Eight Game Critics Band Together To Review Borderlands 2

Eight Game Critics Band Together To Review Borderlands 2

Pandora is a harsh and unforgiving planet to the unwary. What chance do eight video game critics have against the insane brutality of Handsome Jack and his minions? Perhaps these review scores will earn them a stay of execution.

Only a stay, mind you; Handsome Jack isn’t exactly known for not killing people, at least not for extended periods of time. Sooner or later, once he gets bored with his diamond horse, he’s going a person. It’s his thing. Can you really blame him? Those pretzels were incredibly stale.

I’ve played several hours of Borderlands 2 myself, and as far as I’m concerned Gearbox could have made the game Handsome Jack threatening you over the intercom for four hours while you’re tied to a chair in a completely white room and I still would have bought it. Hell, they could integrate Kinect.

Thankfully Gearbox did more than that, and it seems to have pleased reviewers, at least the ones not too busy waiting for Halo 4 and Call of Duty Black Ops 2.




Borderlands 2 is Gearbox’s chance to properly execute on a concept that only barely came together in 2009’s Borderlands. Borderlands was, in hindsight, propped up largely by a hope and a prayer. Taken only by its design, it’s a collection of parts from multiple genres — the quests of an MMO, loot influenced more by action RPGs like Diablo, and shooting out of, well, a shooter. None of these parts were exemplary, and they were even combined in what could be affectionately labelled a haphazard way. But the combination was new, and it was glued together by virtue of a coherent visual style that mimicked hand-drawn art. It felt new, which compensated for how patchy everything felt.

Gearbox has taken a fresh look with Borderlands 2 at the often weak connective tissue linking the pile of divergent ideas that defined its predecessor. The story is developed and surprisingly thoughtful, and systems link together more. The result is a better game in almost every regard and, interestingly enough, a more ambitious one. However, a clearer vision from the start doesn’t prevent Borderlands 2 from straining in several design directions at once.




Borderlands 2‘s main hook is its focus on “shooting and looting”. To that degree, the sequel offers significantly more choice and customisation than its predecessor. Guns are broken down into brands and damage modifiers. So, for example, a gun made by Hyperion will have a more high tech feel, whereas another line may provide punchier gunplay.The damage modifiers — fire, acid, and electricity, among others — all factor in heavily when selecting the best tool to take down enemy types.

It provides a strong sense of strategy to how to approach a mob of hostiles. Though the early stage weapons lack certain tactility, there’s a heft to higher-level guns that’s truly satisfying.




Perhaps the most notable difference is that Pandora now feels like a vibrant, living place. What once was a lonely frontier planet populated primarily by savage men and feral beasts is, well, still a planet populated primarily by savage men and feral beasts. But it isn’t so lonely anymore, thanks to an expanded cast of diverse and entertaining characters. Many familiar faces return, including the delusional robot, Claptrap; the hayseed mechanic, Scooter; and the bawdy vixen, Moxxi.

The four playable characters from the first game are back as well, and they each play a robust role in the story (and have way more spoken lines than ever before). There are some delightful new additions too, such as the arrogant antagonist, Handsome Jack, and the teenage demolitionist, Tiny Tina. Random townsfolk also have a few things to say, no longer content with mute or monosyllabic responses, and even the bandits you fight have a broader range of context-sensitive taunts.




Similarly to how the sidequests build upon the writing Gearbox became known for with the first game’s DLC, Borderlands 2 also expands upon other parts of the game in smaller, but still significant ways. From more options to how you sort missions, to easy ways to mark and sell loot, to an always present mini-map, the entire interface is simply a lot more user friendly and intuitive. Sadly, though, little has been done to improve the driving component of the series.

Outside of a few quests that require you to use a car, the vehicles feel largely underutilised and not all that valuable outside of getting you to destinations a lot quicker. Borderlands 2 is a shooter first and foremost, but it’d be awesome to see smarter mission design that takes advantage of them in, say, the way Halo does with its vehicle levels. Even so, they offer a change of pace from the rest of the game’s shoot and loot cycle.




Another element that gets a nice boost? The enemy AI, which took its fair share of knocks in Borderlands for predictability and a lack of advanced behaviours. Sure, you’ll still catch ’em with their pants down at times, but there’s an impressive leap here with the way enemies move through environments and work together, and the fact that Gearbox does both while offering up a host of creative variants per type is a real boon for the series. This does create some definite difficulty spikes when playing through solo, but considering the degree to which this game shines in its notably improved co-op play, it shouldn’t be a massive setback for folks as they play through.




I mean, when was the last time you cared about the name of any gun manufacturer in any shooter you played recently? Listen, I’ve played the heck out of the COD: MW titles, and I’ve used a TAR-21 more times than I care to mention, but I couldn’t tell you who manufactured it (not without looking it up, at any rate). The gun-makers in Borderlands 2 don’t even exist, for goodness sake, and I’m already brand-loyal to one of them. That would be Jakob, who proffer the most stylish firearms in the galaxy. If you want to take down a Badass Spiderant Burner, be a Gentleman about it, and use Jakob ordnance. (Hey, Gearbox, you can have that one for free!)




… there’s really only one thing that you need to know about Borderlands 2. It’s a tough, stylish, emotional ride through everything that made Borderlands such a great game. Pick three friends, span the character classes, and get to killing. You won’t be disappointed.

And just for funsies…



Wall Street Journal

As a $US30 impulse buy, priced about the same as games like “NASCAR Unleashed” I wouldn’t have a problem recommending Borderlands 2 as a fun diversion. At twice that price, though, I think it’s fair for players to demand the whole magilla — cutting-edge development, engrossing campaign gameplay, scads of downloadable content, a rich social media/community experience, sharing of loot and gear and online multiplayer modes that keep you and your friends coming back until the next version of the game comes out.

And Borderlands 2 misses on enough counts so that I not only didn’t joy puke, I didn’t even get a tiny bit of mirthful bile in my throat. It may be the game for you, but if you’re in the market for a new FPS, I’d at least counsel waiting to compare it to Black Ops 2, due out November 13, or Halo 4, which is slated for a November 6 release.


  • Im loving it so far – massive twist in the story has me hooked. Its not as difficult as the original impressions will lead you on to, but damn its a whole lot of fun. I play on PC and the port is excellent. I play on 1440p and it runs without framerate hits at a solid 60 fps. I really cant sing this games praises enough.

    Cant really comment about consoles though

  • Loving it so far, I just came out of Marcus’ Armory (spoiler free guidepost) and the story is a massive driving point behind the game for me. One thing that I really loved is how surprisingly emotional the game manages to make you feel about certain characters. Take Jack for example, he has some rather funny lines and you “want” to like him like you did General Knoxx but everything he does is so incredibly hateful you can’t help but want to punch him in his arrogant face every time you see it. I can’t go on without spoiling it but if you have put in a few hours you will probably know what parts I mean when I imply there are others.
    My biggest gripe is (at least to me) there aren’t enough chests hidden away in tricky to get to locations and knowing that this is the case, my drive to go exploring in places I haven’t gone to is dampened somewhat. I will do it in New Game + but for the time being I find myself only doing sidequests now if they are directly in front of me.

    • I don’t know about that.. I’ve been exploring around and found a bunch of things I might not have found had I not gone off the beaten track. Have my current SMG to thank for that.. and some of the locations of the weapons lockers can be in plain sight but working out how to get to them is the fun part. 🙂 There’s even some easter egg stuff to find within the game too..

  • really enjoying it. Story keeps me there, its not too difficult. I’d recommend it, unless you played the first one and didn’t like it.

  • “It may be the game for you, but if you’re in the market for a new FPS, I’d at least counsel waiting to compare it to Black Ops 2, due out November 13, or Halo 4, which is slated for a November 6 release.”

    Though it isn’t ‘just’ an FPS, It is a RPG as well which offers way more diverse ways to complete the game than CoD(Dislike this game) or Halo(I’m a fan) ever could. He’s comparing Melons to Watermelons, closely named though vastly different.

      • It’s really funny because Jim Sterling managed to bring the joy puke of the internet on to the writer of the review, hell the escapist is in a feeding frenzy over it atm

      • WSJ Video GameReview Methodology 101

        Is the game COD or Halo?
        Is the game exactly the same as COD or Halo?
        Will there be no longer then 5 seconds in between each bout of murder?

        If you answered no to all three then your game is lame and you should light yourself on fire for not making a COD clone.

      • I agree, why is it that when developers combine genres, and it works REALLY well there are still people who think the COD series holds the patent on FPS’s?? Seriously get a little out of the bubble and realise that gaming should not have the same pidgeon holes that alot of the rest of society have.

        Games excel the most when they embrace all the assets available as long as they mesh. Hell i’d love to play a RPG Gundam type game that lets you switch between FPS when you are out of the machine, go 3rd person in the mech and transition to a realtime tactical strategy screen when you launch into space and then go wing commander mode when firefighting in your mech in space. Short version: Stop limiting styles of games to certain genres alone!! 😀

  • Sans the variety of bugs that I have encountered (characters saying the wrong lines or scripted events getting broken) the game is really good.

  • Even though I’m poor, thanks to the guys at Ziip for their extremely cheap prices I was able to pre-order this. For $36.22AUD. I could not be happier, I loved the original BL and this game does not disappoint one bit.

  • I’m also loving it.. I got it for a similar price as Paul from GreenManGaming with coupon etc.

    I’m only around level 13 now, my nephew is already finished the game.. haha.. but I think that while it seems difficult at some stages, it’s not all that hard to play it solo. It’s a very well balanced difficulty and really does feel like there’s a lot more content than the last game was (without DLC). The areas seem a lot larger and have more diversity than the last game. Yes, I know the dev’s said that it was bigger.. but sometimes you don’t really notice it.. but I am definitely noticing it.

    Really liking the story this time around.. the joke is that the first one didn’t have a story.. well it did.. but not like the story in BL:2 is all..

    Anyway, yeh.. really liking it overall.. just wish I had more time to play.

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!