Though BoJack Horseman has built up a loyal fanbase since it debuted on Netflix four years ago, there's been a contingent who have criticised the series over the voice casting of one of its main characters. Creator Raphael Bob-Waksberg was recently asked about the issue, and his response was pretty much the best answer that can be given in such a scenario.
Diane Nguyen is the human woman initially assigned to ghostwrite BoJack's forthcoming memoirs. Over the course of the show, the pair have gone from being ambivalent colleagues to something more like proper (if a bit dysfunctional) friends. Allison Brie, the actress who voices Diane, is white and while Diane's ethnicity (she's written as a Vietnamese woman) doesn't always feature prominently in her BoJack Horseman plot lines, it's part of her identity all the same, which is what gave many people pause when word first broke of Brie's casting.
In the four years since BoJack first premiered creator Raphael Bob-Waksberg hadn't really spoken out all that much about the accusations calling the show out for casting a white actor to portray a character of colour. But when a fan recently asked Bob-Waksberg about the show's lack of representation, he said that while he supports the cast he works with now, if given the opportunity to develop the show now, he'd make a point of not simply leaning on the idea of colourblind casting.
Short answer: I love my entire cast, but if I were doing it today, I would not cast the show (or any show) with all white people. I've really soured on the idea of "color-blind" casting as an excuse to not pay attention. https://t.co/DG8DDoD9QX
— Raphael Bob-Waksberg (@RaphaelBW) January 15, 2018
At the time Bob-Waksberg added that he didn't think Twitter was the best place to fully express his feelings about the whitewashing issue, but he followed up in an interview with Uproxx yesterday where he spelled out his thoughts more fully.
When asked about whether he knew about the criticisms being levelled against the show, Bob-Waksberg admitted that he did and also said he believed no one had ever asked him about it directly in interviews because most of the people interviewing him were other white men:
For a while I thought, maybe I shouldn't be the one having this conversation. Maybe it's better if other people are talking about the show - people of colour, people who have lived experience, people who can actually talk about this more eloquently than I can. Maybe it's better for me to just make the show and try to listen to what people are saying and adjust [accordingly.]
But more and more I feel like this is my show and these are decisions that I've made and it's my responsibility to talk about them even if it's going to be awkward and even if it's going to feel weird for me… I think it's worth talking about and I feel like my silence can be read as "There's not a problem here" and I'm not comfortable with that anymore.
Bob-Waksberg's comments are a refreshing change of pace from the cavalcade of people within the industry who, after being fairly called out for whitewashing and other forms of less-than-ideal on-screen representation, either dismiss the claims entirely or pretend that they aren't a problem.
This is how you own up to a mistake publicly, keep it moving, and let everybody know you're going to do your damnedest to do better in the future.