This is an interesting question, but the answer is usually dependent of personal circumstances and personal preferences. Do you have a massive TV? You might want that resolution. Playing with your eyeballs five inches away from the screen? Maybe the frame-rate is more important.
Personally? I'm a frame-rate guy. Games running at 60fps? Swoon. If that game can maintain the frame-rate at a super high resolution, that's also great, but a great, playable experience will always be a priority for me.