I Learned To Love Andromeda By Not Expecting It To Be Mass Effect

I Learned To Love Andromeda By Not Expecting It To Be Mass Effect

When Mass Effect Andromeda first released nearly two years ago, I was pretty hard on it. The original Mass Effect trilogy is one of my favourite game series of all time, and a lot of what I loved about those games just didn’t seem to be present in Bioware’s ambitiously sprawling open world sequel.

This article contains spoilers for Mass Effect Andromeda.

jb hifi gaming deals

Where Mass Effect had focused on introducing me to a galaxy that felt strange and new, Andromeda seemed to be content with just showing me new coats of paint on species I already knew. There was an Asari who was obsessed with an alien race from the past; a human woman who was so perfect it was a problem for her; a battle-ready Krogan male who hated the Salarians; and a snarky pilot. It was nothing I’d not already seen.

Sure, I would eventually meet Jaal, a single solitary crew member of a new alien species, but it felt like a token new piece of content in a sea of returning characters. The whole premise of Mass Effect Andromeda is that we we’re exploring a brand new unexplored galaxy. The Salarian, Turian, and Asari arks have gone missing, with only the human ark arriving intact. It’s a perfect excuse to populate the game’s hub with a minimal selection of familiar alien races, and let us go out and meet a bunch of new aliens before returning the familiar alien races to the plot later.

Along with the species I already knew, I revisited conflicts I thought I had solved in Mass Effect 3. I no longer had the sense that I was some awesome hero out to single-handedly save the world. I was doing nothing more than trying to turn off big alien dehumidifiers and finding spots so we could build a home on a giant ball of ice. I expected more Mass Effect – but Andromeda was offering something much different than what I had anticipated.

I spent a lot of time in my first playthrough of Mass Effect Andromeda focusing on what the game is not. Now, two years later, I’m finally starting to see it for what it is.

I started replaying Mass Effect Andromeda a few weeks ago, largely out of desire for more Mass Effect. Replaying the original trilogy with my partner made me crave more of that universe, and it got me thinking about how much I wanted to like Andromeda. I don’t know if it’s the years that have passed since it released, or it it’s having my expectations better in check a second time around, but finally, I’m starting to see the beauty of Andromeda.

Sure, its world is bloated and too sprawling, but that’s sort of integral to its story. Andromeda is about exploring a completely new galaxy, trying to find a home, and feeling alone in a remote corner of space. Planets with huge amounts of open space, covered in tough-to-manoeuvre terrain, aren’t fun to traverse if you’re just racing from A to B in pursuit of the next story mission. But it’s the things you find as you traverse along the path between missions that’s truly amazing.

There’s a real sense that you’re alone, charting a very important map. It’s easy to believe that, without your exploration, these planets would never grow to be the sprawling metropoles present in the original Mass Effect trilogy. Whether you’re finding pieces of missing ships or interacting with sages who believe their species is capable of reincarnation, it’s all about stopping every few minutes to find a new plot thread, each one pulling you in a totally different direction.

If you try to fix every problem on a planet you’ll be there forever, but if you follow the most interesting and pressing threads, you’ll find yourself in the middle of some truly captivating stories.

Andromeda is a game about being a settler rather than a soldier, and that’s something I needed to adjust to. I’m not here to kick down doors with a rifle in my hands; I’m here to help a new species of alien learn to trust outsiders. I’m here to keep people calm, and keep them believing that they have not arrived in Andromeda simply to die alone in space.

It’s not a game about racing between objectives; it’s a game about exploring, about making small steps that add up in order to improve life on these planets in meaningful ways. Sure, you can kill the aliens attacking a planet, but the real solution is to provide their own planet with increased water production and answers about their ecology.

A lot of the moral choices made in Mass Effect Andromeda don’t feel like they have any lasting impact on the way the game ends, which on my first playthrough I saw as a failure. Choices about whether to harvest fish for their anti-enemy weaponry properties, or to protect them for their historical value don’t really change anything later in the game, which originally felt like a frustrating illusion of choice. New dialogue options no longer opened up based on how I had been playing, and it was unclear when a choice was purely cosmetic or was genuinely impactful.

On a second playthrough however, I accepted that not every choice had to have a mechanical consequence. In doing so, it allowed some choices to merely be moral quandaries. That’s something that was missing from earlier games in the series.

When a moral choice has a set path that leads to characters staying alive or communities thriving, it’s easy to look at the results rather than the underlying moral question. There’s something rather nice about personally pondering these queries without worrying that the game would consider one option to be better or worse than another.

When I found a man in prison, charged with murder of his commanding officer, I pulled a thread that led to discovering he had not actually fired the shot that killed his officer – but he’d intended to and thought he had. I had to discuss with politicians whether it was right to convict a man who was technically innocent of murder, but guilty of attempted murder. The new colony he was a part of was already unstable, so we also had to discuss whether hiding his intent was worth the risk of extra instability.

There was no red or blue meter to fill nor any signposting to which answer might have effects on the future; just a personal moral choice that differing schools of philosophy would have different answers to.

Where the original Mass Effect‘s dialogue option and moral choice systems combined to create a game where players are rewarded for either being a consistent lawful or chaotic character, Andromeda muddies those waters in ways which made me need to stop and think.

While I’ve written a lot here about design choices that are not inherently better or worse in Andromeda compared to the original trilogy, simply different, I do have to mention some undeniable improvements Andromeda made to the series. Namely, the combat feels a lot smoother, the jetpack jumping movement options are very rewarding, and the options for controlling how you level up your character are far better fleshed out.

Mass Effect Andromeda didn’t do a good job of setting expectations for fans of the original trilogy. The decision not to factor in your choices from the original games left many players feeling like their choices were ignored, not to mention the game relied too heavily on familiar alien archetypes, its worlds felt unfocused, and it was undeniably broken at launch. Still, a couple of years on, I can say that I like Mass Effect Andromeda a lot more than I once did.

It might not shine brightly as a sequel to the original Mass Effect trilogy, but it does shine when given space to be its own, unique experience. Now, if only they’d given me a Hanar squad member, I’d have probably called it game of the year. Let me play as a squishy religious jellyfish brain creature already, Bioware.

The 1980s Game That Predicted The Internet

This post originally appeared on Kotaku UK, bringing you original reporting, game culture and humour with a U from the British isles.


  • I think my biggest disappointment with Andromeda isn’t that is wasn’t Mass Effect, but that it wasn’t Star Trek. With the premise of people journeying to an entire new galaxy they didn’t know anything about I was looking forward to lots of missions about discovering strange new things and making contact with a bunch of new alien races and the diplomatic problems that would arise from that.

    Instead we stuck to one tiny corner of the Andromeda galaxy, all the planets we explored were pretty basic single biome planets typical of sci-fi, and there were only three new races introduced. The good race, who we got along with basically straight away; the bad race, who were bad; and the ancient mysterious race that felt like a repeat of what we’d already dealt with in the original games with the Protheans and Reapers.

    It was a huge missed opportunity to make use of an interesting premise. Funnily enough Anthem has similar issues. The setting of Anthem, where the “gods” have left behind a half finished world and left behind their tools of creation that are malfunctioning and cause basically anything to happen, is a great premise on which to build some really interesting story and gameplay. And yet that premise is also woefully underused.

    With a setting like that you could have the player go to some really interesting environments. A desert where it regularly snows. Massive trees that reach into the upper atmosphere. Lakes of water hanging in the sky. Even more interesting stuff that I can’t think of right now. But instead everything is just a forest, with the most interesting things being a floating island or two and some backwards travelling waterfalls (which are both fairly standard in sci-fi/fantasy).

    You could play around with the gameplay. Have a section of the game where gravity is inverted, or an underwater section where the water is boiling and overheats your suit, while flying into the air cools is down (in reverse of how it normally works). They could have the player find themselves temporarily teleported to other dimensions or other worlds. But there’s nothing like that. They could spawn some really interestingly designed weapons, but all the monsters in the game have the most standard monster designs possible.

    It really feels like BioWare has been having an execution problem lately. Not just with with Andromeda and Anthem, but also Dragon Age Inquisition. They come up with all these great ideas for their games, but then they just can’t quite make it all work in practice.

  • I was about the only person I knew who actually enjoyed playing Andromeda. Having never played a Mass Effect going in, I didnt have any sort of expectations weighing me down.
    I often think about how it was really strange that I could enjoy something so much while everyone else hated it so passionately; so this article was a pleasant surprise!

      • Yep same. Id played the original trilogy 3 times through by the time i went into Andromeda. It was very different in many ways and had many issues (especially since I was playing from launch, so only like 1-2 patches were released by the time Id finished the game), but I still very much enjoyed it.
        Having now been 2 years (wheres the time gone?) I am almost finished my 4th play through of the original trilogy and ready to give Andromeda a second play through.

    • I’m really enjoying too. Just playing through at the moment after picking it up on PSN for $7 a while back. I hadn’t;t played the previous ones either, so it seems that’s the best way t get enjoyment out of it!

  • I really should get around to finishing this game. I’ll probably have to start from the beginning again.

  • I honestly can’t say I was disappointed. I played it a year after release, I already knew it wasn’t going to be more of the same, and it was fixed by then. Between the fantastic gameplay, gorgeous visuals, and just being able to experience more Mass Effect, it was a good game on it’s own terms. I can see where there was much more potential, and I can only hope we get a sequel, so it can be given a chance to reach that potential.

  • I really enjoyed it. Like others I picked it up for $7 on the PSN sale and it was great for the 30-40 hours until the end.

    I shoved it on easy and played through it for the story. I liked the shooting and the powers. By the end you were pulling and pushing enemies around like a boss. The story was good for me, some of the side quests were a bit grindy and it did seem to boil down to explore each planet, switch on the big generators then explore the big tomb thingys. The main missions were pretty cinematic. The story obviously not up to the caliber of Mass Effect 2 but the shooting was better and I would recommend it especially for the cheap price it is going for now.

    I stuck with the story to the end which is more than I can say for “better” games like Horizon Zero Dawn, GTAV or RDR2 where I got bored of the missions after 20 hours or so.

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!