybe things like the frequency of battles. Which would make it harder even if the actual combat’s the same.

      • @spruppet

        Possibly! It’s hard for me to say right now as I only got a couple of hours with it and was playing as a pale skinned character. I’m sure more will come out about this once the game launches 🙂

    • @shamrocks

      Yeah the sliding scale of difficulty does say things like “hard” depending on the character’s skin tone, but it doesn’t actually scale the difficulty of battle as far as I’m aware

      • Would’ve been interesting to do something a little further with that, “Hard – When dealing with adults – children however don’t give a shit”

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!