My Day With The New SimCity

Last week, I headed over to Maxis headquarters in Emeryville to spend a big chunk of time playing SimCity. I decided that rather than attempt to list all of the features of a game this dense, I'd just keep a journal of my day. So that's what I did. Who's ready for some hot city-planning action?

Many of the screenshots in this article are actually from the city I made while I was there (née "Kotakuville"), but as I couldn't get all of the images I took, a few are stock screengrabs that EA sent over. Those'll be designated, though the differences are pretty clear. The version of the game I played was near to complete but still had some bugs, and the final version is available for purchase on March 5.

Here we go. Hope I don't talk about food/Adam Sessler/Fire Emblem too much.

Tuesday, January 15, 2013

8.54am Iam still in my apartment, and this preview session starts soon. I'm IMing with Jason Schreier about Fire Emblem: Awakening, which we've both been playing. I've been having a hard time not comparing everything to Fire Emblem lately. The Dead Island severed torso thing is happening, which is proving to be a distraction. Also, I have to pay rent on my way to the train station.

8.57am I make a joke to Jason about how I'm including our IM conversation in my journal. He says, "hahaha. excellent. meta."

Time Passes…

10.30am I arrive at Maxis. I'm running a bit late, but thankfully they still haven't gotten started. I head into a boardroom where they've lined up a bunch of computers for us to play. The usual press folks are here.

10.39am Maxis general manager Lucy Bradshaw and SimCity creative director Ocean Quigley come out to introduce the game. They seem genuinely happy to have us here, and proud of what Maxis has put together. I'm sitting at the end of a long table full of reporters, which feels exciting. I'm like the chairman, check it out:

Well-known video game pundit Adam Sessler is sitting to my right. In the interest of Objectify a Male Tech Writer Day, I'll add that I met him for the first time that day, and he seems like a lovely man. He was wearing a snappy hat.

10.41am They show us a splashy intro video of the game. The audio is clipping, and it is kind of intense.

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Is this intro video cooler than Fire Emblem: Awakening? No.

10.43am The press materials here say I get to take 10 screenshots. I'm such a screenshot shotgunner, I'm a little bit worried I'll get too excited.

10.44am Lead producer Kip Katsarelis gets up to give us tips about how to play. If we want, we'll have 5-6 hours to play SimCity today, which he mentions is a "rushed" experience. I'm not sure I'll be able to play for that many hours at once, but we'll see.

10.45am The music that's playing for Katsarelis' demo is quite nice. Chris Tilton did this music for this game. Very soothing.

10.46am The PR guy steps in and turns the demo music down. Boo, PR guy!

10.47am Just watching Katsarelis use the road-making tool in his demo makes it clear that I'm not going to learn much about this game even if I take all 6 hours. There's a lot here. So many variations, just on the road tool! Arced roads, straight roads, and all these different road types. And my god, so many menus. This is a Stephen Totilo dream-game.

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Is this demo more interesting than Fire Emblem: Awakening? No, but this is actually pretty cool. I'm looking forward to playing this game.

10.51am I had forgotten that they call things you drop on the map "Ploppables". Ew.

Time to Start Playing

10.51am Time to start playing. I open up a tutorial called "Getting Started".

10.53am Adam Sessler's phone vibrates. He has gotten a text message.

10.55am The tutorial involves helping the town connect with the outside world. I tried to connect a road to the highway running down the side of my empty pasture, but I failed, somehow. My road just got... stuck... and there doesn't appear to be a way to get out of the basic road tool or use the bulldozer (?), this being a tutorial. Slight panic sets in. Why does this always happen to me at these events?

10.58am I have made peace with the fact that somehow, I failed the tutorial. I built a road out to the highway, and it built "wrong". So, I wound up stuck with no a crazy misplaced ramp jutting out, with no way to bulldoze anything. This does not bode well. For me, I mean, not for the game. I wound up out in the menus and was embarrassed about asking a PR person for help, so I thought I'd just dive into a full game. So. Full game! Who needs tutorials anyway?

11am Wow, I started a new city and two minutes later, it looks like this:

11.01am Just kidding. That's a press screenshot. In reality, I have located the bulldozer. Feelin' pretty good about that.

11.03am I have decided that whatever town I make will be called "Kotakuville", and the roads will form a giant K. Guess what else starts with K? My name. Oh, yeah. I am Ozymandias.

11.05am I've begun zoning different areas for industrial, commercial and residential. Everything is tied to the roads this time — you can't just go zone random land that isn't on a road. That makes transportation much more of an artery of the city, and makes it simpler to place your zones in places where you can easily supply them. I believe there are different sounds for each of the three main SimCity zones — for example, for industrial, it makes a metallic sound. I think this is very neat.

11.05am Kotakuville will rely on oil power. Let's see how this goes.

11.06am It just started raining! In the game, I mean.

11.07am My city is broke. Not brokEN, as in, "Damn, your city is BROKE". But like, we have no money. I'm going to try passing a bond measure, because I don't want to raise taxes, because I need to be liked.

11.08am My city needed water, so I bulldozed some houses and dropped a water plant where they used to be. Sorry, folks.

11.09am Having some fairly extreme graphical slowdown on my computer with the road-building tool. No idea what kind of PC this is, but it seems pretty beefy. Huh. This isn't the final version of the game or anything, so there are liable to still be bugs and the like. This must be one of them.

11.11am Placed my city hall up at the top of the "K". Away from the plebes.

11.11am Now that I have a city hall, I've been invited to formally name my city. Hello, Kotakuville!

11.16am I try to find someone to ask how to take a screenshot. Also, I got a bear claw. It's pretty good! There was almost no coffee left. I can take a screenshot with the "C" key. Because of course, using F12 would be way too… steamy.

11.18am Wrapping up the bear claw.

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Was this bear claw more nourishing than Fire Emblem: Awakening? Not emotionally, but perhaps nutritionally.

Burning Sensations, Server Woes

11.21am Uh oh, my city has an abandoned building with no power. I'm… not sure what to do about it. Likely the first of many bad signs.

11.21am There's a taqueria in my commercial district called "Burning Sensations". That is a terrible name for a Taqueria. Sheesh, residents of Kotakuville.

11.23am Our preview session appears to be having server issues, which is making it difficult for some people to play. Hmm. My game is still OK.

11.25am My factories all have funny names. "Hair Glue Factory". "Kensherr Magnetrons". "Donut Dough Industries". Kotakuville is a centre of industry!

11.30am They're showing us another video. While they're doing that, they're also shutting down all of our games to cycle the server, which will theoretically fix the server issues some people are having. Again, huh. This does not bode well for a game where whenever they turn off the servers, every person in the world has to stop playing.

11.33am This demo is about all of the different ways you can build an identity for your city. How you can add "personality" and culture to you city. I wonder if you have too much culture, if you can get SimHipsters? I feel like probably not.

11.37am We are still not playing the game, because the servers are still down. The launch of this game may well be pretty interesting! And by "interesting" I mean "possibly a disaster". Note that I write this entry at 11.37am. THIRTY SEVEN. Coincidence? I THINK NOT

11.40am Looks like they've got the servers up now. Yup, servers are back up.

Back up and Running

11.41am Splines have been reticulated on Kotakuville. Back to it.

11.42am PR seems audibly relieved that we didn't lose Kotakuville. Well. I'm glad too!

11.45am Spent a while messing around with roads. Accidentally bulldozed a bunch of businesses. Sorry, guys. I'm struck by how comparatively small my city is, compared with past SimCity games. I haven't filled my area, but I can see the boundaries. I guess this is as big as a city gets?

11.47am I've decided to build up a commercial district to the west of the K. The grid-building is a little different, since the game is more fluid than its predecessors. They give you visible guidelines to build your roads, which is a cool approach. Every time you start to lay road, these dotted lines appear to show you where you could put them to keep them symmetrical. It's flexible and seems to work pretty well.

11.51am Oh dear, my city hasn't had sewage this entire time. More like Stinkville 1.0, amiright?

11.51am When I try to drop a sewage outflow pipe, it tells me I "must plop on a snap point!" Ew, again! Because sewage!

11.53am I still have a 68 per cent approval rating, despite the fact that no one in my city has had working plumbing since they moved here. This must be what Obama feels like!

11.54am I paused it to do some zoning, and the rain paused in midair. Neat.

11.55am Raised taxes to 10 per cent. Hope this doesn't cause an occupy movement.

Plains, Trains and Power Supplies

11.55am The power just blew! In the Maxis buildings, I mean. Not in the game. All of our computers just went down. Hmm, no end of technical problems here, i guess. Then again, string together this many PCs, and you're bound to have some power issues.

12.01pm It has been suggested that my Macbook is sucking too much power and causing the crash. This seems unlikely, but I may have to plug in somewhere else. I felt this was worth noting. Now I feel like everyone is looking at me.

12.06pm Took a minute to tweet about this whole Deep Silver severed torso thing, which is happening today, but which most of you will probably have forgotten about by the time the embargo for this preview lifts. But hey, let's remember for a minute. The torso thing! It's probably been replaced in the collective consciousness by some new offence, but man, that was pretty f**king grim!

12.07pm Kotakuville is still chugging along after the power outage. I lost some of my recent zoning, but that's it. Actually, I may not have even lost that. At least now we know that if you lose power while playing, you own't really lose progress.

12.07pm Everyone else here has bigger monitors than I do. Maybe their HUGE MONITORS are what's sucking power. Not my laptop. Jeez.

12.07pm Oh, turns out I didn't lose any progress. Nice.

This must be what Obama feels like!

12.08pm City Hall has given me an incentive to hit a population goal and incorporate into a small city. It looks like "incentives" are little mini-goals that help you branch out and try to hit new waypoints.

12.09pm Music update: The music changes when you pause it, and goes through a filter. But as far as I can tell, it doesn't do that cool layering thing with the camera-zoom that it was doing in the last demo.

12.11pm Power went down again. They made me unplug my laptop.

12.13pm Still waiting on reboot.

12.15pm Tara Long from Revision3 is the only one who got a computer that isn't on this circuit, so she's been playing uninterrupted. Taraaaaaaa! *shakes fist*

12.30pm Power problems resolved. OK, hopefully the game won't crash anymore.

Time to Take Out The Trash

12.30pm Now that I've seen it a bunch of times, I can confirm that the SimCity menu is... pretty clean-looking.

12.33pm Sewage has been taken care of. Whew. OK, here's what Kotakuville looks like now.

12.38pm A little while with no updates. I expanded the roads to the southeast, and did a tutorial about the budget panel. A good sign that I just sort of got into it for a while. I can tell it's going to take a few revisions to get this thing right. I bet Kotakuville 4.0 will be pretty good.

12.40pm Raised taxes again. Sorry everyone. I've taken out two bonds, which was probably a bad call, in retrospect.

12.44pm I've been notified that "Air pollution just drifted in from outside the city." Hmm. I'm not sure what to do about it, so I move on.

12.49pm I'm doing pretty well. Getting some tips from another developer, dropped a hospital, and now have 72,000 simoleons in the bank. Not bad.

12.51pm Fire! We have a fire. Yikes. Though also: Hooray! This is sort of a SimCity milestone. Now to do what all mayors do when there's a fire: quickly build a fire department.

12.52pm Ocean Quigley just came by to show me the camera-filters. There are a few different colour-filters you can use to look at your city. You can watch 'em in the video Chris put together to the side there. They're neat. Quigley says it can be jarring to go back to the other way of doing things. I put on "soft" and then "vintage" and find I do like how it makes my city look. Really, even on my kind of janky monitor, this is a lovely-looking game.

12.55pm I've somehow wound up wandering into the neighbouring area of Norwich Hills, which looks like a second whole city area. (I'll explain this more later.)

1.22pm Lengthy pause from updates. I did a lot of things recently. I ate some Chipotle! Will you believe me if I tell you that as far as I know, that was the first Chipotle I've ever had in my life? Because it was. Hmm. It wasn't half bad. I see why people go there when it's the only option. I don't know if it's as good as "Burning Sensation", but then, what is?

How The Multi-City Setup Works

Longer Update: My PR helper Charlie showed me a lot about the way the game scales, and some of how the multiplayer works. It's pretty cool. Basically, the game exists on three levels: Cities, Regions, and the worldwide economy. A region can hold a number of cities, and any player online can control any city. Regions have anywhere from three to 16 city-spaces, which are pre-designed. (Later, Katsarelis confirms to me that you can't terraform like in past SimCity games — the city-spaces are all pre-made.) Each region also has a "Great Works Site", which can have something mega, like an Arcology or an international airport or a space centre. Each one of those has an impact on every city in the region, bringing in money, or tourists, or other sorts of benefits.

So, like I was noticing, the cities themselves are pretty small — you can't build some huge Dredd-esque Megacity One. That makes the game more complex. I can tell that once I've built a few cities, it'll get a lot easier to plan out how I'm going to do what I'm doing. The basic idea is to have one city be residential/commercial, one city commercial with some industrial, and one city industrial. People will live in the residential city and commute to the industrial or commercial cities to work. Of course, your other cities will influence one another, so you'll start getting pollution runoff from one city, or have your residents go to the industrial city to work. And your friends can take over (or build) your neighbouring cities, too. I get it, and I like it. It's very different from past SimCity games, of course.

Kotakuville, meanwhile, is very much in the awkward, possibly terminal adolescence of the "First SimCity City". Heading over to Maxis employees' regions to look at established cities, I'm now aware of just how smart you can be with your layout, and how you can maximise the limited geography to get the most out of a city. Here is a press screenshot that gives you a sense of what I'm talking about:

1.28pm I've been writing all of this with the SimCity music going in my ears, and I have to say, this is some great music to write to. Good show, Tilton. The tick-tock, pizzicato strings have got me in a rhythm. Might have try working to this music in general.

Multiplayer

1.29pm OK where was I? Right, multiplayer. So the way multiplayer works is, you can invite friends to come and set up shop in cities anywhere in your region. (Or in the blank areas where a city could be. See here:

Once they come in and run one of your cities, there's no going back — if they mess up your city, it's messed up for good. The idea will be, then, that you'll be playing on a server next to people, which will be a different sort of experience than the one I've been having so far.

1.33pm Kip is going to walk us through multiplayer. This is most of the stuff I just talked about. He says that after 4-6 hours, players are going to want to step out and make another city. He's going into how you can share services from city to city around your region, gift money and resources to one another, send firefighters and police, etc.

1.43pm I pipe up to ask Kip about a 16-City map. He obliges and loads one up for us. It's much, much bigger than what we were working with, but very cool. Quite big! Loading the map is taking quite a while, since the game still isn't quite finished.

1.53pm Back to Kotakuville. I keep going for the undo button once I accidentally lay a road incorrectly . In this game, there is no undo. There is only Bulldozer.

1.57pm Kotakuville looks quite nice at night. I... didn't get any screenshots of it. Sorry. You'll have to take my word for it. Oh ok, here's a press screenshot:

1.58pm This soundtrack is very much a fan of the lydian mode. Points off for over-reliance on Lydian, Tilton! There are other ways to conjure "airy and thoughtful!"

1.59pm JK that's not really fair, I mean I really like lydian too

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Is this the lydian mode better than Fire Emblem: Awakening? Tough call. There is some lydian IN Fire Emblem: Awakening, so they're kind of related, even. Jury is out on this one.

2.01pm My people are protesting. Too many deaths per day in my city! What a drag. I should probably upgrade my clinics.

2.02pm I zoomed in on a sick sim walking down the street, puking everywhere. It's not as horrifying as it sounds. He's going to the hospital, which is pretty far away.

2.03pm I've gotten a few achievements. "Bad News, Creeps" for having my police catch a criminal, and "Sand through my fingers", for spending expenses over $US5,000 per month. I also got "Awfulest Mayor Ever!", which is an achievement for having an approval rating below 10 per cent. Whoops. When did I get that award? (He asked, like every awful mayor ever.)

2.05pm I upgraded my clinic with an add-on for an ambulance.

2.08pm Well, Kotakuville is starting to look pretty nice.

2.10pm Again my city burns. And there's nothing I can do. Boo. To illustrate what's going on, albeit in a much grander, more successful city, here is another official press screenshot:

2.12pm Some of my factories are closing because there "aren't enough places to ship freight". I gotta say, I get the sense playing this game that there is an entirely new feel to the way all the systems interlock. It's cool, though overwhelming at the moment.

2.13pm Good example of a system that isn't overwhelming: I built a school, but then had to build school bus stops to go to my various neighbourhoods. It's pretty cool, how it works — very intuitive. As you place stops, the streets light up green; you have to get all the streets where people live to light up green. Here's an example of a similar thing with a clinic:

2.15pm Having one of those SimCity moments where I think I'm doing well, but as it turns out, my city is this close to being abandoned. I don't believe that's happening, but you never know.

Ghost Towns

2.16pm Speaking of that, one cool thing is that you can just "Abandon" a city or region, and other people can "find" it and start playing it. Could well be we'll start to get a raft of cool, weird abandoned cities, and no one will know who made them. I like that idea. It's sort of like Jason Rohrer's awesome "Chain World" Minecraft experiment.

2.17pm Time to make a second city. Kotakuville can cruise for a while and earn money.

2.19pm In two minutes, I seem to have burned through my neighbouring town's budget building a second city that is entirely roads and a coal power plant. This is going to generate revenue? … OK.

2.26pm Since we're meant to be messing around with multiplayer, I'm now connected to everyone else, and have been informed that someone has come to my city to take a look at it. That's something you can do with any public city. It's of course possible to make your city or region private.

2.39pm I got some coffee! I realised that I hadn't had much coffee today.

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Is this coffee better than Fire Emblem: Awakening? Right now, yes.

2.43pm The overhead viewing angle is pretty cool:

2.45pm Whoops, just dropped a dump into my residential area.

2.46pm Aaaand, read over that last entry and realised how it reads, decided to keep it in, since it is sort of what i did, actually.

2.50pm My cops are not keeping up with crime in the city, I've been told. I'm always so bad at the SimCity balancing act at first.

Plumbing

2.53pm I've fixed my water system. Fun to watch water pump out to houses, and have their angry red water-taps vanish as they become hydrated. People are like crops.

2.58pm I'm focusing on figuring out how transit works; there are so many different kinds of roads, and you can upgrade and downgrade roads depending on what you need.

3pm Everyone must be escorted to the bathroom. Towel-service jokes are being made. This is s.o.p. for a game studio visit, by the way.

3.05pm I'm pretty much stepping back from active SimCity at this point, doing the thing where you leave your city to run without you for a bit and build up some money. This is definitely one of the things I like about SimCity; it allows you to take breaks while still making progress.

FIRE EMBLEM TEST: Is taking a break from SimCity better than Fire Emblem: Awakening? No. SUB-TEST: Can you play Fire Emblem: Awakening while allowing your SimCity city to build up money over time? YES YOU CAN

(Am I going to do that now? No, because that would be rude.)

3.08pm It's a little thing, but when the sun moves in the game, the shadows of the buildings move, too. It's very nice-looking.

3.08pm Filter update: I have gotten very used to the "Vintage" filter I have on everything.

3.13pm I'm a bit SimCity'd out. Kip is going to talk to us about multiplayer again, which is all well and good, but I've seen as much as I can see for now. I'm going to talk to him, then go home, I think.

So here we have it; this is where Kotakuville wound up:

Overall Impressions

The SimCity beta will start this weekend, so if you can get in, you can relive my first hour over and over. While I was at Maxis, I spoke with Katsarelis about a bunch of interesting stuff relating to the game and what I played, so I'll have that on Kotaku soon.

My overall sense of SimCity is that it is faithful to the general feel and flow of past SimCity games but dramatically different in several ways. It's a lovely-looking game that is fun to interact with; Maxis has achieved their goal on that front. I enjoyed using it, moment-to-moment. The other key difference is more sweeping, and it stems from the fact that you can't save your game, not in the traditional sense. Specifically, you can't save a copy of your game, then save in a new slot if you want to preserve the version you just saved. There's a sense of forward momentum to everything, and I can see how playing the game could start to feel like writing in the sand.

Everything is a bit ephemeral, which can be freeing, but over the long term, it might make it harder to get too invested in your cities. You can't back up a version of your work in order to preserve a moment in time, or download famous cities that your friends have re-created. It really is different from past SimCity games in that way, especially when you combine that with the new game's always-online ecosystem. This SimCity is happening in the present-tense. I'm not at all ready to say it's a bad thing, because the game I played was vibrant, interesting, and fun. But it certainly is different.

tiny family no plumbing, but hey, OK burning sensations


Comments

    Seriously 0 fucks given for fire emblem. What an unusual point of reference for a Sim City game.

    My interest was killed at always-online. I'd have loved if I could play it offline just like any SimCity before, but the triple hurdle of EA, Origin and always-online....

    Nope.

      The way I see it and they way I think they're marketing it, is that it's an MMO-type game. You can play by yourself, or play with others. You do that in MMO's without worrying about an "always-on" connection.

        More's the pity.

        The MMO city building scene is already filled with 'villes, you'd think the city building game would get some love... I mean there's a giant gap in the market, such as it is. I always hear mixed messages about the Cities stuff so I never bothered, and the other closest thing, Anno, is a completely different game.

        A shrug of the shoulders, and the knowledge that EA is on hand to screw things up, as usual.

        Yeah, but this is basically just the same thing blizzard did with diablo 3. It's pretty transparent.

      Always on?
      Pass, or ill pirate a cracked version thats offline.
      I really, really wonder when the cancer at EA wakes up to people HATE always online rubbish.

    As long as it looks nothing like The Sims.

    Sick of hearing about SimCity. I just want to play SimCity. Give me SimCity, god damn it! GIMME! NOW!

    its brilliant played 3 hours now

      Lucky. I wasn't fortunate enough to be granted beta access. Bastards.

        You're not missing a huge amount... you're given "1 hour" to play your city.
        After this, you're redirected to the pre-order page.... I don't think EA understands what a "closed beta" is supposed to be.
        That said, the game *is* enjoyable and I am looking forward to release.

    I wanted to want this. I have a soft spot for city builders.

    Cities XL remains one of my faves. It isn't anything to rave about in visual terms compared to Sim City but once you add a UI mod and the Realistic Highways 2.0 mod, Cities XL becomes a free builder with heaps of options and a pretty neat globe to create cities at will offline.

    There's far to much reliance on online play and social integration. Not that it doesn't belong, just not in place of a "free to enjoy" single player games. This is the main reason I will avoid Sim City unless on the very cheap or sly. I prefer the option of online play as I don't spend the majority of my time playing with others socially.

    Maxis may have created an absolute gem but that means nothing when I have so many restrictions limiting how I play.

    Why Sim City? Just why?

      so many restrictions limiting how I play.

      But there's really just one requirement/restriction: be connected to the internet.

        -You must be online
        -You must play with other people
        -EA's servers must be online
        -You can't save copies of cities as keepsakes or to try something risky, or to just burn it all down/
        That's 4 restrictions and I'm not even thinking hard about it.

          You don't have to play with other people, you can claim a region all for yourself and never see another person.

          I have a dodgy connection here and I did not notice any problems playing simcity, Authentication took 2 seconds then I was playing within a few minutes.

      I wanted to want this.

      @ashley yea me too. far too many dubious decisions from ea have definitely killed any desire i have to play this game. im far more disappointed than i thought i would be able that fact too. =[

      Last edited 27/01/13 10:42 am

    Sounds like an interesting game, which is too bad - since Diablo 3, 'always online' is a dealbreaker for me.

    This was meant to be my new train game for to and from work. No internet on my train so EA screwed me out of that. I can actually relive the disappointment I felt when I first read always on DRM and I watched my anticipation die.

    Planning on pirating are we? I see no problems with always online these days especially since most people have broadband at home that is always on anyway. I've got this game pre-ordered! :-) Really looking forward to it. Thanks for the rad review.

Join the discussion!

Trending Stories Right Now