Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

You’re probably wondering what’s taking Valve, a company with nigh-infinite resources, forever to make Half-Life 2: Episode 3. Or you’ve given up on that and you believe it’s going to be called Half-Life 3. The sad truth is that we will probably never see Half-Life 3 from Valve, and for one very good reason: its most important character is dead.

“But, Doc,” I hear you saying, “Gordon Freeman is alive and well!” While this is true, I have another shocking revelation to make: Gordon Freeman is not the most important person in Half-Life! Incredible but true.

So, wait, let me back up and talk about Half-Life, which is the third-greatest shooter of all time after Halo: Combat Evolved and Quake, which are tied for first place. Half-Life’s greatness comes from two distinct elements. The first, which everyone has talked about since it was released 18 years ago, is how Half-Life feels real. At the time, it was an incredible feat, and all these years later, it still is. Despite the ageing graphics, my journeys through Black Mesa always feel as real and vibrant as they did the day I first played Half-Life, back in 2007.

The other, more important element is the way Half-Life motivates you. See, one of the things that enhanced the realism were the game’s other characters. Sure, they were two-dimensional stick figures, but they showed up when it mattered. As the game opens, they’re kind of mean to you; you get the sense that people resent Gordon’s presence. It characterises Gordon too: he seems to be perpetually late, and nobody seems to value his skills all that much — his job amounts to “push a cart into a very dangerous energy beam.” Apparently, they didn’t want to risk anyone else doing it, because they made everyone wait until he showed up to do it.

Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

As Half-Life progresses, people bestow upon you more and more responsibility. Go get help. Kill the giant monster. Go meet the scientists at the Lambda Complex. By the time you get there, the scientists have gone from “ugh, Gordon,” to “Gordon, we’ve been watching you on the monitors, and we believe in you.”

What’s great about this is how it all feels earned. Gordon has gone from a dope nobody likes to a guy who, through the experiences in the game itself, is a hardcore survivor and all around action hero. It’s silent character development, and a huge aspect of Half-Life’s appeal. Gordon’s journey isn’t just geographical, it’s emotional.

Half-Life 2 is terrible. Within minutes, other characters are fangirling over you, like they knew you or something. Why? Because you left a secret base shortly before a nuclear explosion. Seriously, there were no witnesses to your defeat of the Nihilanth at the end of Half-Life, and even if there were, they should, reasonably, object to what you did, because in Half-Life 2, apparently the Nihilanth wasn’t so much a bad guy as a rebel against the Combine, the actual bad guys in the Half-Life 2 universe.

We could get into a whole big thing about why this is a bad decision, from game design to lore perspectives, but that would be an article the length of a novel, and nobody has time for that.

Instead, let’s talk about Eli Vance. The first real objective you receive in Half-Life 2 is to go meet Eli at Black Mesa East. Why? Because Eli is the Resistance leader, and he will tell you why you’re here. So, ok, Eli’s an important bigwig in the Resistance, but does that really make him the most important character?


Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

See, Half-Life 2 uses Eli as a tool. First, you go to Black Mesa East to find out Why You Are Here. Then, when Black Mesa East is attacked (no one in the Resistance assumes that you, the new guy, might have had something to do with it), Eli is taken, and your next goal is… to get out of Ravenholm, find the Resistance, and go rescue Eli. This time, he’s in a prison called Nova Prospekt. Cool, so you set out across the beach to go get Eli back.

When you get to Nova Prospekt, you watch as Judith Mossman, the rebel traitor, kidnaps Eli. Just to be clear, this is the third time you chase after Eli. Only this time, the teleporter malfunctions, and you don’t just jump through space, you jump through time. When your teleport ends, you find yourself something like two weeks in the future, and the rebellion has started.

The reason for this?

Because “Gordon Freeman,” if that is his name, “disappeared with Alyx, Judith, and Eli.”

Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

So. Let me get this straight. A 27 year-old guy shows up almost 20 years after he disappeared, without having aged, and his appearance heralds an attack on the Resistance base that sees its most important member, daughter, and assistant kidnapped. Nobody knows Judith is a traitor, because only you, Alyx, and Eli, who were all in Nova Prospekt know this. Most rebels, I’m betting, are pretty paranoid, which is what’s kept them alive for so long.

Most paranoid people I know would see all the evidence and assume this “Gordon Freeman” character is an impostor whose sole purpose was to destroy the Rebellion’s leadership.

The characters in Half-Life 2 decide that everyone’s disappearance is a signal to attack, so they attack. Without you. They’ve been carrying on a war against the Combine while you were gone. Apparently they could have done this without you — or any of their leadership, really — so there seems to be no clear motive for attacking at this juncture rather than at any other, and they seem to be doing a pretty good job on their own.

Your job, of course, is to rescue Eli.

So you rush to the top of the tower, get to Eli, defeat the bad guy, and… the game freezes.

It picks up again in Half-Life 2: Episode 1, which comes in two halves. The first half is about a bunch of boring puzzles starring energy balls. Your motive? Delay the self-destruction of the Citadel, allowing Eli and friends to escape the city. The second half is about you getting to a train and fleeing the city before the Citadel explodes and kills everyone. That and plugging holes to stop those irritating ant-lions from spawning.

Half-Life 2: Episode 2 is broken up into three sections. In the first section, you save Eli’s daughter. In the second section, you escort Eli’s daughter to Eli. In the third section, you attempt to defend Eli, who promises to finally tell you what he was going to tell you, presumably, after you toyed with the gravity gun that was something like twelve years ago.


Why Half-Life 2 Doesn’t Live Up To Its Predecessor

So, to recap: Half-Life was about you proving yourself to other people, a personal journey as you attempted to escape from a bad case of Science Gone Wrong and Government Coverups. Half-Life 2 was about spending all your time trying to get to Eli while everyone masturbates your ego, presumably to disguise the fact that you’re nothing but a glorified errand boy, whose only purpose is to do things that help Eli out, and then the guy just straight up DIES on you, and now you’re stuck.

You know what? I think the problem is that Valve never really knew why you were there. I think they never really had anything beyond “go fight some Combine.” Most narratives set up their conflicts pretty fast. Star Wars took a little while to get to the Death Star, but the first movie was about character growth and stopping the Empire from killing everyone with the Death Star. Half-Life 2 doesn’t have any of that. Half-Life did. It just strings you along while everyone tells you about what a great guy you are the entire time.

Half-Life is one of the greatest games of all time, because it made you earn your place. Half-Life 2 isn’t, because it doesn’t.

There are plenty of other reasons for it; ex-Valve employees have complained about the studio’s structure. Viktor Antonov, the art designer who made Half-Life 2 so distinct and went on to help create Dishonored, said that Valve stopped making AAA games. I’ve heard other, similar statements from time to time.

But at the end of the day, we’ll never see Half-Life 3 because Eli Vance is Princess Peach. And now that Princess Peach is dead, there’s no one left for Mario to save.


  • Couldn’t really take this seriously after your opening gambit was:

    “Half-Life, which is the third-greatest shooter of all time after Halo: Combat Evolved…”

  • OK, I also prefer Half-Life to HL2, I also think killing Eli in episode 2 was a mistake and I also don’t like how characters worship Freeman in HL2 – but really?

    How can you simultaneously argue HL2 doesn’t live up to Half-Life and that Eli is the most important character in the franchise at the same time? The only game he wasn’t actually in (no, retcon-ing him in doesn’t count) was Half-Life, the game you clearly think trumps the others.

    That aside though – no, Eli wasn’t the most important character, the G-man is. His influence and control over Eli and Alyx is very much a part of the narrative of 2 and the episodes, and definitely in HL: Alyx (which it seems you haven’t played? Maybe you should?) but every other character, other than the Nihilanth and arguably the Vortigaunts are just pawns in a game they don’t understand. It’s true Gordon Freeman doesn’t matter, but that was always deliberately stressed by the G-man. Consider the false choice at the end of Half-Life – you work for him or you die. You have no agency, you have no control over what happens in the narrative. He’s always opening doors and closing others, guiding Freeman through a particular path for reasons you are never told. For all its faults the ending of Half-Life 2 was very much about disempowering you and reminding you of the G-man’s importance – you destroy the citadel and the moment you do the G-man has no use for you, taking you away from the struggles of the resistance movement to be brought out again when whoever or whatever employs the G-man asks for some help again.

    I kind of agree with most of your points individually, but they don’t add up at all, and I sort of question whether you actually understood the narrative of Half-Life at all. Also you should probably play Alyx. Just saying.

    • Ah, it’s a repost. That explains the lack of a mention of Alyx, but I stand behind my other points.

  • I really didn’t enjoy HL2 or get engaged with it, partially for the reasons in this article.

    In the first one, I was just some guy, the world had gone to crap and I was forced to creep around and try and find my way out. My skills in the game developed alongside the character development and the whole thing just had me fully engaged.
    The moment in the vents when the bullet holes started blowing through, with the light streaming in, getting closer to me while I panicked backwards was one of my favourite moments in a game ever.
    The varied locations, crawling through a vent, coming down that giant lift, heading outside and bringing down a chopper. It was both small and epic, and really felt like the stakes were high, coupled with trying to sort out WTF was going on.
    I was a scientist with a good survival instinct, that always felt like, “I’m probably not going to make this” and not having the firepower to be Duke Nukem and just blaze my way through. The story and pacing were good, the feels were real and the shock and some guilt, of also having to fight human troops, who would flank you, really heightened the whole experience.

    HL2 to me just felt like being tasked. Run over here for reasons. Basically just either sprinted on an airboat thing or a vehicle as fast as possible through fairly unimaginative backdrops with no real goal other than get there fast. That the character would meet you there. Get there, meet up with the character and immediately just be told to go somewhere else. Rinse and repeat.
    Why couldn’t I just go with that character and have an adventure, it always felt like everyone else was doing the important stuff and I was just the ‘driver’, even though everyone seemed constantly in awe of me, for reasons that made no sense at all.

    The humanoid potagonists all had masks and were faceless fodder, it just wasn’t engaging. It was the most disappointing sequel to me, and I really had high hopes that Hl3 would bring it back around, but it never came. I miss shooters with a story, and with a protagonist that starts of not all that powerful and that there is a bit of mystery as to what was happening.

  • A new type of zombie. Give it a new headline then use exactly the same copy. Hopefully no one will notice.

    Argument was wrong then and is wrong now. Hope no one got paid for this crap.

Show more comments

Log in to comment on this story!