Mario Kart 8 Deluxe: The Kotaku Review

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe: The Kotaku Review

Mario Kart 8 is an excellent game. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is even better.

Normally in a situation where a game we’ve reviewed in the past gets an updated version on a new console, we’d simply republish the original review with some notes on any significant differences. The Mario Kart 8 situation is a little different. The original came out on the Nintendo Wii U, a console that tried really hard but was never a huge mainstream success. Conversely, Nintendo is calling the Switch its fastest selling console ever, with more than 2.5 million sold worldwide in under a month. There’s a whole new audience flocking to Nintendo’s new hybrid console, and they’re going to need a racing game to play once they’re finished with all of that Zelda. This is that game.

So welcome, newcomers. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the latest instalment of Nintendo’s long-running series of kart racing games, in which colourful characters from across several different Nintendo properties race through fantastical Nintendo-themed tracks. Winning requires a combination of racing skill and luck, as random power-ups sprinkled throughout the tracks bestow powers and weapons to help even the odds. If you haven’t yet experienced the joy of taking a blue shell to the face inches from the finish line, you’re in for a real treat.

Much of what I wrote in my original Mario Kart 8 review still stands. Nintendo’s prolific kart racing series hadn’t really resonated with me until the Wii U instalment came along, offering arcade style controls much easier to come to grips with than in previous games in the series.

In the past I’ve struggled with Mario Kart driving controls, struggling to grasp the correct timing of the series’ signature drift and boost system. Moments into my first run through the game’s first track, Mario Kart Stadium, I was powersliding around corners like a semi-pro.

Vehicle handling is more intuitive than ever before, and adjusting from a wide-sliding kart to the tight cornering of a motorbike is just a matter of taking a quick test drive around a track. For a relatively novice player the learning curve is incredibly short, which breeds the confidence needed to take on tougher tracks at higher difficulties. Never in my history with the series have I tore through all of the courses (16 new and 16 revamped classics) with such enthusiasm.

Of course my enthusiasm has waned somewhat after three years and countless trips around the same set of courses. Though some minor changes have been made, the game feels completely the same. Or at least it does once you figure out how to turn off Smart Steering, a handy crutch for new players that’s inexplicably enabled by default.

As far as I can tell, the in-race pause menu seems to be the only place to turn the Smart Steering feature off. Update: As pointed out in the comments, you can do it in kart select as well.

You can turn the Smart Steering feature off in the in-race pause menu as well as in kart select.

It’s familiar, but by no means stale, especially now that we can play Mario Kart 8 wherever we want, whenever we want. No longer are we constrained by the signal tether of the Wii U game pad. The Switch’s tablet mode allows us to play Mario Kart 8 all over the damn place. I was playing in a bar the other night during my family’s weekly bar trivia events. We lost. I have no idea why.

From what I can tell from the meagre time I’ve spent playing online in the hours since Mario Kart 8 Deluxe‘s launch, the online multiplayer is just as solid as it’s ever been. I’ve had no problems connecting to a race, though I have encountered problems winning one. Setting up a private room to play with friends makes the Switch’s lack of online communication features painfully apparent, but at least it’s easy to get started once you’re all together.

The original Mario Kart 8‘s online racing was fine, but one aspect of multiplayer fell flat.

The only downside to online multiplayer (and multiplayer in general) was Mario Kart 8‘s Battle Mode. Traditionally held in custom-crafted arenas, the balloon-popping competitive game mode is instead played on normal circuit tracks. Players drive around in circles, hoping to run into someone that’s not driving rapidly in the opposite direction. They hardly do. The tracks are so large and winding they’d be lucky to see another person more than once or twice in a given round. It’s horribly tedious, borderline unplayable.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe‘s biggest improvement comes in its new Battle Mode. Rather than try to shoehorn different game types onto existing tracks, the new version gives players eight brand new arenas to play in.

And instead of just popping each other’s balloons, players are now bombing the living hell out of each other’s balloons in Bob-Omb Blast, desperately trying to keep possession of the titular treasure of Shine Thief, collecting coins in Coin Runners and playing cops and robbers in Renegade Roundup.

With these new additions, Battle Mode has transformed from “borderline unplayable” to all I want to play. I might not be the best racer in the world, but I know a thing or two about tossing bombs at passing karts.

Yeah, I really like the Squid Girl.

Yeah, I really like the Squid Girl.

So while much of Mario Kart 8 remains the same in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, Battle Mode has given me a whole new way to play and enjoy the game. I can’t wait to pick up a couple of extra Joy-Cons so I can play four-player splitscreen on a single tiny tablet.

If you have played Mario Kart 8, don’t expect a lot of major changes outside of Battle Mode. The ability to carry two power-ups at once is nice but doesn’t make a massive difference. The already lush graphics look the same as they ever have to the naked eye, though the Switch tablet display really makes them pop. Mario Kart TV is still a thing, for those who enjoy flipping through highlight reels of past races, and it still isn’t as robust a tool as I would have liked.

If it’s not broke, don’t fix it. Part of the original Mario Kart 8 was broken, and Nintendo fixed it in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, giving an already spectacular game substantial new legs.

As for those of you new to Mario Kart 8, you’re showing up to the party at exactly the right time. We were just about to tap the keg. Leave your kart keys in the basket by the door and get on in here.


  • I think it’s good that the Switch is doing well and I wish all the best for people playing MK8 for the first time, but I’m not buying this again.

    It would have been nice if Ninty offered a discount to people who bought the Wii U title digitally (like me).

    • Agreed. I have a Switch but only a big discount or a shitload more new content would have justified purchasing this for me.

    • And completely ignore all the people who bought it on a disk because the system has no storage room at all for games. Unrelated: why are people buying this console in droves? So far we have Zelda and a MK8 rehash, which are both WiiU games………

      • Gamers grow up and have kids. Trust me, nothing is as good for young children and more to the point…….parents playing with young children, than Nintendo games.

        At least that is why I have and am loving the Switch.

        My son and I have devoured BOTW together and will forever cherish memories forged from that game.

        We are currently playing Mario Kart as a family.

      • Nobody (By which I mean I did not) buy a WiiU, mainly because it didn’t have a new Zelda on it. Then I would not spend almost the same money (the WiiU is still $429) for a console on its last legs.

        I hope they re-release all the WiiU games. Like Project Zero & Xenoblade Chronicles X.

        • I had no idea on the WiiU pricing, I picked mine up for 289 with Mario Kart and a download code for a free game which I used for The New Super Mario Bros.

      • Plenty of storage for a couple of games. If you want to go all digital you can expand it. No reason to increase the base cost for the people that are never going to buy digital. Never had to expand on my Wii U.

        People are buying it because they want to play it portable? People have commutes, only 1 TV and lunch breaks. All great times to play. Also looks like a return to form for Nintendo and loads of people who didn’t get a Wii U are jumping in.

        Also it’s going to have Splatoon2 😀

        • Depending on the game you want to play, you could if you found the right battery for it.

    • that makes total sense, unless you want a version you can play anywhere, anytime.

      I personally didnt pick it up for the WiiU and im LOVING it on the switch.

  • I was an early adopter of the Wii U but traded it in last year for a Switch pre-order.

    I’m not upset about paying the price of admission again for MK8. The game is essentially the same I guess but it definitely does look a lot better (if that was possible). It;s truly amazing how the Switch can run a game like this….and in 4 player!! One can never say they don’t get enough value for money out of a Mario Kart purchase really. Especially if you have kids.

    Battle mode is a real treat and was sorely missed from the original game.

  • As soon as this game was announced I traded in my WiiU copy towards my Switch preorder to at least negate some of the cost of re-buying it.

    But as a train commuter, being able to take Mario Kart 8 portable is a huge bonus because it’s the best Mario Kart available and the perfect thing for a quick play when you have nothing else going on.

    I just hope they make more DLC tracks for it, I’d like to see more classic tracks revamped.

  • The battle mode makes it a worthwhile purchase for us. Will get months and months of use out it with friends and family.

Show more comments

Comments are closed.

Log in to comment on this story!