Civil War II Is Finally Over, And We All Lost

Civil War II Is Finally Over, And We All Lost

Mere days before 2016 comes to a close, Marvel’s “winter” event series Civil War II has released its last issue. But Civil War II wasn’t going to go down without at least adding a few more twists to the future of the Marvel Universe… and oh boy, did it add some.

Not a lot actually happens in Civil War II #8 — by Brian Michael Bendis, David Marquez, Clayton Cowles and Justin Ponsor, with guest art from Esad Ribic, Adam Kubert, Leinel Francis Yu, Daniel Acuna, Alan Davies, Mark Farmer, Marco Rudy, Mark Bagley and John Dell — that we didn’t already expect going in. Although the last issue’s burgeoning scrap between Captain Marvel and Iron Man wasn’t quite what we thought it was, it might as well have been, given that the scrap doesn’t last much longer before Carol takes out Tony, in front of heroes and TV cameras alike:

So Tony Stark is dead. For now. Sort of. We’ll get to that after seeing the final issue’s other wrap-up point: The “death” of Ulysses, the future-predicting Inhuman who kicked the whole event off (who could obviously never stay around permanently in the Marvel universe given his powers). Basically, he evolves into a higher consciousness, taking his place alongside the legendary cosmic character Eternity as part of the fabric of existence himself.

Ulysses “died” as he lived, sort of pointlessly but while also serving up as a conveniently teaser-y plot point for Marvel to evoke “potential futures” (each, rather neatly, drawn by a different artist) for the comics universe. Those came in the form of nebulous visions or, in some cases, straight up teases for actual upcoming comics events like Monsters Unleashed

…or Inhumans vs X-Men.

The more nebulous visions are by far the most interesting — with one hinting that the potential fatal brawl between Miles Morales and Steve Rogers could still happen, another teasing the return of Ultron and a third offering a future where it appears Odinson has regained the use of Mjolnir and is once again Thor. But, like basically anything Ulysses actually did in Civil War II, they’re lacking in any sort of substance or context for us as readers to care about them. Ulysses hasn’t really done anything other than serve as a catalyst for Tony and Carol to have an ill-conceived argument, and now he’s just up and vanished off into the cosmic ether.

So what remains? Well, Civil War II #8 has one more “trick” up its sleeve to reveal with the fate of Tony Stark, now that Ulysses is conveniently out of the way. For the past few months, we’ve been told that Tony Stark is dead — or at least that while his mind lives on as an AI, his body is gone for good. But Civil War II #8 shows us that that is very much not the case.

Whatever process Tony did to turn his consciousness into an AI — one now in the hands of his successor, Riri Williams — also involved doing something to his body that essentially leaves him in a coma, under the watchful eye of Hank McCoy and SHIELD. They’re currently too scared to do anything but keep the barely-still-alive Tony in stasis, but it means that Civil War II‘s biggest twist isn’t actually that big at all.

It’s the latest in a long line of conveniently cheap comic book “deaths” that treat the afterlife as little more as a revolving door. It’s a “gotcha!” moment that leaves you more annoyed than intrigued, because we already know what it means for the future of Marvel’s comics: Tony Stark will be able to come back as Iron Man pretty much whenever it suits Marvel — maybe, perhaps, just in time for a certain upcoming Avengers movie. It casts a shadow over everything Riri Williams is currently doing in Invincible Iron Man, because the spectre of “break glass to revive Tony Stark” hangs over that series in the context we have now.

For a series that has been about looking at potential futures, in the end Civil War II relied on the worst tricks of the past — both in terms of its predecessor, the original Civil War, and the superhero comics’ ever-lengthening history of “killing off” characters for cheap thrills.

In the final battle between Carol Danvers and Tony Stark, the real loser was the audience.


  • Should have just killed every male in the marvel Universe and replace them with renamed females…. oh wait.

    • There was an interesting idea presented by Comics Explained that maybe this whole thing would have gone down a lot better if the transition was organic like a lot of past attempts have been and spread out; rather than a targeted cluster fuck over the course of 16 months.

      • That’s pretty much the point… a lot of the new hand overs were rushed rubbish dropped in the middle of nowhere.

        Only Komala and Mile’s hand overs (heck I’ll even take Cap no.2 Falcon as well =P) are what I consider a great hand-over/transition. They all built themselves up before the main title holder passed the torch or name on to a degree…

        • Worse yet they passed over natural progression (Rhodes died for a quota) and decided that when their hardcore fan base were slowing down purchases that they would instead double down and created the situation we have now where DC could be running much weaker titles (though I am glad that Rebirth is looking to a new “golden era”) and would still likely be in a better position than Marvel.

          A quick look at sales shows that Marvel’s best selling titles are the ones that feel right; not from a political position, but from a writing one. There are of course a couple of titles that are bucking this trend, but history tells us that this is likely due to Marvel’s hard on for renumbering as most are #1’s.

          I am very interested to see how Unworthy, Mighty and Logan do (the latter is in serious need of some love, Lemire is ridiculously under appreciated).

    • So after two* recent gender-swaps of a hero mantle (Thor and Iron Man) you are ready to declare a fem-pocalypse? Among hundreds of male Marvel characters?

      *(Three if you count Spider-Gwen but she’s alternate universe so not actually taking over Spider-Man’s mantle.)

  • Over all it was a dirt tier event, made Convergence look like the second coming of some dude that was apparently crucified for your bloody sins and that takes a lot of work to do.

  • Only death I’ve cared about is Cyclops, which if (hopefully when) they bring him back they will make him like his old rational, inspiring self again.

  • Not a lot actually happens in Civil War II #8 — by Brian Michael Bendis, David Marquez, Clayton Cowles and Justin Ponsor, with guest art from Esad Ribic, Adam Kubert, Leinel Francis Yu, Daniel Acuna, Alan Davies, Mark Farmer, Marco Rudy, Mark Bagley and John Dell — that we didn’t already expect going in.

    That’s quite the mouthful.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!