The State Of Anime In 2017

By Sam Woolley

In 2017, anime is being stretched in several directions. With a glut of new live-action anime adaptations, it's being stretched into reality. With the airing of Naruto's 720th (and final) episode, it's stretching into the future. With behemoth streaming channels hoarding licensing deals, it's stretching into the mainstream. And by moving into the mainstream while continuing to embrace so many of the same tired tropes, it's stretching its audience, too.

The anime industry has ballooned over the last half decade, experiencing boom after boom every year since 2012. This year, we've seen a wealth of anime, but not a lot monumental ones. I write a lot about anime on Kotaku, and each time I do, I see anime fans talking about how much the scene has changed. That's a perennial complaint for any fandom, but the particulars shed light on the state of anime. Now, it's a circus, they say. It's laden down by gimmicks, they say, refusing to innovate beyond what viewership numbers say is appealing to certain audiences. After last year, I lowered my usual "Five anime of the season you should be watching" post to to four shows. Throughout this year, I still often couldn't come up with a fifth.

At the same time, this year we've gotten a handful of captivating titles that have done some cutting-edge stuff. They were few and far between, but the fact remains that throughout 2017, anime studios released some of the most memorable shows and movies I've seen in years.

This is part of our 2017 State Of series, a look at how the major consoles, PC, and other areas of interest are doing this year.

Assessing an entire animation form is difficult if not impossible. But after watching most of 2017's anime premieres, I was able to tease out a few notable trends that say a lot about how the world of anime fared in 2017.

The Genres

A steady stream of solid-enough sci-fi, fantasy and slice-of-life anime flowed through the entire year. Fantasy anime had a typically strong year. From the crowd-pleasing Little Witch Academia series, which premiered in the winter, to the second season of Attack on Titan in the spring, to summer's dark fantasy adventure Made in Abyss and fall's Kino's Journey remake, the greatest hits landed squarely in the realm of sword, sorcery, and enormous floating monsters. One-trick gimmick shows didn't quite weigh down the genre as much as they could have, but there was certainly a show about summoning weapons by holding hands and, also, Armed Girl's Machiavellism, which is what it sounds like.

Made In Abyss

Sadly, shonen faltered in 2017. Where was this year's Samurai Champloo or Hunter x Hunter or One Punch Man? Shonen titles with lots of hype often had glaring flaws, like the winter's Black Clover, which had strong promise that was swiftly stomped out by its annoying protagonist. Luckily, there were new seasons of old favourites: Gintama, My Hero Academia and Food Wars.

The Styles

Since 2010, anime has subtly changed. Characters' faces used to be pointed, rendered with more delicate lines. Now, lines are generally slightly bolder. Characters' noses have generally disappeared. Anime backgrounds are significantly brighter than they used to be, full of shining special effects, which dazzlingly colourful movies like Your Name took to an extreme.

[Image: 2ch]

Anime mostly remained 2D. Only one big show went all-in on CGI this year: Land of the Lustrous. After last year's Berserk utterly failed to make CGI cool, Land of the Lustrous, a show about "jewel people," has been widely considered a surprise success.

The Stand-outs

2017 delivered at least two extraordinary shows per season. That's significantly more generous than last year, though last year was not a great year for anime. Scum's Wish was a disturbing anime about lovers who love other people. It was a tender look at the sort of teenage nihilism that only comes from desperately wanting to be loved. Made In Abyss, about cave raiders diving for artifacts in a mysterious pit, is now in my top five anime of all time. The gorgeous, easy-to-watch Re:Creators asked: What if anime was real?. And the saccharine Recovery of an MMO Junkie restored my faith in how women are portrayed in anime.

Neo Yokio

There were some cult hits, too, but nothing as massively appealing as 2016's ice skating anime Yuri!!! on Ice. Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid, an anime about a dragon woman who, along with her dragon family, comes to live with an ordinary office worker, proved amazingly popular, to the point that I visited a Dragon Maid maid cafe to try to see if I could get the appeal. Neo Yokio, a star-studded and Western-looking show about being rich in late capitalism, was a conversation piece among anime fans and normies alike for months.

Less talked-about, but certainly worth a watch, were the jazz-inflected spy show Princess Principal, the slice-of-life Sakura Quest and the haunting sci-fi Inuyashiki.

Your Name

2017 was also a landmark year for anime movies. Stunning slice-of-life anime Your Name became the highest-grossing anime worldwide, earning $US355 ($463) million at the box office — and it deserved to be. American theatres across the country aired Your Name, making it one of the more accessible anime movies to Westerners in years. The slightly less-publicized A Silent Voice was a sensational, touching movie about bullying that stands toe-to-toe with Your Name. In This Corner of the World was a less-heralded favourite that demonstrated a startling variety of animation styles with its haunting Hiroshima-based plot. A pleasant surprise: the live-action Fullmetal Alchemist movie was actually pretty good. Apparently, so was the JoJo's Bizarre Adventure live-action movie.

The Bummers (and the tropes)

Yes, there were disappointments. Smash hit Attack on Titan's second season was divisive, not generating the same hype as its first. Early episodes fell on tired storytelling devices and confusing pacing. The significantly less recognised serious Dynamic, a shoddy anime about sexy male musicians, was one of the most glorious crappy anime in recent history.

Live-action anime adaptations have always been greeted with scepticism. 2017's Ghost in the Shell, starring Scarlett Johansson, was a major disappointment among Kotaku staff. Kotaku staff found Death Note mostly likable, but with some glaring flaws. (In 2018, we'll get the Battle Angel Alita, which already is looking pretty sketchy with the protagonist's huge, live-action anime eyes.)

Miss Kobayashi's Dragon Maid

There were some real sinkers this year, as well. According to 2016's anime industry report, adult anime is making a killing over in Japan. A lot of this niche, "late-night" anime makes it way over the the West. Did you want to see an anime in which enemies are defeated by stripping them? Well, you have Akiba's Trip. Did you want to see an anime glorifying nazis? There's Dies Irae. Or did you want to see an anime about being attracted to your kid sister? There's two: Eromanga Sensei and A Sister's All You Need.

2017 was also loaded with tropes and fan service. If you're the kind of person who enjoys shows in which sexualized children are actually 700-year-old dragons, 2017 was a great year in anime for you. If you're the kind of person who loves it when women randomly lose their clothes mid-battle, or after someone sneezes, 2017 was a great year in anime for you. If you're the kind of person who likes when every pair of breasts has their own, specific breast-bouncing sound, 2017 was a great year in anime for you. Everyone has their own views on fan service, of course.

The Streaming Services

Anime viewers now have more watching options than ever. Last year, Crunchyroll and Funimation joined forces, splitting simulcasts between the sub and dub streaming services. Crunchyroll hit 1 million paid subscribers in February (as far as I can tell, Funimation has not announced number, but Sony recently acquired a major stake in them). In 2017, Crunchyroll and Funimation are still going strong. Earlier this year, Crunchyroll's parent company Ellation launched VRV ("verve"), which lets fans subscribe to Crunchyroll and Funimation, plus other geek entertainment mainstays like Geek & Sundry and Rooster Teeth. These different services are like "channels" on VRV, which now has over 1.5 million users.

Princess Principal

Amazon showed up to the anime party as well. The mega-corporation's Anime Strike, a $US5 ($7) subscription service on top of a $US99 ($129)-yearly Amazon Prime subscription, nabbed most of my favourite anime this year. It may have gotten some good shows, but fans found the service itself hard to love. Fans feared that Amazon would edge out niche services like Crunchyroll and Funimation, out-bidding its competitors for anime licenses. In my experience, searching for anime on it is a nightmare, since the search bar brings up all of Amazon's products related to the anime in question.

Not content to let Amazon have all the fun, Netflix made some big investments in anime this year. Neo Yokio, a satirical show about being rich in late capitalism, drew lots of attention to Netflix as an anime hub. The show was created by Vampire Weekend's Ezra Koening and starred Jaden Smith, Jason Schwartzmann and Jude Law. In 2018, Netflix is placing a big stack of chips on anime. Netflix's chief content officer Ted Sarandos said in October that they'd be putting $US8 ($10) billion toward producing 30 new anime series and 80 new films for 2018. The service already boasts some of the hottest anime titles, and next year, Netflix will offer famed director Masaaki Yuasa's upcoming series Devilman Crybaby and Nickelodeon producer LeSean Thomas's Cannon Busters.

Twitch even moved into anime streaming this year with days-long marathons — in partnership with services like Crunchyroll — of shows like Mob Psycho 100, Yuri!!! On Ice and Kemono Friends.

The Culture

It's been said for a decade that anime is "entering the mainstream." That was just anime sinking its roots into Western consciousness with Toonami shows like Dragon Ball and Sailor Moon. Now, we're seeing the fruits of its mass acceptance. Scarlett Johansson starred in a movie based on a cyberpunk anime. Anime aesthetics have bled into fashion, specifically streetwear. In anticipation of the new Blade Runner movie, Cowboy Bebop's director produced a Blade Runner anime. Anime cons across the country are attracting tens of thousands, and in parks around the world, thousands of fans gathered to run like Naruto.

2017 may have been a mixed year for anime overall, but there was an anime for everyone. The West's appetite for the medium has never been more voracious. From obscure, trashy simulcasts to Hollywood blockbusters, anime is now offering so many options that it can be overwhelming. Luckily, you'll have Kotaku in 2018 and beyond, guiding you to the good stuff.


    Man Princess Principle was a pleasant surprise.
    I ended up watching it shortly after it finished airing and because of the combination of the name and the cast of cute anime girls I didn't have very high expectations. I then proceeded to binge watch it over the course of two days because my goodness was it so much better than expected. A genuinely well written spy/espionage story with a cast of likeable characters and some pretty heavy themes taken seriously.

    It and recovery of an MMO-Junkie were great for subverting my expectations in the most welcome way.

    My Hero Academia has been pretty spectacular so far, and I'm looking forward to the next season. It condenses a lot of what makes shounen appealing, but with better pacing, more variety and less nonsense.

    Put side-by-side, it actually makes Dragon Ball Super look depressingly bad.

    Was the Ancient Magus bride this year? Because I've been watching that and it's simply beautiful . Top quality animation and lovely story to go with it

      Pretty sure it was this year as it's still going, great anime with fantastic animation with beautiful art and wanderlust scenes telling an amazing story that is both fun & heart-wrenching in all the right ways.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now