Xbox One X Is Impressive, But Doesn't Seem Essential

Minecraft running the "Super Duper Graphics Pack" which isn't just for Xbox One X, but which will look great on it.

You have to listen very, very closely to figure it out if you need or even want Microsoft's powerful new console. I did so yesterday during a private demo of the Xbox One X. While the Xbox One X seems cool, it also feels very much optional, though that is arguably a good thing.

On stage during their public press conference, Microsoft executives and designers rattled off spectacular stats that secure this upgraded Xbox One the status of "most powerful console ever." In their private demo, they tried to showcase how that power is relevant to games.

Microsoft's entire E3 presence is one big sales pitch. Today, in a tent set up in L.A.'s Galen Center, they are cycling hundreds of Xbox-curious gamers through, one group at a time, leading them all through a dazzling presentation of the new unit. I got a private version of the same run-through, which was a little awkward, but also very helpful to get a sense of what they're doing. Executives from Xbox gave an overview and then game developers who help make Forza 7, Minecraft and Gears of War 4 talked about cool stuff happening with their games. As was the case with the PS4 Pro before it, things quickly got confusing: some of the improvements Xbox One X offers only matter if you have a 4K TV and some don't. Some of what Microsoft showed, for Minecraft in particular, doesn't even appear to require an Xbox One X.

The PS4 Pro Will Help Launch A New, More Complicated Era Of Console Gaming

Sony's new, more powerful console, the PS4 Pro, has been designed to improve the graphics of new and old PS4 games. But conversations with developers at the PS4 Pro's reveal event in New York City on Wednesday made it clear that it will also make console gaming more complex, introducing greater variation in a game's graphics from one model of PS4 to the next and among a range of TVs. The Pro will sometimes even offer improved performance in framerate for those with lesser TVs.

Read more

Before you enter the demo, you pass an Xbox One X that is sitting on a podium next to an Xbox One S. That alone may be confusing to folks who file past, not just because the names sound so similar when you say them out loud, but because the sleek white S draws the eye away from the slightly smaller, black X.

Both consoles have regular Xbox One controllers sitting on them. I'd later confirm that not only is Xbox One X compatible with existing Xbox One controllers (makes sense, since it also is compatible with every Xbox One game), but they're not pushing a new controller: "Same controller," chief of Xbox marketing Albert Penello said.

Stand-off: Xbox One S vs Xbox One X

When groups of gamers file into the tent today, they will be able to sit in rows of chairs. Yesterday I found myself alone in the room, able to sit anywhere I wanted.. If I sat in the front I'd have the best view of the 4K TV that they were using to show this stuff off. If I sat in the middle, though, I'd get the best surround sound, which was tempting because the Xbox folks said they had set the room up for really advanced Dolby Atmos surround sound. But I would have felt weird sitting in the middle of a sea of empty chairs, you know? I took a seat in the front row.

Even in the front, I'd soon hear Atmos-enabled sound effects whizzing all around me. The beat of a helicopter's blades encircled the room. Streaking missiles seemingly flew over my head as they blew up targets in Gears of War 4. All of this sounded really great, as did Xbox One product manager Ryan Moore's comment to me that you can get these Atmos effects using special headphones, if you're not likely to wire your room for this advanced surround sound. Cool. Maybe a reason to get Xbox One X? Not so fast.

Now's a good time to check the Xbox One S and Xbox One X comparative fact-sheet Microsoft would later send me.

Compare and contrast the Xbox One X and Xbox One S features, as listed by Microsoft. Both units play all of the same games, of course.

Xbox One S also does Atmos. Cool, but hmmm. Moore did say that when we were talking, but given our meeting's focus on the Xbox One X, it was easy to assume it was an exclusive feature.This is what I mean about listening carefully.

The big X vs. S differentiator isn't Atmos audio. It's visuals, though not HDR lighting, which looks great but is also something that both the S and X can do. No, the differentiator is 4K resolution, a bit of tech jargon that is currently dominating Microsoft's marketing message.

"We're all about 4K, as you know," Microsoft's Moore said near the kickoff of my demo. He pointed out that Xbox One S supports 4K streaming and Blu-Ray, but the X is the machine for doing 4K gaming. He pulled up a still shot of the eight million pixels that can fit in a 4K image, compared to the two million pixels you can see on an HD TV running a game in 1080p. Yep, it was definitely four times as many pixels. Xbox One X will do "supersampling" for people who connect the machine to a non-4K TV, which they say will crunch those eight million pixels into something that will still look better than 1080p.

When Moore wrapped, he ceded the stage to Cameron Egbert, the rendering lead on the Microsoft-owned Minecraft. "We're going to show you a few of the new features that the power of Xbox One X has allowed us to build into the game," Egbert said in a statement that would momentarily confuse me as I watched his impressive demo

What followed was a really neat fly-through of the "Super Duper Graphics Pack" coming to Minecraft. Egbert and his colleague, art director Brad Schubert, showed off specular map effects that allow light to make blocks in the game shiny and react differently as you move past them. "Our rails are no longer flat," Schubert said, as the camera panned over what are now three dimensional railroad track panels in the game. "They are a great example of what we can now do with additional 3D geometry," he said. They're going to let more blocks give off light, are putting subtle highlighting on blocks, doing more with directional lighting, directional shadows on the terrain and mobs. And he said they're "working on animated foliage" and improved water tech.

The Minecraft men showed a comparison shot of the game running on Xbox One X and what I believe was Xbox One S to demonstrate how the X lets them render more of the game in the distance. That improved draw distance is a solid, undeniable win for the X, and by the end of the short demo, they were talking about how the graphics pack "is coming this fall to the Xbox One X."

Here's the catch: the Super Duper Graphics pack is also coming to lots of other platforms, including Xbox One S, PC and Switch, even mobile (unclear if/when it's coming to PS4), basically everything that will be running the game on the new Bedrock Engine. "It will be anywhere that you can play Minecraft in the new version," Egbert said.

"It will improve any screen on which you play, but the best experience will be on Xbox One X." This is the theme: what you can play on Xbox One X is playable elsewhere, but, short of a high-end PC, it will simply look best on the X.

The Coalition's Colin Penty played through part of Gears of War 4 using the Xbox One X enhancement patch, which is coming to the game for free in the fall. Pente said the patch will let the game run in 4K resolution. The Xbox One X version will also get visual upgrades including real-time dynamic shadows and "up-rezzed textures for environments, characters and effects" and improved draw distance, among other things. The patch does not affect the framerate. Running in 4K, though, the game looked spectacular.

Tucker Kelly, who helps market Forza Motorsport 7, played a race in that game, emphasising the 4K, 60fps graphics of the game as it ran on the X (though he pointed out that Forza tech runs at 60fps on Xbox One S, too). As he sped his car through a course in Dubai, he drew my attention to the reflection of the clouds on the body of his car, the high resolution rendering of other cars and the impressiveness of the rocks on the periphery of the course. He pointed out the vibration of the windshield wipers while in cockpit view. How much of this can only be seen on the X is unclear, though it was undeniable that in 4K this game, like Gears, looked terrific.

The showcase took about 20 minutes, and then I got to pepper Penello, the Xbox marketing boss, with questions.

  • Power brick? No. It uses an internal power supply, Penello said, and connects with the same power cable that plugs into the Xbox One S.
  • VR support? "We think PC is the right place to be playing with VR right now."
  • Multiple copies of games, one for S and one for X? No. Xbox One games are one disc on store shelves, though if the game as enhancements for the Xbox One X, a label will indicate that. I pointed out that Bethesda's Prey has a PS4 enhancement label even though it didn't initially seem to be enhanced for the Pro. Penello: "We have a very high standard for getting that and the developer has to have gone and demoed it before they get the logo."
  • Don't the phrases "Xbox One S" and "Xbox One X" sound too similar? Have you said it out loud enough times to be sure? Penello: Yeah, we've said it out loud…." Moore, laughing: "It's too late now." Penello: "Look, I think people are going to know when you go into the store, the packaging, the ID, the power, the price, they're going to know which one they're after."
  • For people (such as me) who have 1080p TVs, will the Xbox One X recognise our displays and divert power from 4K rendering to other stuff? Penello's simple answer on that boiled down to no, saying developers will decide how to use the X's power, be it to improve resolution or framerate and then have the system do that regardless of display. Games outputting in 4K will do the aforementioned supersampling for 1080p sets.

Penello also walked me through what an Xbox One X will do for those of us on team 1080p. He promised faster load times, anisotropic filtering, and said that even games that don't get Gears-style Xbox One X enhancement patches could see benefits. If an existing Xbox One game has "variable resolution or variable framerate, they will run at their max," he said. "We made a very concerted effort to say, 'If you don't have a 4K TV there's a bunch of great things Xbox One X will do.'"


It's easy to be sceptical about the Xbox One X, as it was the PS4 Pro before it. Both consoles provide superficial benefits without doing anything that demands you buy them.

Look at it another way, though, and that's a positive. The Xbox One X is a mighty machine, but it doesn't close off the current generation of consoles prematurely. It's not a device that augurs in a whole new line of games that can't be played on the Xbox One you may already own.

These mid-generation enhanced consoles are a new idea, and it's not clear if they sell well. Maybe they at least serve as a deterrent to keep people from switching sides, offering the deep-pocketed loyalist a higher-end console to buy, when they might otherwise use that money on one of the competition's devices.

Whether or not these consoles sell is more the concern of corporations than fans. For people who enjoy games, Xbox One X is simply an additional option. It's a box that will make games look better and maybe run better, and whether that's $US500 ($663) worth of better, it's hard to say. Microsoft isn't showing anything at E3 that makes getting an Xbox One X a no-brainer. And if you really pay attention, you'll notice they're even showing a lot of reasons that sticking with an Xbox One S would be perfectly fine.


Comments

    Wow, I really appreciate this article. Especially given the recent price drop on the S.

    I thought the photo was of a PS4 and an Xbox One S , I had no idea scorpio looked so much like a PS4 at first glance.

    VR support? "We think PC is the right place to be playing with VR right now."

    That surprised me, I thought Scorpio was going to be all over VR to compete with PSVR. Odd.

    It will be interesting to see comparisons of say Forza running on an XBOX One S on a good 1080P TV and the Xbox One X running on a 4K TV side by side. In racing games though, I don't notice the graphics as much as the framerate, so I'd be surprised if I see a difference whilst playing. Whilst watching maybe.

    Good news if you already have an Xbox game library and have a 4KTV.

      I imagine xbox is a bit wary of entering a market that is still in its infancy, see Kinect

      PSVR is probably one of the better mass-consumer headsets, but it's still quite limited by the console hardware. I used to have it but I ended up selling it, because the visual fidelity was pretty limited (although it was pretty cool). It was like looking at a blurry image that never focused properly, with a lack of AA.

      I'd say the real reason MS didn't get into VR this time is because they still lack a solid "Mixed Reality" platform to push. Also they'd be competing with the standard set by Valve/HTC, which still has much more support (with the Rift playing second fiddle).

      VR is entering 8k 120hz territory over the next few seasons..... we have everything so far but the PPI screens

    As someone with a 4k tv and a digital xbox library over 200 strong the X makes sense, for me.

    The S is a great deal on a 4k bluray player that also happens to be able to play x1, 360 and soon original xbox games though.

      4K capability and backwards compatibility with original Xbox games makes me interested. I never got rid of my original Xbox games, and there are some real classics I wouldn't mind going back to experience.

    My XboneS will do fine I think.

    And what is with all this "Most powerful console ever made" bullshit?

    Every generation is the 'most powerful console ever made'.......what a crock.

      ummm.... so no one can ever say its the biggest or greatest or most powerful because they will one day be beaten? that's just stupid.

        The Xbox one wasn't the most powerful and neither was the Xbox One S and the latest Nintendo consoles are never the most powerful.

    So, basically the same differences as between PS4 and Pro but with a larger power gap? I can see why you'd question whether getting a Bonox was worth it, particularly if you didn't have a 4K TV.

    Probably the best article written about the X yet. Finally some pragmatic advice.

    I really just want speed improvements. My mate who has the elite console (with the SSD) has bugger all load times on his games versus me with my External HDD and OG XB1 waiting for the second coming of Christ to get a game going.

    I'm most probably going to get this at launch just because I spend an unhealthy amount of time gaming on my Xbox and I want to have the best possible experience.

    Almost all the best games announced so far are cross platform and This console will play all cross platform games the best.
    If i didn't already own a xbox or ps4, its kind of a no brainer

      That is the big if though isn't it. How big is the market that doesn't already have a console from this gen?

        Very true, but it doesn't look like this generation is ending anytime soon. Cant see a "new" console coming for many years seeing both major players have just, or are about to, release upgraded consoles.

        I Got my xbox on release day almost 4 years ago, im ready to upgrade

    I really don't get the half gen upgrade plan. It's spending a lot for not much return. With Microsoft's push for everything to be on PC and Xbone, wouldn't it just be better for people to throw $650 worth of parts into their PCs?

    Remember how outraged everyone was when the PS3 cost $1000 at launch? Well now we're spending well over $1000 for a full console cycle, just in two installments.

    It's probably because I don't get the whole 4K thing, pretty much anything that's come out since the PS3 has looked amazing to me. Jumping into the highest specs available as soon as they are available doesn't make everything look amazing, it just raises what you consider standard. The sooner the industry can get everyone on to 4k, the sooner they will try to set 8k as the industry standard.

    Look at how slow television technology moved between the 1980s and 2000s, companies made better screens and better formats, but the public weren't ready to move on them, so the industry slowed the their pace.

    I could go on forever about this, since hitting 30 last year, I've seemed to embrace the 'crotchety old man' stereotype when it comes to how face people want technology to move. Slow down, everything's pretty good as is. Plus 16k TVs are only a few years down the road...

      So the distance you need to be from a 16k screen to see a difference will be what, 5 centimetres? :)

      i agree when a saw the PS pro was coming out and scoprio. i got to thinking the same thing Sony and Microsoft want to update every few years. also having to pay for PS Plus or Live is a joke when PC is free. i sold my PS4 and used the money to get a GTX 1070 it cost me $629 to my door and its does everything i want plus more. it supports VR if i want to go there it will also last over 2 years. i have my PC connected to my TV and i have a media keyboard and an a wireless xbox one controller i have not looked back.

      Last edited 14/06/17 8:49 am

    I already have a 4k pc, where's the part when they say play 4k game's in just as high quality settings as a PC?

    Im guessing the next generation isn't coming for a long time then, otherwise the next Xbox now has to make a much bigger leap in power to leave the XB1X behind.

    Maybe there is a sizeable amount of people that felt the xbone is too slow, but I'm fine with it. Things load quickly enough for me and it doesn't look bad.

    This review site doesn't seem essential.

    you still cant chat to more than one person at a time where as on an old ps3 you still can and its free you still havent got this yet, the bad boys stay with the ps because they are bad boys and the nice mommy boys get an xbox because they are nice boys meaning more adults go for the ps because xbox have too many rules about swearing, you could have had a place for adults to burn of steam instead of yes men, if you follow my drift, the way Scotsmen talk with a freedom of the word mate so all the little kids again get an xbox and the adults go pc or ps simply because of the church boy rules, kids are not allowed in pubs for a reason if you follow, lets be honest the net is full of the same people that buy adult talk adult and avoid xbox because its for kids, I like to swear Its part of what an Irishman dose, You can on a ps3 talk to 6 folk on cameras all at the same time with no restriction that`s about the Donald Hump of it mate, It still says kids have xbox and adults have ps you took the Scotsman off the board with your church boy rules, not that they are bothered as Ive said there are other alternatives than xbox and 4k no matter how powerful it is, Adult entertainment is not the same as family entertainment or Quality Time on video chat All youve done is the same old tune its a better picture, for the spoilt kids to play on, when is the adult xbox coming out mate until then I will stick with what works even if its old at least I can say now this is Man time to the kids away and play on your baby box theres a nice boy Daddy has something to say in private to a nice man that thinks his console is a confessional box

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now