Vince McMahon 1986 Rape Allegation Resurfaces As Former Wrestler Corroborates Story

Vince McMahon 1986 Rape Allegation Resurfaces As Former Wrestler Corroborates Story
Vince McMahon interviewing Rita Chatterton on the professional wrestling talk show, Tuesday Night Titans. (Screenshot: WWE / Peacock / Kotaku)

Amid news of misconduct and hush money payouts at the WWE, Rita Chatterton, the first female referee for the then-World Wrestling Federation, revisited her rape accusation against WWE CEO and chairperson Vince McMahon in an interview with New York Magazine.

McMahon has stepped back from his roles while the company’s board of directors conducts an investigation into his affair with another former-WWE employee, who was reportedly paid $US3 ($4) million in a separation agreement barring her from disparaging either the company or the relationship with McMahon. The investigation is also looking into allegations of misconduct against both McMahon and WWE head of talent relations John Laurinaitis.

Chatterton’s accusation goes back much farther, however. She first accused McMahon of raping her in the summer of 1986 during a 1992 interview with Geraldo Rivera on his show Now It Can Be Told. During the interview, Chatterton alleged that McMahon propositioned her with sex during a private meeting to get a higher-paying WWF contract.

By then, the statute of limitations for rape had already run out, and charges were never filed.

McMahon hired Chatterton to the WWF to referee for his storyline where American singer Cyndi Lauper managed wrestler Wendi Richter. After she was hired, Chatterton told New York Magazine that her friend and former wrestler Leonard Inzitari, warned her to stay away from Vince.

“He could make me or break me, and if I didn’t satisfy him, I was black-balled, that was it,” Chatterton told Rivera in 1992. “I was done.”

Chatterton told New York Magazine that McMahon pretended not to know her when they both attended Andre The Giant’s funeral. McMahon and his wife would later file a lawsuit against Chatterton and Rivera for false rape accusations. They later dropped the charges as the WWE had its hands full with unrelated trials regarding child molestation, sexual harassment, and trafficking illegal performance-enhancing drugs.

Read More: Everything We Know About WWE’s Probe Of Vince McMahon [Updated]

Today, McMahon and the WWE face new controversy as the misconduct probe continues. His daughter, Stephanie McMahon, is serving as the wrestling promotion’s interim CEO and chairperson while McMahon maintains creative control of ongoing WWE storylines.

The news of WWE’s internal investigation of McMahon led former wrestler Leonard Inzitari to corroborate Chatterton’s allegation against McMahon in the same New York Magazine report.

“Was she taken advantage of? Absolutely,” Inzitar told New York Magazine. “Was she scared to death? Absolutely. Did she wanna do that? Probably not.”

Both Inzitari and Chatterton told the publication they are not surprised by McMahon’s current investigation, and Chatterton added she is glad that allegations against him are being investigated.

“Now this girl’s come forward I’m sure others will come forward,” Chatterton told New York Magazine. “Because we’re not the only two. There’s not a doubt in my mind about that.”


  • I missed the part where this American sports news story was related to an Australian gaming news website…

    • You must be new, Kotaku has always covered stuff outside gaming and has never pretended otherwise.
      Wrestling has always been a common sight here, Ruby just interviewed a few American wrestlers the other week.
      The appearance of articles from the US and UK is also common and is often automated based on engagement and agreements between the various parent companies.
      (Same with AU articles)

      • “Kotaku has always covered stuff outside gaming and has never pretended otherwise.”

        You know you say that… But Kotaku US is definitely pretending that Ezra Miller doesn’t exist, especially since the big project he is currently involved in is, I’d argue, more in line with Kotaku’s interests.

        But I do look forward to the next “I hate Chris Pratt for arbitrary reasons” due out next week.

    • It’s curious that the article doesn’t mention a single game he worked on. It doesn’t mention any game development he’s been a part of. It doesn’t even mention any games at all. It’s because he’s not a part of it. Putting up an article about his sexual assault allegations on a gaming website is just a ridiculous stretch to make.

      • Who cares mate. I’m a WWF/WWE fan from waaaaaaaaaaaaaay back (1980s) and I’m glad they published it. Found it highly interesting myself, so thanks Isaiah, keep em coming.

        And if you don’t like that, then don’t click them to read em?

  • I find it funny when people query about why something is being published by Kotaku/x.

    It’s their business, so if they want to publish something, they can publish it.

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!