In Black Mirror, Dating Is Awful But Not Hopeless

Black Mirror's best episode of season four is, again, a love story.

Season three's standout, "San Junipero," maybe the series' first happy episode, was a sweet love story about two women falling for each other in a simulated world. This season's fourth episode, "Hang The DJ," has the setup of a good dystopian young adult novel. The lead characters, Amy and Frank, are participants in The System, a dating service that shunts people into a series of relationships until it can algorithmically find "the one." It's kind of like hell's OK Cupid. Participants hang around an idyllic closed community, going on jogs and skipping rocks on a lake, until their Coach, an Alexa-like device that the characters carry around all the time, tells them they have a new relationship. The lengths of these relationships can last anywhere from 12 hours to a year. They don't get a say in who they're matched with or for how long. The System is using their reactions to different kinds of relationships to determine who "the one" is for them. It has 99.8% accuracy, but its processes are opaque. They just have to trust it.

One of Black Mirror's greatest strengths is its subtle storytelling. Despite sometimes being overly blunt in its moralizing, each episode throws you into a brand new world and lets you figure things out just with a few snippets of information from the environment and characters. When Amy and Frank meet, they check when their relationship is set to end on their Coaches and comment that 12 hours is a bit short. Their meals have been pre-selected: Amy has a nice-looking pasta, and Frank has some kind of fish cake. When he takes a bite of Amy's pasta off her fork after asking if that's something they're allowed to do, the camera lingers on a threatening-looking man watching them from over Frank's shoulder, taser in hand. From there, they go to their cabin. Being that this is their first date, they both freak out at the prospect of spending the night with each other. Amy, amusingly, asks her Coach if they're just supposed to "go at it" and her Coach replies, "Define 'go at it.'"

They don't end up having sex, but rather lay together on the bed holding hands, musing about how much dating must have sucked before The System. "People had to do the whole relationship thing themselves," Amy says. "And if things seem shitty, they have to figure out if they wanted to break up with someone." Frank scoffs, saying, "How to break up with someone? Fucking hell."

Watching "Hang the DJ," I felt a pang of jealousy at the notion that, in this world, these two haven't ever had to end a relationship before. The System seems a lot worse, though. As Frank and Amy go on to their next relationships we see this society's inscrutability in action. Amy ends up with a pretty hot, charming guy she's to date for the next nine months. Frank ends up with a very irritated woman he has nothing in common with, who responds to one of his jokes with "So, you're the type of person who makes jokes." He has to date her for a year, and his Coach repeatedly tells him that disobeying The System will result in his expulsion from society.

Frank and Amy had an immediate chemistry. It was a delight to watch them get to know each other, to see them tease each other and slowly, carefully let their guards down. It's easy to see the arc of the episode: Frank and Amy are meant for each other, and The System is going to try to keep them apart.

"Hang The DJ" isn't trying to blow your mind, instead telling a simple but compelling love story. Like last season's "San Junipero," it can be bittersweet or even quite sad, but ultimately it's a story about two people trying to open up to one another, and how technology can both aid and impede that. Yes, "Hang the DJ" does have a twist that changes the context of the episode. It probably won't dazzle you, as it gets telegraphed pretty early in. Even if you know what's coming, it's still a charming episode with two likeable leads that I genuinely rooted for.

After Frank finally finishes out his horrible year-long relationship with a woman he hates and who also hates him, Frank and Amy get rematched. It turns out for the past three months, The System has put Amy in a series of 36-hour relationships -- just about enough time to meet someone, have sex, and then go their separate ways. What started out as fun has made her incredibly jaded. Over dinner, she tells Frank that she finds all these short flings dissociating, describes having sex with a guy who is "basically just a haircut," and recalls being so detached that she had an out of body experience, feeling like she was watching herself have sex with him from across the room but not actually there. She later says asks Frank if maybe The System isn't processing all their reactions from these relationships and instead grinding them down until they will settle for anything. "Each time you get a little bit more pliable, a little bit more broken," she says, "until eventually it coughs up the final offering and says that's the one." Frank tells her that that is one of the bleakest things he's ever heard.

It's these moments that feel like "Hang The DJ" is trying to say something about modern romance. When Frank is without Amy, he's miserable. In one funny scene, he tells a woman who's also sad about her last relationship about how much he misses Amy while she is giving him a blow job. Unlike Amy, Frank doesn't seem all that interested in casual sex or dating, so The System is not really a good fit for him. Still, his desire to just settle down backfires. During his second relationship with Amy, she makes him promise not to check their expiry date, to just date her without worrying about the future. He can't resist and looks anyway, and because he broke her trust their time together dwindles from five years to 18 hours. As he mourns what he's lost, his Coach will only say to him the most frustrating aphorism about dating: Everything happens for a reason.

While Amy doesn't seem to want to be tied down too fast, going back to a series of flings leaves her almost broken. In a stark, sad sequence, the audience watches Amy's bed from over her shoulder. Although the partners change, she remains the same, standing completely still. When the camera cuts to her face she's impassive, unfeeling, seemingly unable to react to or care about the people she and the audience are watching filter through her life.

Dating is just hard. There's no real way to fix that. It's depressing, it can be humiliating, and sometimes you will fuck up and hurt the one you love. There will probably not ever be some technological panacea that takes the frustration out of that process. "Hang The DJ" makes it seem worth it. When Frank and Amy realise they need each other it's pure and unpretentious and beautiful. Even if Black Mirror can't help but throw another twist their way, it doesn't sour the preceding hour of watching these two people fall for each other. There's no cynicism. Despite how hard it is, falling in love really is worth all that pain.


Comments

    Awesome episode and one of the best BM episodes so far imo. Joy, sadness, futility of dating, empty relationships. Loved it.

    Far preferred the first episode to this one. Didn't mind it, but found the payoff to be rather empty to be honest. The first episodes analysis of the obsessive fan psyche, toxic masculinity and other aspects were engrossing to say the least. But apart from that, I found this to be the absolute worst season of Black Mirror unfortunately.

      I've got to agree. Sadly, whether it was the switch to 6 episodes a season or something else going on behind the scenes since the show has become a Netflix original something feels missing.

      The writing seems more American in style, the twists, technologies and even characters are starting to look all too familiar and the twists are often my least favourite parts of each episode. I'd say especially so in Hang the DJ in which I was far more invested in the straight narrative before the predictable and sort of flat twist.

      Ultimately I think the show lacks the 'mirror' part of its title in this last season, what facet of society is actually being reflected in any of these episodes? This is where the first episode was perhaps the most successful, there was an aspect of society, or at least individuals in a society it was building upon and critiquing, but the others either wasted the technological / societal critique it might have offered (Crocodile) or lacked anything interesting to say about the technology that made up the entirety of the story (Metalhead).

      I'm probably being a little harsh, but Seasons 1 and 2 were something genuinely special, season 3 was great TV, although not on the same level as 1 and 2 and then 4 was just enjoyable. I didn't once think any deeper about the implications of the narrative - those thoughts being, for me at least, the reason I love Black Mirror.

        Echoes my thoughts exactly - though I did actually at least watch all of S4 - I gave up on S3 half way through. It was a drag. But White Bear had me SHOOK and there were multiple episodes that left me mentally drained and contemplating life on the couch after they ended. S3 and S4? Basically every episode bar this one was a slow march toward a horrible ending for one of the characters.

    my favourite episode since Fifteen Million Merits, well that is until I saw Black Museum.

    There is just something really special about Black Mirror. I go out of my way not to watch trailers or read anything until after I watch it. Its like a lucky dip. Am I in for a fun ride, a harrowing parable, a chilling macabre tale. I like that each episode can be virtually about anything and you are not sure how you should be reacting to what you are watching until you are finished watching it.

    Charlie really hit it out of the park this season.

      Yeah, Hang the DJ and Black Museum were standouts this season for me.

      Spot on! I find it best to go in cold too. Black museum blew me away. Even when this show doesn't quite hit the target it's still one of the best shows around

    you know that ep, just showed what an Alpha rythem does right?

Join the discussion!