The Last Of Us 2’s Scariest Scene Has A Gameplay Problem

10
Screenshot: Naughty Dog
Screenshot: Naughty Dog

Between the screaming fungus zombies and the overtones of mindless militarism, The Last of Us Part 2 is basically one big, playable nightmare. But the scariest moment of the game comes at the midway point.

Illustration: Kotaku

At the end of Abby’s “Seattle Day 2” chapter, you end up at the Washington Liberation Front’s hospital base. Your goal is to pop in, snag some medicine, and pop out. Naturally, everything goes sideways. Eventually you have to make your way to the basement; through conversations with Nora (this is before Ellie cold-bloodedly murders her) and some scattered collectibles, you learn that the area is ground zero for the cordyceps outbreak in Seattle and has gone largely untouched for three decades. Sounds like a fun and totally not-terrifying place to explore, yeah?

You sneak through the dark, plundering some cabinets and turning on a generator. At the end of your search, you find the medicine you need in the cab of an ambulance. Roughly two seconds later, a massive Infected rips the ambulance doors off. It’s called the Rat King, it’s the oldest Infected in Seattle, and it’s no singular entity. Three decades stuck in a cordyceps-filled cavern caused a small contingent of Infected — clickers, stalkers, runners, and one very angry shambler — to fuse together like a nightmare-inducing Voltron. Nothing in The Last of Us series comes closer to the horror of the Rat King. Seriously, just look at this thing:

Screenshot: Naughty Dog/Kotaku

I know I’m not the only one who summarily pissed their pants. A friend texted me as the scene went down, and had some thoughts:

Screenshot: Apple/Kotaku

You fight the Rat King in dark corridors, running for your life while emptying every clip in your arsenal into its Hummer-sized body. Once you whittle its health down enough, an Infected splits off from the host body in a brief cutscene that’s, to quote my friend, “fucked up.” You then have to fight both of them. On paper, it should make your blood run cold. So it’s a shame that the encounter itself is really rather boring.

Boss fights in Naughty Dog’s recent games tend to be cinematic, timing-based combat challenges interspersed with quick-time events. See: Nadine Ross in Uncharted 4, Talbot in Uncharted 3, Asav in Uncharted: The Lost Legacy, or Nadine Ross in Uncharted 4 (again). Even such encounters in The Last of Us series follow a similar script. Recall Ellie, in the first game, sneaking through a restaurant, avoiding piles of shattered ceramic plates, just to get the jump on a sadistic cannibal with a bad haircut. These fights require a keen eye and sound strategy, or at least the illusion of it.

By contrast, there’s only one way to take down the extremely absorbent bullet sponge Rat King: Shoot it. A lot.

Tips For Playing The Last Of Us Part 2

It’s been seven years and an entire console generation, but we finally have another Last of Us game. Out today for PlayStation 4, The Last of Us Part 2 plays much like the first game: tight, third-person action set in open-ended levels with a heavy focus on stealth. Much like...

Read more

In defeating the Rat King, I went through an entire tank of flamethrower fuel, a dozen 9mm pistol bullets, at least half a dozen hunting pistol rounds, six incendiary shells for the shotgun, four regular shells for the shotgun, three crossbow bolts, two full clips of the military rifle, two pipe bombs, and one very sleepless night. Show me one bloater that can survive all of that.

If the Rat King touches you once, you’re done for. It doesn’t help that the fight takes place in a cramped, waterlogged subterranean room. You can technically leap through windows into various other rooms or duck behind objects, but the Rat King will simply crash through whatever wall you’re behind. So the “strategy,” such as it is, is mindless: Turn on your heel, sprint, stop, shoot, reload, repeat. There’s a convenient hallway behind the level’s starting point that makes it easy to create some distance.

Screenshot: Naughty Dog/Kotaku

The Last of Us Part 2’s wonky checkpointing also helps with the lift. Often, checkpoints will save during the middle of encounters. In this boss fight, they seem to come after you dish out a certain amount of damage. (There’s no helpful health bar indicating where you’re at in the fight, though. You literally have to just spray and pray.) Once you realise that, you can cheese your way through the fight by pumping the Rat King full of lead, dying, and reloading ad infinitum (at least on the normal difficulty setting). When you die, you’ll come back with some ammo. It sucks the wind out of the sails of what, by all rights, should be one of the most tense moments in the game. If there’s no consequence to scamming the system, why not do so with abandon?

This is the core issue in the fight against the Rat King. Most of the gameplay in The Last of Us Part 2 is all about making the most of what little you have. Even on lower difficulty levels, you’re constantly outnumbered, low on health, and pressed for ammo. The goal, then, is to find the smartest and most effective way through battle scenarios. Defeating the Rat King doesn’t require any such mastery — only patience (and a whole lot of bullets).

There’s also the unavoidable matter of narrative ramifications — or, rather, the lack thereof. If I was in Abby’s shoes, and I took this thing down, I’d never shut up about it. “Hi, yeah, I’ll take an iced oat milk latte, and also did you know that I killed the Rat King?” For Abby, though, it’s nothing more than yet another undead nightmare that stands between her and her goal. She kills it and wordlessly moves on. It’s characteristically badass. It’s also a window into how The Last of Part 2 treats this initially nail-biting, ultimately banal encounter.

More The Last of Us 2

I Love Cracking Safes In The Last Of Us Part 2

The Last of Us Part 2 has 14 locked safes scattered throughout its world. In contrast to the rest of the game, where resources are limited and ammo is scarce, these safes are loaded with supplies. In a game where visceral fun is in short supply, cracking these safes is...

Read more

I Have Mixed Feelings About The Last Of Us Part 2’s Trans Character

Whether or not you like The Last of Us Part 2, there’s no denying it’s a diverse game. People of different genders, sexualities, and races exist in its world, and there’s a perverse equality in the way none of them are exempt from suffering. The game’s only trans character, a...

Read more

Riding Horses In The Last Of Us 2 Feels Great, Here’s Why

The Last of Us Part 2 is a big, big game that excels at the little things: the way Joel raises his hand to block sunlight from his eyes, the way Ellie marks up a map of downtown Seattle with a Sharpie, or the feel of riding horses.

Read more

Comments

  • We totally need more games where the protagonist walks into local taverns saying stuff like “That badarse monster in yonder castle there? Yep, I killed it. That was me. Buy me a drink.”

    • or like Skyrim, when the moment you accomplish something in-game, everyone in the land gets notified of it and tells you about it…

  • I kinda agree with this. While initially terrifying, the lack of options to move around meant you had basically deliver as much damage as possible until some arbitrary point without dying, then when stalker comes off, and then again some point. It was frustrating to be repeatedly one hit, because there was barely room to move, and it didn’t really feel like an achievement to win.
    I would have preferred a more cat and mouse encounter, being able to move through broken walls and windows, similar to a point in the game where Yara and Lev leave you boxed in a run down building. Having the stalker tear off and begin hunting you would have been terrifying in that scenario.

  • This took me 3 tries. Drop the landmines as you run. When it is confused petrol bomb it and keep running corner to corner. Didnt take long at all.

  • Are you kidding? Lack of options? Jump around through windows, sneak around the place, lay mines, shoot it, throw grenades, you can still sneak. For a boss battle, this was pretty damn good. And only THEN do you get the issue of the Rat King separating it’s little partner off of it. When that happened? Jesus, I kept thinking “Am I gonna have to keep fighting off more and more of these?”

    I literally felt like Abby was in dire straits here, like I wasn’t going to survive (and I didn’t, many times). I loved it. Burn the damn thing, as much as you can, use landmines, use grenades. Pistol barely works, it’s a boss after all! Like Darren44 up there said, *keep moving* or you’ll die.

    Abby also makes a comment that noone would believe her remember?

    • Sounds like you had a much better experience than I did. I tried to sneak, seemed it always knew where I was. And every time I tried to dodge, or jump through the window, it was just straight up death. Maybe I just sucked at the game.
      The only success I had was running around the operating table 😀

      Also, I had serious difficulty seeing where I was going 90% of the time, maybe my picture was too dark.

  • I think Naughty Dog tend not to do great boss fights. They’re actually better when they go the QTE route. Stuff like this or “shoot the blue blobs as invincible guy walks past them 50 times” at the end of Uncharted 2 tend to be the low points of their respective games.

Log in to comment on this story!