Final Fantasy XIV’s Director Talks Blue Mages, World Visits, And ‘Modern’ MMOs

Final Fantasy XIV’s Director Talks Blue Mages, World Visits, And ‘Modern’ MMOs

Final Fantasy XIV is prepping for a new expansion later this summer. The lead-up to this expansion, Shadowbringers, has brought new classes like the Blue Mage, and will soon open worlds with the ability to visit other servers.

Kotaku emailed questions to game director Naoki Yoshida (a.k.a. “Yoshi P”) about new job classes, whether or not world visits could shake up economies, and what multiplayer games he’s keeping his eyes on these days.

On the introduction of Blue Mages:

Naoki Yoshida: The Blue Mage is only able to acquire balance because it is what we now call a “limited job,” and there are no plans to remove the limited aspect from the job.

However, we do plan to raise the level cap on the Blue Mage—and this doesn’t necessarily have to be timed with an expansion release. So at some point during the 5.x patch series, players can expect new blue magic which can be acquired, additions to the Masked Carnivale, and even new content to tackle.

I would say we are only at the “So You Want to be a Blue Mage?” chapter in the overall journey for this job – there is a lot of future blue mage content in the pipeline for our players to enjoy.


On the idea of “limited” jobs:

Heather Alexandra, Kotaku: But how do you decide what is or is not limited? For Blue Mage, it seemed to rest in how difficult it was to control when players unlocked certain skills. Is there another job that you want to have in-game but only see working as a limited class? Beastmaster, for instance?

Yoshida: The process of developing one of these jobs doesn’t start with us asking ourselves what will be the next limited job.

We are, however, mindful of two things: ensuring both that the job or job type we implement will be enjoyed by the players, and that it will make for an interesting and fun experience. During this process, if we come to a potential job that we feel may not necessarily fit well within standard party gameplay, we will then consider whether or not we make it a limited job.

With Blue Mage, for example, we run in to the issue where learning monster actions is the main pillar of the job, but we can potentially see a huge disparity in power between Blue Mages depending on the blue magic they have learned—even if their job level is the same. In other words, too large of a disparity in the number of blue magic abilities learned would create issues if Blue Mages were able to queue normally for duties.

Additionally, blue magic is interesting because they are powerful. However, if we allow Blue Mages to queue for the newest raid, we would need to weaken much of the blue magic to properly adjust the class to the fight, and I feel it would be boring for the Blue Mage. To avoid issues, we created this as a limited job—this allows us to circumvent the problem but still have an enjoyable job.

By utilising this concept of limited jobs, I feel that it could potentially open up possibilities to explore the addition of jobs such as like Puppetmaster and Beastmaster.

On comparisons to Final Fantasy XI and making a “modern” MMO:

Yoshida: Whenever we compare FFXI with FFXIV, I believe it’s important to have a knowledge of the history of the MMORPG genre. FFXI is a part of the first generation of MMORPGs, and the game itself is structured heavily on a “time to win” model. There is the assumption that players will spend huge amounts of time in-game, and therefore the game world provides the freedom to adventure without guiding the player through it.

However, because you have the freedom, people end up getting lost, or just spend a lot of time travelling between locations. Furthermore, there was the aspect of not being able to progress through almost all content without a party. This type of gameplay experience continued for quite some time [in the MMO space].

Although this did create some very strong experiences and memories which helped to drive the development of the MMORPG genre, it also created an issue on the opposite end of the spectrum: players weren’t able to actually play the game because they couldn’t dedicate the time.

When we were redesigning FFXIV for A Realm Reborn following the failure of FFXIV 1.0, I had a very strong mindset to make A Realm Reborn the final game of the second generation of MMORPGs. Modern day gamers are very busy, and time has become far more valuable than money—many forms of entertainment, not limited video games, are now vying for players’ time.

Keeping that in mind, the base of FFXIV is built upon providing a high-quality experience for players, even if they are only playing in shorter sessions. On top of that base, we create content that provides the opportunity for those who wish to spend more time playing, but never making this a mandatory experience. This is the difference in gameplay experience when comparing FFXI and FFXIV.

I grew up heavily immersed in first generation MMORPGs myself, so I would like to have the opportunity to create a game that fits that mould, but I’m certain it would be tough to sell in this day and age…

On the upcoming World Visit system and whether or not it might affect server economies:

Alexandra: I know some players who are worried that their servers might see a rise in bots when the gates open. Is the team doing anything to prepare for these sort of things and combat this in the future?

Yoshida: I believe there is no doubt that the economy will show some fluctuation, but I don’t think farming bots would suddenly increase in number across all the worlds. Unless there’s a sudden surge in the number of players, supply and demand should not change drastically.

The game economy will show increased activity at first, and I think players will jump from world to world to sell and buy items. However, each of these economies will establish a price point within in the market, and the initial fluctuations should stabilise.

I am honestly a bit more concerned about fluctuations in the market price being very severe over a short amount of time rather than an increase in bots.

As an aside, we have always been applying countermeasures against bots, and as we report to our players each week, we continue to ban thousands to tens of thousands of characters that are determined to be taking part in these activities. We will continue to do our due diligence to mitigate this type of activity.


On the other multiplayer games he follows:

Yoshida: I regularly check out all varieties of online games, but currently feel that Monster Hunter: World has great potential. The ease of content matching and the unique gameplay experience that almost instantaneously provides excitement works very well within the current gaming era, and I feel that there’s even greater potential for the title.

One other strong example would, of course, be the World of Warcraft. Looking at the various challenges they took on with their latest expansion package, I feel they have a certain foresight that can look even a few years ahead, and continue to stay strong.


  • I really enjoyed being a part of FFXI’s world and I regret that I didn’t get into FFXIV. I bought it a couple of times (I mean it IS a number FF game…), but never took the plunge. I dunno if I have the time for it and I worry it’ll be like FFXI where it starts infringing on your personal life (some of those raids required massive amounts of organisation skill, time management and adaptability in communication to just arrive at the location without even knowing if you had a chance of pulling the feat off).
    Do any Kotaku AUS players play?

    • Yeah I play. It is by very story rich so I find I do a couple of quests each day or so as well as the daily dungeons. When I do reach end game level content I find I am usually too busy in the real world to commit to the raid but that doesn’t bother me because there are so many other things to do other than raid.

    • I play still, I catch up every few months and then spend the rest of the time helping people and chatting. Not much energy for progression raiding though.

    • It’s really not a lot like FFXI at all. It’s much more casual-friendly. One of Yoshida’s core design philosophies is that the game should never feel like you have to log in every day to catch up. FFXI was very open and extremely hardcore. XIV is much more modern in its design, though some might say it’s a bit hand-holdy.

      It’s also extremely content and feature-rich if you’re coming in as a new player. The bulk of the game is gated on the main story progression and that main story is *enormous*, and also pretty good for the most part (especially the Heavensward expansion). Every major patch adds more story content and you need to do it all. I think getting through everything from level 1 to current would be a good 80-100 hours.

      Also their job system means you’re generally not rolling an alt, since one character can pick up every class/job. People are always running all the older dungeons and everything as well, because they’ve built good incentives to do daily runs and have a system that scales you down to the appropriate level, plus people will be running them as they level up new jobs.

      It’s definitely worth giving it a go. I haven’t been playing recently but spent a good part of 2017 and 2018 playing, and probably will be heading back in for Shadowbringers later in the year, even if just to play through the story.

  • I played FFXI for years, and I’ve played FFXIV since A Realm Reborn launched. (Although I did take a year or two off)
    Just last year I went back to FFXI and finished all of the main story and expansion missions that I’d never completed in my main years. Glad I did that, but the core of that game has been drastically altered, and I pretty much did everything from Wings of the Goddess onwards completely solo.
    As mentioned, FFXIV is a LOT more respectful of your time. It’s super-easy to zap yourself around anywhere in the world, you level up in a fraction of the time FFXI used to take, and there is always lots of stuff to do.
    The story’s also (mostly) really good, if perhaps a bit long-winded. And the soundtrack is among the best in the entire FF series.
    Definitely worth a look, I’d say.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!