The Year In Controversy

Studios may close, servers may crash, projects may be canceled and bankruptcies filed, but these are the given in the video games industry. No matter how regrettable, they still won't be the No. 1 heated controversies in any given year for video games.

Here's a look back at the scandals, outrages, foofaraws and kerfuffles that made the past year in games both unlike any other and yet still, somehow, completely typical of the culture we celebrate when it's all said and done.

The Year in Controversy

Dorito-gate

Dorito-gate involves a gaming show host doing interviews while seated between bags of Doritos and bottles of Mountain Dew; a column about journalists making promotional Tweets to win a free console; an apparent legal threat tied to that column; the columnist quitting over the removal of a quote, and from there, an avalanche of complaints and suspicion about the coziness of the gaming press with the public relations wing of the companies whose games they cover. More »

The Year in Controversy

Anita Sarkeesian, and "Tropes vs. Women in Video Games"

Anita Sarkeesian wanted to make a web series about how women are portrayed in video games. She asked the world for $US6,000. Some of the people who thought that was interesting and worth doing have given her just shy of $US159,000.

Some of the people who thought it was not worth doing, have defaced her Wikipedia page, written vile things to her on YouTube and ... well, that's what she already told us about in mid-June. But, wait, there's more. More »

The Year in Controversy

Mass Effect 3's Ending

We should have known the conclusion would be trouble. Ending a game like Mass Effect 3 poses a special set of problems, because a central attraction of Western RPGs is that their systems respond to player choice. Mass Effect and its like are the classic case of games that generate stories through collaboration between designer and player. Drawing things to a close, however, requires the hand of the developer to show, often in ways that seem unattractive. More »

The Year in Controversy

The War Z

After its December release, fans came out criticising this zombie survival game for misleading advertising, suspicious microtransactions, and forum censorship. Steam removed the game from its marketplace and opened an investigation into the bannings. In the end, it's hardly a surprise The War Z's creator was the lead programmer on Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing, commonly regarded as one of the worst video games of all time.More »

The Year in Controversy

Hitman and the Sexy Nuns

The director of upcoming stealth game Hitman: Absolution says the team didn't mean to cause controversy with their most recent trailer, which features protagonist Agent 47 slaughtering his way through a squad of scantily-dressed nuns. In fact, he says the ensuing Internet firestorm caught them all off-guard. More »

The Year in Controversy

Oliver North Sold Weapons to Iran, Now Sells Call of Duty

Call of Duty, has spent four years solidifying its image as a crass chickenhawk brand thanks to some particularly dumb marketing initiatives. But hiring Lt. Col. Oliver North as a spokesman for Black Ops II represents a new low. More »

The Year in Controversy

PAX East's "No Booth Babe" Policy Sanctions Bigtime Cosplayer

Jessica Nigri, hired by Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment to portray the protagonist in Lollipop Chainsaw at PAX East, was asked by expo staff to either dress more modestly or keep her movements out of sight of the young kids touring the show floor. It was the first visible test of PAX's "No Booth Babe" policy, developed in consultation with the Penny Arcade community. More »

The Year in Controversy

Fez's Creator Says Japanese Games 'Just Suck'

Phil Fish, the creator of indie hit Fez is known for being Phil Fish. During a Q&A session, a Japanese game developer noted that so many indie games seemed inspired by old Japanese games and asked Fish for an opinion on the country's modern games. According to website Develop, Fish replied, "Your games just suck". More »

The Year in Controversy

Tomb Raider, Lara Croft, and Attempted Rape

At E3, the executive producer of Tomb Raider said Lara Croft's assailants "try to rape her" in one scene, a remark the studio's head later disowned in followup comments to Kotaku. "Sexual assault of any kind is categorically not a theme that we cover in this game," he said. That seemed only to be a starting point for the blowback, not its end. More »

The Year in Controversy

Metacritic Refuses To Pull Negative Review That GameSpot Admits Was Factually Inaccurate

In November, GameSpot pulled a review of Natural Selection 2, citing "several inaccuracies" and apologizing to readers. The review, scored 60/100 and written by a freelancer named Eric Neigher, had been eviscerated by readers and commenters who pointed out a number of mistakes GameSpot ran a re-review by a new writer, who scored the game an 80. But the original review is still on Metacritic. More »

The Year in Controversy

Competitive Gamer's Inflammatory Comments Spark Sexual Harassment Debate

During a promotional TV series for the fighting games Street Fighter and Tekken, competitive fighting gamer Aris Bakhtanians made remarks that said sexism was integral to the culture of the fighting games community, and later asked "What is unacceptable?" about shouting things like "Rape that bitch!" at a match. More »

The Year in Controversy

Medal of Honor's Official Site Links, then Doesn't Link, to Firearms Manufacturers

Back in August, Electronic Arts removed links to gun manufacturers' websites from its Medal of Honor website, where they had been listed in a distasteful promotion for Project Honor, a charity supporting Special Operations veterans and their families. The company also ended a promotion for a special $US75 "tomahawk" knife that featured "an extended cutting head." More »


Comments

    only 2-3 of those should have been controversial the rest are really fucking stupid

      Couldn't agree more - obviously the nuns & booth babes are controversial - the rest are just ridiculous.

    The whole controversy around Anita Sarkeesian is that people saw through the well made video and had a feeling she wouldn't commit to her project...

    6 months after funding ended and we haven't seen a single video. All she has done is fly around places and dwell on the harassment she got from the big bad 4Chan trolls.

    Not sure if deliberate or unfortunate pink arrow placement.

    Anyway, what's not controversial about the others? ME 3 caused a mighty crapstorm, rightly or wrongly, and I don't think anyone came out of that smelling of roses. Dorito-gate follows on the heels of a period when games journalism was being seriously questioned, especially with regards to how cosy it was with the publishers of games. Intolerable language towards female gamers is surely a controversial issue, especially with the infamy of Xbox multiplayer games. There's being a douchenozzle, and then there's being the dirt at the bottom of a boot. Male gamers don't have the best of reputations to begin with, so perhaps it is time to have a look at attitudes. I play a bit of multiplayer, but mainly what puts me off it is the pure asshattery of people on the internet, they may be few in number, but one rotten apple is enough to spoil the whole bunch, as they say.

    So either people have a very narrow definition of controversy, or simply refuse to see anything merely tangentially related to games mentioned here.

    And not a mention of the ARMA 3 alleged espionage arrests

    "or keep her movements out of sight of the young kids touring the show floor" That is so sad and pathetic... it's basically demeaning her as a grown adult woman; childish, extremest, puritanical views painting her as immoral or disgusting just because her costume could be construed as "sexy". She wasn't performing as a stripper or a prostitute (not that there's anything wrong with those either) but she was treated like she was. Thank goodness such backwards attitudes aren't prevalent all over the USA.

    It's funny how things connect differently depending on your POV. The biggest connection in this list to me is the ME3 ending and Dorito-gate controversies. The way in which gaming journos - even those for this very site (exhibit A, your honours: http://www.kotaku.com.au/2012/03/charitable-donations-dont-give-you-the-right-to-demand-changes-to-mass-effect-3/) - uniformly leapt to the defence of EA and BIoware (and consequently - though perhaps not coincidentally - the journos own glowing reviews) with all the "entitled"-based criticisms of disgruntled fans was very disquieting. When the media sides with businesses against consumers, it isn't usually a good sign.

    the "the year 2012 that was" arrow is not doing Jessica Nigri any favors in that pic above 0_0

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now