Netflix Remakes Saint Seiya And So Far, The Fan Reaction Is Not Good

Netflix Remakes Saint Seiya And So Far, The Fan Reaction Is Not Good

Saint Seiya: Knights of the Zodiac is Netflix’s updated take on the classic anime. Andromeda Shun, originally a male character, has been reworked as a female character.

The trailer (below) is racking up dislikes on YouTube.

Eugene Son, the remake’s producer, took to Twitter to explain the decision. Via Japanese site Hachima, here are his tweets:

Hachima" loading="lazy" > Screenshot: Hachima
Hachima" loading="lazy" > Screenshot: Hachima
Hachima" loading="lazy" > Screenshot: Hachima

Inclusiveness is great! The sensitivity to the current climate is admirable. Viewers who aren’t familiar with the series, especially younger viewers, will probably be oblivious to the change. However, for Saint Seiya fans, the decision overlooks the character’s essence and what makes him special.

Here is an excellent Twitter thread by Tales of Nothing co-creator Fanny Rodriguez that explains why:

Besides these thoughtful reasons, it also feels like other female Saint Seiya characters might have been overlooked when making a decision that could have better satisfied longtime fans.

Saint Seiya: Knights of the Zodiac debuts on Netflix next winter.


  • This seems like some really solid reasoning about why the character being male was integral to the theme.

    Seems a real shame that they’ve changed him for the remake.

  • Sooo, they didn’t want to be seen as making a statement by having a bunch of male characters… Do they think changing a primary character’s gender isn’t a statement in and of itself?

    I’ll never get changing existing properties like that… And I’d have the same “Uh, why?” reaction if people went and turned the likes of Samus or Lara Croft into dudes in gaming.

    • I don’t think they’re denying that it isn’t a statement in and of itself.
      rather than by not changing it they might have been making a statement on gender roles that they didn’t intend or agree with.

    • I reckon its subtle when he was explaining it, but I think what he was really trying to say was something along the lines of
      “In this new age, I am actually afraid of creating something with an all male cast lest I get hate from the progressives. I rather take my chances with the fans”

  • I could not care less to be honest…As long as the series explains their origin and then builds a good story, I don’t care about adhering to the past. If I want to see the old storyline, I’ll watch the old series.

    What I’m saying is stop calling it a remake and just call it the 2019 series…

    • Very much this!

      If you are going to get to the point of drastically altering in a series then at the very least make it its own thing… SSSS Gridman still has some of the themes from the original Tokusatsu show years ago but has its own spin on the themes a new cast based both on the first concept AND new faces in relation to the theme changes.

      Just calling it Saint Seiya and then suddenly alterring the main character whilst being functionally the same in plot and story sorta seems more of a cash in on the brand to get views IMHO

  • I’ve never really had much knowledge of Saint Seiya but yeah, this does seem like a bit of a shame the way they’ve done this.
    add in more female characters? that’s fine
    genderbend the most softhearted male character as if that made him the natural choice to get that treatment? less fine.

  • Why not follow the Hobbit’s example and instead of changing the gender of the core group, add in a female character?

    • That was kinda the 2nd point… there are already great female characters in the original. Why change the gender of the main character when you coulda have had an original spin off/show based on the female lead mentioned

  • Heh, one really does have to wonder how many people crying out over this were not the same who used to make fun of the character for being overly effeminate.

    I don’t super dig the change but I’m willing to wait and see. My biggest concern at this point is that those cosmo energy attacks look rather cheesy in 3D.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!