Abdullah Karam, co-creator of an autobiographical game about leaving Syria in 2014, has been denied entry into the United Kingdom. Karam's visa application was rejected just days before he was supposed to attend the Casual Connect Europe games conference in London where his game, Path Out, was nominated for the Indie Prize award.
Abdullah Karam presenting Path Out last year in Budapest at the Sziget Festival. Photo: Causa Creations (Facebook)
Karam currently resides in Austria, where he's received refugee status. This has previously allowed him to travel to a number of different European countries without issue, according to a report by GamesIndustry.biz.
However, when he learned that Path Out was nominated for the Indie Prize in April (past winners include Hue, Shadow Tactics: Blades of the Shogun, and Floor Kids), he learned he'd need a visa in order to travel inside the UK, where the event was scheduled to take place at the end of May. According to Karam, this process required paying to expedite the process and travelling numerous times to Vienna for interviews.
After everything was finally submitted, Karam learned on May 23 that his application had been rejected. Karam shared the rejection letter with GamesIndustry.biz. It pointed to a lack of sufficient "translated evidence" by the game designer demonstrating his income. The reviewer of his application determined that Karam could not "be relied upon to meet the conditions of visit entry clearance", and wasn't convinced he intended to leave the UK once the visit was over.
— wobblersound (@wobblersound) May 29, 2018
"I think the decision is ludicrous," said Georg Hobmeier, Karam's colleague at Causa Creations, the studio behind Path Out and other games, in an email to Kotaku. "Some facts were simply wrong and the main argument was based on a missing non-mandatory item."
That item was evidence of Karam's finances, including a pay stub or bank statement, which Hobmeier and Karam said the rejection letter appeared to hinge on despite it not being a required part of the application. The UK visa application website lists supporting documents such as bank statements as optional.
In an email to Kotaku, he said he thought the work information he put in the application would suffice. "I thought the documents I included from my company were enough to prove my salary so other than it not being mandatory I didn't have any other reason not to include it."
As a refugee who fled the Syrian War and then made a game about it, the inability to freely travel to a game conference in another European city to promote it is a particularly disappointing twist.
"I felt sad and mistreated - let alone the fact they claimed I had two kids and wrote my email address wrong," Karam told GamesIndustry.biz, adding that he felt the treatment he received was possibly related to his background and refugee status. "A European will never have to go through this treatment, but for a refugee or citizen of a nation outside of the global power club it's a must."
Hobmeier, who is able to attend the event, also sees the application rejection, including its unhelpful timing of just a week before the game conference, as being part of a larger, anti-immigrant sentiment in Europe at the moment.
"In Austria we have a sad tradition of being on the forefront of right wing populism, heavy discrimination against refugees and hateful rhetorics have been part of our political discourse since decades. It's sad and shameful, but unfortunately true," he said.
"Other European countries have certainly jumped on that bandwagon lately and we see an increasingly vitriolic tone that is directed against migrants, most often a very transparent effort to blame those vulnerable parts of society for political shortcomings and social problems with other origins."
Whatever the ultimate reason, Karam will be missing the chance to attend the Indie Game prize event where Path Out is nominated either way, seemingly because the UK government is afraid if they let him into the country, he might never leave.