One Year Later, Did Nintendo Keep Its E3 2014 Promises?

One Year Later, Did Nintendo Keep Its E3 2014 Promises?
To sign up for our daily newsletter covering the latest news, features and reviews, head HERE. For a running feed of all our stories, follow us on Twitter HERE. Or you can bookmark the Kotaku Australia homepage to visit whenever you need a news fix.

Nintendo’s digital event at E3 was one of the best “press conferences” in history, not because it was full of particularly great announcements but because it was short, sweet and bullshit-free, setting an example for what an E3 event should be.

Since it was a pre-recorded 45-minute show with lots of gameplay trailers and very few executive speeches, Nintendo’s 2014 digital presentation was almost entirely spot on. They stuck to nearly every claim they made, as we discovered while looking back at last year’s showcase as part of our annual series to check whether the big first-party publishers lived up to their promises. (You can see how Microsoft did right here. Sony’s coming later this week.)

Let’s break it down.

The promise: Nintendo’s digital showcase opened with a fun fake brawl between Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata and Nintendo of America president Reggie Fils-Aime. It was a tie, so they just decided to play Smash Bros. Wii U instead — where they revealed Mii versions of themselves. “By using a Mii Fighter, anyone can join the battle,” said Smash creator Masahiro Sakurai in a segment afterwards.

Did they deliver? Sure did. Mii Fighters are in both versions of the newest Smash.

The promise: Three varieties of Mii Fighters would be en route: Mii Brawler, Mii Swordfigher, and Mii Gunner. Each one would have 12 different special moves, for a total of 36.

Did they deliver? Yes on all counts.

The promise: Smash 3DS will have various modes: Smash Run, albums, trophies, etc.

Did they deliver? Yep.

The promise: Smash 3DS gets a delay from “summer 2014” to October 3, 2014; Smash Wii U is now slated for holiday 2014.

Did they deliver? Yes. Smash Wii U made it to North America on November 21, 2014.

The promise: During the Smash talk, Fils-Aime introduced what would soon become one of Nintendo’s most controversial products: amiibo. “Only on Nintendo systems will you be able to enjoy all the different experiences in this toys-to-life category,” he said, going on to explain how amiibo figures will store and transfer data. Super Smash Bros. for Wii U will be the first game to support amiibo, Fils-Aime said.

Did they deliver? Yes. The first wave of amiibo started shipping on November 21, 2014, alongside Smash Wii U. Sadly, customers would go on to run into all sorts of supply and communication issues, but that’s a whole ‘nother story…

The promise: “Along with amiibo, both Disney Infinity and Skylanders Trap Team have unique features and functionality that can only be found on Wii U.”

Did they deliver? Doesn’t seem like it? Neither of those games used amiibos or had any special features, unless you’re counting regular Wii U GamePad stuff like off-TV play.

The promise: Other games, like Mario Kart 8, will also support amiibo.

Did they deliver? Yep. There’s also amiibo support in Hyrule Warriors, Mario Party 10, and a handful of other Nintendo games.

The promise: “There’s nothing wrong with having a little fun,” Fils-Aime added.

Did they deliver? Yes. It is correct that there is nothing wrong with having a little fun.

The promise: Right after Fils-Aime’s segment, the video presentation cut to the developers of Yoshi’s Woolly World, who talked about yarn and showed some gameplay. (It’s pretty much Yoshi’s Island with fantastic animation.) They said it’d be coming in 2015.

Did they deliver? TBD. The game’s now slated for this fall in North America.

The promise: Nintendo then announced Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker with a gameplay trailer that called back to the mini-games in Super Mario 3D World. They said it’d be out “holiday 2014.”

Did they deliver? Yes. Toad’s adorable adventures were available in the US on December 5, 2014.

The promise: Halfway through Nintendo’s presentation, Zelda producer Eiji Aonuma came out to show off their big new Zelda for the Wii U, which he described as an open-world game in the style of the original NES game. He showed a brief, gorgeous trailer depicting Link on horseback shooting bows at a monster, which Nintendo would later say was all in-engine footage. The end of the segment declared that this new Zelda would be out in 2015.

Did they deliver? Not quite. We already know the game isn’t coming out in 2015, and Nintendo has said it won’t be at this year’s E3 either, so we might not see Zelda Wii U for quite some time.

The promise: Next up was a live-action trailer for Pokémon Omega Ruby and Pokémon Alpha Sapphire, scheduled to be out November 21, 2014.

Did they deliver? Yes. Both games came out then.

The promise: We saw a cool new trailer for the surprise Wii U exclusive Bayonetta 2, which had already been announced a couple years back. The news this time: every copy would come with a newly-developed Wii U port of the original Bayonetta. “October 2014” was the promised release window.

Did they deliver? Sure did. Bayonetta 2 came out on October 24, 2014, and alongside it was a port of the first game.

The promise: Nintendo showed off the Zelda spinoff Hyrule Warriors, which they said would be out September 26, 2014.

Did they deliver? Yes.

The promise: More Kirby! Nintendo announced Kirby and the Rainbow Curse, a sequel to Canvas Curse, to be released in 2015.

Did they deliver? Yep. Kirby and the Rainbow Curse came out in February of 2015.

The promise: JRPG fans would finally have something to look forward to on the Wii U with the newly-retitled Xenoblade Chronicles X, now delayed to 2015.

Did they deliver? TBD. The new Xenoblade is already out in Japan, but we haven’t seen it here yet.

The promise: Three decades after Mario first popped out of a pipe and into the world, Nintendo would finally release an official stage creator called Mario Maker. The concept: anyone can put together their own Mario stages thanks to the Wii U’s tablet controller. After a brief trailer, Nintendo said it’d be out in 2015.

Did they deliver? TBD. We’ll likely see more of Mario Maker — currently slated for September — next week at E3.

The promise: Something brand new! Nintendo announced Splatoon, an inky shooter that would let players transform between squid and kid while squirting coloured paint everywhere. They said the game would be available in 2015.

Did they deliver? Sure did. Though the interface in the final game looks a little different, Splatoon came out last month for Wii U.

The promise: “Right after we sign off, we invite you to stay tuned on Nintendo’s Twitch channel for our post-show recap,” Fils-Aime said.

Did they deliver? Yes! Nintendo successfully recapped their show.

The promise: Fils-Aime added that Nintendo had even more game news coming that “we didn’t have time to squeeze into this video.”

Did they deliver? True. Later during E3, the publisher held a special evening roundtable to announce the strategy game Code Name: STEAM.

The promise: Palutena joins the cast of Smash Bros.; Dark Pit is hinted in the new trailer, too.

Did they deliver? Yep. Both characters wound up in the new Smash.

The promise: Finally, to close off the video, Nintendo’s Shigeru Miyamoto made some brief comments about how he’s working on some brand new experiences for Wii U that can be appealing both to people playing and to observers watching.

Did they deliver? Sorta? After the press conference, news came out that Miyamoto had brought a handful of demos to E3. These demos would eventually be turned into a new Star Fox game, Nintendo promised, although we haven’t seen anything about it since then.


  • Mostly delivered, although I think to a lot of Americans at least the amiibo delivery was more of a troll than a fulfillment of a promise 🙂

    • Agreed, especially for the gamers who own a console to play games and not waste their money on little plastic toys!

      Damn you Nintendo! Damn you for turning all of your games into Nintendo branded skylanders!!

      • You don’t have to buy them. They are mostly cosmetic unlocks. I certainly like having a couple of physical little trophies.

    • er.. half of the promises were token 🙁
      perhaps a promise of better promises this year?

      • Yes, it has been a pretty lean year all ’round for Nintendo. Wii U is on an intravenous drip with 3rd parties few and far between, 3DS is still doing quite well, although for Western audiences the focus has always been less on hand-held and more on home console experiences. Interesting to see what Nintendo promises for the coming year!

  • So Zelda for Wii U has gone from being released in 2015 to not even being at E3 in 2015?

    You’ve got to wonder if that’s been quietly turned into a launch title for the NX or whatever it ends up being called?

    • That’s where my money is. I don’t expect there to be much in the way of significant Wii U announcements this year.

      • The WiiU is dead and Nintendo knows it, it got ONE genuine AAA game from Nintendo since E3 last year in Smash Bros.
        Outside of that it got spinoffs and short games rushed out to fill holes in their release schedule (Toad, Splatoon, Mario Minigame Collection 438).

        I said at E3 last year that Nintendo would never be able to get Zelda finished to a respectable standard within a year (given that every console Zelda ever has been delayed significantly) and would ultimately have to choose between releasing a sub-par product (by Nintendo standards) to keep the WiiU on life support or pushing the game back and relegating the WiiU to being an abysmal failure.

        It looks like they’ve taken the second option, which in my view is the right one.
        While I’ve got no faith in them whatsoever when it comes to the NX, if it has a brand new, next-gen standard Zelda at launch them i’ll be giving them whatever they’re asking for it.

        • I really want Yoshi’s Woolly World, but I’m thinking I might wait and see how the NX turns out and count on it having backwards compatibility with Wii U. Although that might not be the case if they decide to ditch the touchscreen controller…

          • If they’ve got any Braaaains at all then the WiiU tablet thing is history.

            It’s not entirely useless, but it’s a lead weight on the pricing of the system and its benefits are limited.

            The obvious way to do backwards compatibility would be to allow the new console to use a WiiU controller in the same way that the WiiU can use the assortment of sh*tty controllers the Wii had, but honestly I’d prefer Nintendo just dropped the whole thing and released the NX with one standard, gaming focused controller.

            The best games on the WiiU are Mario Kart, Smash Bros and Wind Waker and those games are two iterations in a running series (ie. Mario Kart NX and Smash Bros NX should be the same but better) and a remake anyway. I don’t think people will be dying to replay those titles on the next console.

            It’ll suck if games like Wooly World turn out to be great and essentially never get played by anyone, but is it REALLY worth tacking additional functions onto a new console for the extremely small number of WiiU titles that people will want to play?

            They should focus on BC for the games that use traditional controllers (back when Nintendo made good games) and draw a line through the piles of sh*t they’ve released post Gamecube. The two Mario Galaxy games and possibly Skyward Sword are the only games Nintendo released in the past 10 years that I’d be in any way sad if I never could play them on a future console.

          • The way you talk it’s almost as though as you were purposefuly ignoring that Splatoon is a thing and that it’s basically been the most talked about videogame these days after Bloodborne.

          • I’m not ignoring Splatoon, but there’s no shortage of reviews out there criticising it for being polished but minimalist on content.
            You don’t buy a Nintendo console because you expect to be kept entertained consistently anymore, it’s not like an Xbone of PS4 where you get a major release every 2 months at least, you buy it because you want to play a handful of 1st party gems.

            I know it’s the worlds laziest measuring stick, but Splatoon has a metacritic score of 81. The biggest criticism being that compared to other titles on the market there’s very little to it. It’s polished, it’s fun, but it’s not long enough to be a full-blown AAA release. Nintendo could have made it a classic but it was pumped out to fill a massive hole in the WiiU’s release schedule.

            Captain Toad? Same metacritic score, same criticism, same reasoning. Lazy game which was greenlighted from the start to be a project that could be pumped out relatively quickly to fill a space. Nintendo has had its priorities ass-backwards since they rushed the WiiU out before the other consoles but did so with no games. Since then they’ve prioritised getting games out the door over innovation and content.

            Don’t you think it’d be nice if Nintendo could say “we’re working on a new Zelda/Mario/Metroid, but it’ll be out when it’s done” and then spend 5-7 years on it the way teams like CD Projekt do with the Witcher, instead of designing their titles from the ground up with the release date and hardware sales in mind?
            If they make a Mario Kart that’s in HD they can get it out the door in one year, they can do HD Smash Bros in the next. If they borrow the design blueprint from the 3DS Mario it can be out 6 months later. A 2D sidescroller Mario can be made quickly too…..

  • That fight between Nintendo CEO Satoru Iwata and Nintendo of America president Reggie Fils-Aime was amazing

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!