Wow, People Are Still Coming Up With Wild Silent Hills Theories

Wow, People Are Still Coming Up With Wild Silent Hills Theories

I want to say that I can’t believe people are still trying to break down P.T. But you know what? I’m not surprised. That’s just how good the teaser is; it’s making people obsessive about every detail.

We’ve heard plenty of good theories about the game before — like the one about aliens, and the one about Jarith. But YouTuber Marszie is going even further with the most detailed, in-depth breakdown of P.T. I’ve ever seen. He talks about the old theories and gives his own thoughts, but he also presents theories I’ve never heard before.

For example: Marszie thinks that perhaps the husband/murderer used to be a photographer. Another theory, a more exciting one: perhaps Lisa and the foetus aren’t the only supernatural forces present in the hallway. Another one, which probably isn’t true but is fun to think about: perhaps the Swedish messages present in the game were an attempt to get the attention of Pewdiepie. The teaser is a marketing gimmick, after all.

Like I said, this breakdown is full of lots of bonkers theories — some more convincing than others, but all rather entertaining. And best of all, there’s also some analysis of Kojima’s choices, many of which helped me understand just why P.T. was so effective.

Basically, if you were a fan of P.T. and are hyped for Silent Hills, you should totally give this a watch:

My favourite assertion here is that, after playing ‘god’ in Metal Gear Solid, Kojima is basically going to ‘play’ as Satan in Silent Hills. Damn.

Worth noting: there’s a third video coming which finishes this analysis. No worries, though. While you wait, there’s still even more for you to chew on, thanks to this theory by Redditor queenquack, which actually dives in to the recent “concept trailer” for P.T.:

I was wondering if anyone else noticed some similarities between PT and the new concept trailer with the anime and manga series “Monster?” Considering Guillermo Del Toro was in talks to produce an American version of Monster with HBO, I don’t think it’s that far off to think some aspects of it could work their way into PT. I caught two possible references, and wanted to see if anyone else had spotted any others.

The first is this, a recurring phrase in Monster about “having a monster inside” oneself. When I saw “Forgive me Lisa, there is a monster inside of me” in PT I immediately went, “Oh hey, it’s that line in Monster!” Then today I watched the concept trailer and noticed these fans, which reminded me a lot of this other recurring image in the series. Spoilers for Monster as to how the two could be related more than just aesthetically: The fan in Monster is very symbolic of a fictional place in the story called Kinderheim 511. This was an orphanage where children were experimented on and brainwashed for years, the goal being to turn them into basically killing machine soldiers that the government could use. Might go along with the sort of hellish school/tortured children theme that the concept trailer seemed to show!

Woah. So many potential connections! Do I think all of these theories are true, necesarily? Naw. But to me, that’s not the point. I’m having lots of fun exploring the ideas anyway.

What about you? Do any of the theories you’ve heard about Silent Hills thus far sound convincing? Have you come up with your own theories? Let us know in the comments.

The Cheapest NBN 1000 Plans

Looking to bump up your internet connection and save a few bucks? Here are the cheapest plans available.

At Kotaku, we independently select and write about stuff we love and think you'll like too. We have affiliate and advertising partnerships, which means we may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. BTW – prices are accurate and items in stock at the time of posting.


4 responses to “Wow, People Are Still Coming Up With Wild Silent Hills Theories”