What Comics Do You Think Should Have Been Nominated For The Eisner Awards?

Black Mask Studios

The nominees for this year's Eisner awards have been announced and, the contenders represent some of the best writing and illustration in the comics industry. But, as is always the case, there are countless amazing books that didn't receive a nod.

Unlike the Hugo awards, which are chosen based on votes from everyone who attends Worldcon, the Eisners are selected by a much smaller panel of blue-ribbon judges. On the one hand, this means it's nearly impossible for trolls to hijack Eisners the way they have the Hugos in the past, but it also means that the nominees are only reflective of the judges' tastes.

While it's safe to trust the judges' read on the comics scene (really, this year's selection is very good) it's difficult not to think about the books that you would have pushed for as you read the list. Take writer Kwanza Osajyefo, Tim Smith 3, Jamal Igle, and Khary Randolph's Black, for example.

Black Mask Studios

Black's story of a world in which black people — and only black people — develop superpowers and are hunted by the police is both a bold and timely piece of social commentary about American police brutality. It's Black's covers, though, that always catch my eye when I see them in comic shops.

Allegorical comics like Black speak in metaphors, but the covers speak in very explicit and overt ways to contemporary and historical anti-black racism. I, personally, would have pushed for Randolph's covers to be included in this year's Eisners for reasons that should be obvious.

What about you? Who and what do you think deserve a shot at the glory? Here are the categories and nominees, if you need a refresher.


    I am gonna do the cardinal sin and suggest somethings from the mainstream;

    -Best Continuing Series to Batman; Tom King is killing it and shows us he has a clear knack for taking a character that should very well be stale in new and interesting directions. His bane arc only just slightly falls short of Scott Snyder's Court of Owls.

    -Best Writer/Artist to Jeff Lemire & Andrea Sorrentino on Old Man Logan. Everything about this pair works together exceedingly well. There is something about Sorrentino's art does an amazing job of conveying Logan's age. The lack of colour and detail make everything feel just as alien as Logan in the main continuity; coupled with his story of trying to fix what he perceives to be a looming extermination of the heroes make the story truly awesome.

    -Best New Series to Deathstroke: Rebirth. You have to give it to Christopher Priest; the guy literally only returned to DC on the condition that they wouldn't pigeonhole him and give him complete creative freedom to go to town and holy cow did he. The story is at times hard to follow, but anyone that sort of understands Deathstroke's chaotic (and sometimes really messed up) origin or is just looking for a well developed storyline that isn't going to completely hold your hand, should most certainly check this out.


Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now