The Smash Community Is Chaos Right Now

The Smash Community Is Chaos Right Now

The sudden end to Project M‘s development yesterday has turned the Super Smash Bros. community on its head. No one’s quite sure what the next step should be, resulting in a lot of conspiracy theories, yelling, and confusion.

Read my last post to get completely up to speed, but let’s lay out the basics.

Project M was an ongoing effort by a handful of developers to make Super Smash Bros. Brawl for the Wii more like Super Smash Bros. Melee for the GameCube. Tweaks, roster changes, and stage additions occurred over the last six years before the developers, out of nowhere, announced they were calling it quits.

“We realise that this will come as a shock to many of our fans,” wrote the development team on the Project M website yesterday. “Please, forgive us.”

While Nintendo had never publicly condemned Project M, various gestures over the years — such as banning mentions of it on the Miiverse, streams on Twitch — painted the unsurprising picture that Nintendo didn’t really care for Project M.

Still, Project M‘s developers claimed Nintendo had not slapped them with a lawsuit, nor was there a scary cease-and-desist letter telling them to stop.

In the hours since the news broke, however, the picture has gotten…fuzzier.

For one, the official Sonic the Hedgehog account on Twitter weighed on.

Whoever is running that account should get a raise. Anyway!

The Smash community is full of vocal, passionate fans, and Project M ending had plenty of people distressed. It didn’t take long for emotions to impact the team.

These emotions — on both sides — were (are) a mixture of anger and sadness. Specifically, anger and sadness over the notably vague reasons Project M was dead, and questions over why the website had been stripped of download links.

But the big question still lingered: what’s next?

3.6 was the last major revision for Project M, though the development team had actively been working on 3.61. Official patch notes hadn’t been released, though a mixture of details and speculation made the rounds on reddit and elsewhere.

3.61 was never released, but in yesterday’s chaos, it leaked out. An anonymous post on 4chan included the statement “Christmas is early this year” with a link.

Undeterred by the threat of viruses, some folks downloaded whatever the link contained and found an in-development version of 3.61. One of Project M‘s former developers — the team has cycled through people over the years — appeared to knowingly wink at the leak during an AMA (ask me anything).

Though 3.61 wasn’t finished, it inspired others to pick up the mantle. A “newPMDT” subreddit was established to examine 3.61’s problems and begin a new development branch of Project M called Evolution.

(PMDT stands for Project M Development Team.)

The community was mixed on whether this should even happen.

“Playing with fire, bros,” wrote one user. “Be careful.”

“I doubt this will work, the mere mention of new mechanics and physics changes (most importantly) already is gonna have people on edge,” wrote another. “This will just split the community more.”

But only 24 hours later, Evolution already had a logo!

I mean, a logo makes it official, right?

Though Project M was dead, the developers were monitoring the community reaction. When Evolution was announced, it didn’t take them long to condemn it.

“Last night and earlier today we saw a community in pain,” wrote one developer, Strong Bad. “A lot of pain. The situation is far from ideal.”

Though the leaked files made them uncomfortable, it stood as a testament to the community’s dedication to Smash and Project M, so they understood. That said, picking up where Project M left off was something they couldn’t ignore.

“As you know we haven’t been contacted, issued a C&D, threatened or had legal action taken against us in any way, and we want it to stay that way,” said Strong Bad. “Even with our own development halted any continuation of the project by new developers could jeopardize that good standing not only for ourselves, but for them as well, and we don’t want that for either party.”

Strong Bad “urged” the community to stick with 3.6 and “condemned” projects like Evolution. For me, the vague statement “could jeopardize that good standing not only for ourselves, but for them as well” is where I started to get curious.

Project M‘s developers claim everything was kosher when they decided to move on. After six years, no one could blame them for wanting to pursue new things.

But is there something else going on? It’s unclear, but here’s what we know.

Mewtwo2000, a former developer on Project M, posted a message to Facebook, focusing both on the passion of the Project M team….and their legal troubles.

“The truth is that it has not been a responsive action, but a preventive one. Certain event (which, again, doesn’t involve a company contacting the PMDT) made the members fear a legal problem if the project kept on. At some point, it was determined that, even just the fact of releasing the announced patch, PM 3.61, could involve negative actions that nobody in the team could afford at all. A lawyer was contacted and it was confirmed that the possible threats the PMDT could face in an hypothetical legal sue were really terrible. As the PMDT was formed mostly by teenagers, people with little money or even in red numbers, and with a long life to run, it was determined that it was better for their safety to stop immediately just in case. It’s been a hard decission that had to be made public as soon as possible. And even in this case, nobody guarantees that there will be no legal actions taken in the future because copyrighted content has been distributed already.”

That lawyer is Ryan Morrison, an attorney focused on games. Morrison told me that “nothing currently ongoing has been shared with him [Mewtwo2000].”

While Morrison reaffirmed no active legal action had been taken, he confirmed something was happening behind-the-scenes, though he wouldn’t get specific.

“This wasn’t a malicious decision made by an angry dev team,” said Morrison. “This is a group of students and young adults who have put a lot of hard work and passion into something, and who had their hands forced into preventive measures by some changes in the scenery. Unfortunately, in the immediate future, I can’t speak further on what those changes are.”

Morrison said there wasn’t a gag order in place. Whatever the Project M development team wouldn’t say publicly, it’s their choice not to speak about it.

Last night, reddit user throwingthisaccsoon posted to the Project M subreddit with “Story of what happened to Project M“, containing a story from “another forum” with hefty allegations. Within minutes, the thread was gone.

It’s hard to permanently hide things on the Internet, though, and the story was allegedly captured before it disappeared, allowing it to be shared in other places.

Since I didn’t see the post before it deleted, I can’t 100 per cent verity its authenticity. The whole image is right here, but below is the relevant except, in regards to the supposed legal troubles that Project M was encountering before it went dark:

It goes on and on, but the basic gist is that Project M allegedly got wind that Nintendo was fed up, and the next time Project M was updated, the hammer was coming down. To avoid drowning in a big time lawsuit, Project M was shut down.

Fuelling the fire is Project M’s own lawyer admitting to me that the development team had their “hands forced” due to “changes in the scenery”. Hmm.

Nonetheless, their lawyer pushed back on the reddit post.

“Between Twitter and Reddit I’ve seen more theories and conspiracy stories the past 48 hours than I can even comprehend,” said Morrison. “All I can say is that we have received no credible threat, communication, take-down notice, etc. from anyone.”

Whatever’s happening was enough to get the Project M spin-off, Evolution, to shift tactics. When I asked for an interview, they agreed…before backing out.

“We’re gonna start working behind the scenes to avoid the Big N,” said Evolution’s co-founder, TheWizard34. “We’ve been warned of legal trouble.”

There’s something going on, but whether we’ll ever find out? Who knows.


  • The Smash Community Is Chaos Right Now

    This is a bit of an exaggeration. It’s only the PM community that is affected by this, which is only a relatively small percentage really of the overall Smash community…and even “chaos” is probably overdoing it.

    There’s certainly a lot of disappointment from the PM community and there might be more to the cease in development than meets the eye, but the headline is really misleading regardless.

    Ultimately though, this was a mod that was not sanctioned by the original IP holders nor any third parties that were involved, development was going to be shut down eventually one way or another. I’m honestly surprised it lasted 6 years.

  • I’m thinking that with stuff still being added to Smash4, and the fact that so many of the PM community so vocally express the superiority of PM (i.e. they have no plans to actually support the actual IP holders), it is no surprise that (from what I read) a lawyer with video game IP experience told them that they could be facing a C&D hammer on next release.

    Not only that, but all the various “Project M is better than any Nintendo made smash” types of posts could possibly be used as evidence of actual financial damage to Nintendo (because people get Project M rather than buying products from the IP holder)

  • We’re looking at some (potential) legal troubles (by affiliation with PMDT), so we’re canning everything having to do with the PMDT (and going by another name).
    Yes, continuing the project under a different name will totes get rid of those pesky legal problems…

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!